Officiating getting worse because of VAR - Shearer
Image: BBC

Officiating getting worse because of VAR - Shearer

21 March, 2026.Sports.1 sources

Key Takeaways

  • Alan Shearer says refereeing standards are the worst in a long time due to VAR.
  • VAR use linked to more perceived incorrect officiating decisions in the Premier League.
  • Debate around VAR continues; weekends dominated by officiating controversy in the Premier League.

Shearer critique of VAR

The comments come as VAR again dominated discussion after Friday's match between Bournemouth and Manchester United.

Image from BBC
BBCBBC

In-match incidents and inconsistency

Maguire's red card followed a foul on Evanilson in the box during a 2-1 lead late in the game.

Diallo was denied a penalty for a similar incident at the other end ten minutes earlier.

Image from BBC
BBCBBC

Carrick described the inconsistency as baffling and questioned how one decision could be given and another not.

VAR debate and governance

A summer meeting with UEFA will discuss how VAR is used across Europe's top leagues.

In 2024, Wolves submitted a resolution to the Premier League about VAR, and clubs voted to keep it, arguing scrapping could yield about 100 more incorrect decisions per season.

Selective memory and statistics

Clubs tend to remember decisions that go against them while forgetting times they benefited from VAR.

VAR interventions are down this season, but on-field accuracy is reported at 94%.

Image from BBC
BBCBBC

The Key Match Incidents Panel says on-field accuracy has been steady at 86% since 2023-24.

More on Sports