Judge Dismisses Trump’s $10 Billion Defamation Suit Against WSJ and Murdoch
Image: Variety

Judge Dismisses Trump’s $10 Billion Defamation Suit Against WSJ and Murdoch

13 April, 2026.USA.33 sources

The story in 15 seconds

  • Federal judge dismissed Trump's defamation suit against The Wall Street Journal and Rupert Murdoch.
  • Judge ruled Trump failed to show actual malice in reporting Epstein birthday letter.
  • Trump may amend or refile by April 27, per order.

The divide · 1 of 4

Legal standard and how the judge described malice

Shows different framing of the court’s ruling: CNBC emphasizes the lack of plausible actual malice; BBC emphasizes the standard and the explicit ‘nowhere close’ phrasing.

Who skipped what

How each outlet frames it

Every outlet we compared, the headline it ran, and a link to the original article.

Source Diversity
33 sources
Western Mainstream
17
Other
7
Local Western
5
Asian
2
West Asian
1
Western Alternative
1

Western Mainstream

ABC News
ABC News

Judge throws out Trump's $10B lawsuit against WSJ over Epstein reporting

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Axios
Axios

Judge tosses Trump's lawsuit against WSJ over Epstein letter

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
BBC
BBC

US judge dismisses Trump defamation suit against Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
BBC
BBC

US judge dismisses $10bn Trump defamation suit against Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
CNBC
CNBC

Judge dismisses Trump defamation lawsuit against Murdoch, WSJ about Epstein letter

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
CNN
CNN

Judge tosses Trump’s Wall Street Journal defamation lawsuit, gives him chance to refile

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Le Monde.fr
Le Monde.fr

Donald Trump is seeking at least $10 billion from The Wall Street Journal after an article about Jeffrey Epstein.

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
LiveNOW from FOX
LiveNOW from FOX

Trump’s $10B Wall Street Journal lawsuit over Epstein ties dismissed by judge

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Newser
Newser

Judge Tosses Trump's Defamation Suit Against WSJ

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Politico
Politico

Judge dismisses Trump’s lawsuit against WSJ over Epstein birthday letter

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
RFI
RFI

Epstein affair: Trump seeks ten billion dollars in damages from the Wall Street Journal for defamation

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
The Hill
The Hill

Judge dismisses Trump’s Wall Street Journal defamation suit over Epstein story

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
The Independent
The Independent

Judge dismisses Trump’s Wall Street Journal lawsuit over Epstein birthday letter story

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
The New York Times
The New York Times

Judge Dismisses Trump’s Suit Against The Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
The Telegraph
The Telegraph

Judge dismisses Trump’s $10bn lawsuit over Epstein birthday book

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
USA Today
USA Today

Trump lawsuit against WSJ over lewd Epstein birthday letter dismissed

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Variety
Variety

Judge Dismisses Trump’s Defamation Lawsuit Against Wall Street Journal Over Epstein Report

13 April, 2026

Read the original →

West Asian

Al Jazeera
Al Jazeera

US judge dismisses Trump’s $10bn lawsuit against WSJ over Epstein story

13 April, 2026

Read the original →

Other

BFM
BFM

Affaire Epstein: Donald Trump porte plainte pour diffamation contre le Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Business Day
Business Day

US judge tosses Trump’s defamation suit against Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Capital.fr
Capital.fr

10 milliards de dollars : Donald Trump contre attaque face au Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
La Libre.be
La Libre.be

Affaire Epstein: Trump attaque pour diffamation le Wall Street Journal et son patron Rupert Murdoch

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
La Libre.be
La Libre.be

Affaire Epstein - Un juge rejette la plainte en diffamation de Donald Trump contre le Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
The Daily Item
The Daily Item

Judge dismisses Trump’s $10B lawsuit against WSJ, Murdoch over reporting on ties to Epstein

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
The National Scot
The National Scot

Donald Trump's $10 billion lawsuit over Epstein article thrown out by judge

13 April, 2026

Read the original →

Local Western

Boursorama
Boursorama

A U.S. judge rejects Trump's defamation suit against The Wall Street Journal.

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Le HuffPost
Le HuffPost

After the Wall Street Journal's revelations about Trump and Epstein, the White House strikes back.

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Le Soir
Le Soir

Epstein case: Donald Trump’s suit against The Wall Street Journal dismissed

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Ouest-France
Ouest-France

Epstein Affair: Donald Trump threatens to sue the Wall Street Journal after revelations.

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
This is the Coast
This is the Coast

Judge dismisses Trump's $10bn lawsuit against Wall Street Journal and Murdoch over reporting on Epstein ties

13 April, 2026

Read the original →

Asian

Business Standard
Business Standard

US judge dismisses Trump's $10 bn defamation suit against WSJ, Murdoch

13 April, 2026

Read the original →
Firstpost
Firstpost

US judge dismisses Trump’s $10 billion defamation suit against WSJ about Epstein letter

13 April, 2026

Read the original →

Western Alternative

Deadline
Deadline

Judge Dismisses Donald Trump's Lawsuit Against Wall Street Journal

13 April, 2026

Read the original →

Full story

Judge Dismisses Trump Suit

A federal judge in Florida dismissed Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against Murdoch and The Wall Street Journal.

Judge Gayles ruled that Trump had not plausibly alleged actual malice, the legal standard for public figures.

Image from ABC News
ABC NewsABC News

The Journal had contacted Trump, Justice Department officials, and the FBI for comment before publishing.

Trump responded with a denial, which was included in the article.

Gayles gave Trump two weeks to file an amended complaint.

The ruling did not address whether the statements were true.

The Birthday Letter

The lawsuit centered on a Wall Street Journal article about a letter bearing Trump's signature in an album Epstein was giving for his 50th birthday.

The letter contained typewritten text framed by the outline of a naked woman, with Trump's signature mimicking pubic hair.

Image from Al Jazeera
Al JazeeraAl Jazeera

The letter concluded: Happy Birthday -- and may every day be another wonderful secret.

Trump angrily denied writing the letter, saying This is not me. This is a fake thing.

The letter was subsequently released publicly by the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee.

The Journal noted the letter was at the request of Ghislaine Maxwell.

Supply Chain Under Scrutiny

Both companies said they were deeply saddened and would review their Bangladesh operations.

Hessen's compliance team had audited the factory in March.

Rahman Textile owner Faisal Rahman claimed the factory had passed its most recent safety inspection in January.

Clean Clothes Campaign said the audit system was fundamentally broken.

The Dhaka Tribune reported Rahman was being questioned about welded shut emergency exits.

The deep audit

How victims, perpetrators and terms are handled across outlets.

More on USA