
Howard Lutnick Tells House Oversight His Epstein Interactions Were Virtually Nonexistent
Lutnick testified he met Epstein three times, with no personal or professional relationship at all. He described those encounters as virtually nonexistent during the congressional interview.
Beat 1 · The verdict
What Lutnick claimed happened regarding the 2012 island visit.
Full story
Lutnick’s Epstein testimony
Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick told the House Oversight Committee in a closed-door interview that his interactions with Jeffrey Epstein were “virtually nonexistent,” describing three in-person encounters in 2005, 2011 and 2012, including a lunch on Epstein’s private island in the U.S. Virgin Islands.
“his interactions with Epstein were “virtually nonexistent,””
In the transcript released by the committee, Lutnick said, “To the best of my recollection, those were the only three occasions in which I interacted with Epstein in person,” and added that “Each and every one was meaningless and inconsequential.”

Lutnick also told lawmakers that he and his wife were invited to Epstein’s New York home in 2005, where he said Epstein showed him a room with a massage table and candles, prompting him and his wife to leave.
CNN reported that the interview came after Justice Department files revealed his contact extended years beyond what he initially claimed in public, undercutting his assertion that he had cut ties with Epstein in 2005.
The BBC said Lutnick testified that he found Epstein’s comment about “the right kind of massage” “off-putting,” and that he and his wife “excused themselves and left the home.”
Blackmail claim and criticism
In a separate interview with House lawmakers, Lutnick backed away from a previous claim that Epstein had blackmailed people, telling the committee that he was only “speculating” when he made the assertion on a podcast.
The AP report quoted Lutnick saying, “I had no personal information. I was just speculating for a podcast,” and it said he later described his two other personal interactions as “meaningless and inconsequential.”

Democrats pressed Lutnick to explain why he met Epstein after initially deciding he would avoid him, and Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, said, “If a Cabinet Secretary lies to the American public, they should no longer serve in that position.”
The BBC also reported that bipartisan calls for Lutnick to resign followed the revelation that he visited Epstein’s island long after he asserted he had cut off contact in 2005.
MS NOW said Lutnick downplayed a 2012 trip to Epstein’s private island in newly released testimony, and it quoted him saying, “If you said chitchat, I’d go with that,” about whether anything was discussed during the visit.
What the committee released
The House Oversight Committee released transcriptions of interviews with both Lutnick and Ted Waitt, the billionaire co-founder of Gateway computers, as part of its investigation into Epstein and his orbit.
“He did seem to have significant influence over her, she always kind of look[ed] up to him”
The BBC said Waitt testified about his years-long relationship with Ghislaine Maxwell, describing Maxwell’s role as “estate manager,” and it quoted Waitt saying, “He did seem to have significant influence over her, she always kind of look[ed] up to him and I was not comfortable with that.”
Waitt told lawmakers he had never visited Epstein’s home, flown on his planes or visited his private island, and he said, “Each of those were very brief and unintentional,” according to the AP report.
Newsweek’s transcript summary said Lutnick told the committee that in late 2012 he visited Epstein’s island for lunch with his wife, children, friends and staff, and it quoted him saying, “We sat outside, had lunch. It was boring. We left.”
The Guardian reported that Lutnick opened his testimony by saying, “I unequivocally condemn the conduct attributed to Jeffrey Epstein and everyone who participated in his illegal activities,” while also asserting he had no “personal or professional relationship” with Epstein despite the proximity of their addresses.
Story read · 22 outlets · 2 disagreements · 3 facts unevenly covered
Keep reading
Donald Trump Confirms Secret Plane Switch in Turkey After Iran Threat
19 sources compared →
Trump Says Secret Service Ordered Plane Swap in Ankara After Iranian Assassination Threat
how 21 outlets framed it →
ICE Plans Up To $20 Million Electric Shock Gloves For Officers, DHS Procurement Says
how 17 outlets framed it →
The divide · 1 of 2
What Lutnick claimed happened regarding the 2012 island visit.
““If you said chitchat, I’d go with that.””
Read at source →“Each and every one was meaningless and inconsequential.”
Read at source →They emphasize either no discussion or broader insignificance, shifting perceived accountability.
Coverage map
Local Western (3)
Other (2)
Latin American (2)
Western Alternative (1)
How each outlet frames it
Every outlet we compared, the headline it ran, and a link to the original article.
Western Mainstream
Live updates: Democrats accuse Commerce Secretary Lutnick of evading questions on ties to Epstein
06 May, 2026
Lutnick downplayed contact with Epstein in House Oversight interview, transcript shows
13 May, 2026
Why Trump’s Commerce Secretary Is Testifying To Congress About Jeffrey Epstein Today
06 May, 2026
House Oversight releases Lutnick transcript on Epstein: Read in full
13 May, 2026
Howard Lutnick Downplays Epstein Connections in Capitol Grilling
06 May, 2026
WATCH: Comer says Commerce Secretary Lutnick hasn't been '100% truthful' about Epstein's island
06 May, 2026
Lutnick admits to having prolonged ties to Epstein in closed-door interview
06 May, 2026
Comer says Lutnick ‘wasn’t 100 percent truthful’ about being on Epstein’s island ahead of interview
06 May, 2026
Howard Lutnick says he couldn’t remember when he learned Epstein was a sex offender, deposition transcripts show
13 May, 2026
Other
U.S. Congress questions Howard Lutnick over inconsistencies regarding Epstein
08 May, 2026
Lutnick backs away from his Epstein ‘blackmail’ claim in interview with House committee
14 May, 2026
Latin American
We explain Howard Lutnick's ties to Epstein as he testifies today before Congress.
08 May, 2026
Howard Lutnick faces an intense closed-door questioning about his ties to Epstein as he struggles to stay in Trump’s good graces.
08 May, 2026
Local Western
Western Alternative
Howard Lutnick testified he saw Epstein’s massage table as ‘sexual in nature’ during 2005 visit
13 May, 2026
NewsCord Digest
Get every USA story like this one, in one email
Daily or weekly, only the topics you follow, each with the difference our analysis found across the outlets covering it.
Set up your digestMore on USA

Donald Trump Confirms Secret Plane Switch in Turkey After Iran Threat
19 sources compared

Trump Says Secret Service Ordered Plane Swap in Ankara After Iranian Assassination Threat
21 sources compared

ICE Plans Up To $20 Million Electric Shock Gloves For Officers, DHS Procurement Says
17 sources compared
Christopher Luxon Survives New Zealand National Party Caucus Confidence Vote in Wellington
10 sources compared