James Comey Surrenders After Indictment Over Instagram Post Threatening President Donald Trump

Former FBI Director James Comey was indicted Tuesday over an Instagram post prosecutors said threatened President Donald Trump, CNN reported, describing it as the administration’s second attempt to prosecute one of its biggest political opponents.

CNN said the charges were approved by a grand jury in the Eastern District of North Carolina where Comey allegedly took the photo, and that the charges include making a threat against the president and transmitting a threat in interstate commerce, according to court documents.

Above the Law

The case centers on a picture Comey posted on social media last May of seashells on a beach writing out the numbers “86 47,” CNN reported, with the caption, “Cool shell formation on my beach walk.”

Comey responded to the indictment Tuesday in a video posted to his Substack account, saying, “I’m still innocent. I’m still not afraid,” and “let’s go.”

BBC reported that Comey surrendered to authorities to face charges alleging that an image he briefly shared on social media posed a threat to the life of US President Donald Trump.

BBC said the case stems from a 2025 Instagram post shared by Comey containing a photo of seashells on a beach arranged to read "86 47," and that prosecutors allege it encourages violence against Trump, the 47th president.

The New York Post reported that Comey, 65, surrendered at the federal courthouse in Alexandria, Va., near his home, ahead of an initial court appearance, and that an arrest warrant was also issued for the ex-FBI director.

After the indictment, Comey surrendered Wednesday and appeared in federal court in Virginia, with BBC and CBS News describing a brief, procedural hearing in which he did not enter a plea.

BBC said Comey did not enter a plea or speak during his brief appearance at a Virginia court on Wednesday afternoon, and that Judge William Fitzpatrick read the charges, with Comey nodding as he was read his rights.

Al Jazeera

CBS News reported that Fitzpatrick denied the Justice Department's attempts to set conditions of release, quoting Fitzpatrick saying, "I don't think conditions on release are necessary in this case," and adding, "they weren't necessary last time" Comey was indicted.

CNN said Comey is expected to self-surrender on Wednesday to law enforcement at federal court in the Eastern District of Virginia, according to a federal official familiar, and that the case represents a reinvigorated effort to satisfy Trump’s demands to investigate his own foes.

The charges were described in multiple outlets as two counts tied to threatening Trump’s life and transmitting a threat across state lines.

BBC said prosecutors have charged Comey with knowingly and wilfully making a threat to take the life of — and to inflict bodily harm - on the president, and also, knowingly transmitting in interstate commerce a threat to kill him, and that each charge carries a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison.

The Detroit News reported that Comey’s surrender preempted agents seeking him out, and that Fitzpatrick rejected a government request to place restrictions on Comey’s release, allowing him to leave the courthouse pending a hearing in North Carolina where he will enter a plea.

Comey denied wrongdoing and framed the prosecution as politically motivated, while Trump publicly attacked him and interpreted the “86 47” numbers as a coded call for violence.

CNN reported that Comey removed the post the same day, writing on social media that he assumed the shells represented “a political message” but “didn’t realize some folks associate those numbers with violence.”

BBC said Comey denied any wrongdoing, saying he did not know what the numbers meant, and accused the prosecution of political motivation, and it quoted Comey’s video statement: “This won't be the end of it - but I'm still innocent, I'm still not afraid and I still believe in the independent federal judiciary.”

In the same BBC account, Trump called Comey a “crooked man,” and said, “If anybody knows anything about crime, they know '86,” adding, “It's a mob term for 'kill him.'”

BBC also reported that when asked if he believed Comey's social media post was a threat to him, Trump replied: “Probably.”

The New York Post quoted Trump saying, “It’s a mob term for ‘kill him’,” and also quoted Trump calling Comey a “very dirty cop” and saying, “People like Comey have created tremendous danger, I think, for politicians and others.”

Al Jazeera described Comey’s court appearance as brief and procedural, saying he did not speak, while his lawyer Patrick Fitzgerald said he would argue the case is a vindictive prosecution.

Legal experts and lawmakers questioned the strength of the indictment, and multiple outlets described how the case turns on whether the “86 47” post qualifies as a punishable “true threat” under the First Amendment.

CNN quoted Eugene Volokh saying, “This is not going anywhere. This is clearly not a punishable threat,” and described the uphill nature of the prosecution because the charges require proof that Comey “knowingly and willfully” made a threat to “take the life of” the president.

Australian Broadcasting Corporation

BBC reported that some legal experts and lawmakers questioned the strength of the charges, quoting Republican Senator Thom Tillis saying he hoped “there's more to it than just the picture in the sand,” and it quoted Jimmy Gurulé calling the indictment “an embarrassment to the American criminal justice system.”

BBC also included Acting US Attorney General Todd Blanche’s response, saying the case had been investigated “for the past year,” and quoting Blanche: “People should be very wary of threatening the life of President Trump because that is a crime. Full stop,” and it said Blanche rejected the suggestion that there were political motives behind the case.

CBS News added a constitutional framing, quoting a CBS News legal contributor saying, “They're based on seashells,” and describing the “robust First Amendment defense” if prosecutors cannot show the required intent.

CBS News also cited a Supreme Court standard, saying that in 2023 the Supreme Court said that for a true threat to be considered speech unprotected under the First Amendment, the government must show that the speaker “consciously disregards a significant risk that their words might harm another.”

CNBC reported that the indictment says Comey “knowingly and willfully did transmit in interstate and foreign commerce a communication that contained a threat to kill the President, Donald J. Trump,” and that it hinges on how a “reasonable recipient” would interpret the post.

The indictment is described across outlets as part of a broader, escalating legal and political conflict involving Trump, the Justice Department, and Comey’s history as a critic.

“- Published Former FBI Director James Comey surrendered to authorities to face charges alleging that an image he briefly shared on social media posed a threat to the life of US President Donald Trump”

BBC

CNN said the new case represents a reinvigorated effort to satisfy Trump’s demands to investigate his own foes, including Comey, and it said it comes less than a month after the president dismissed Attorney General Pam Bondi, with Todd Blanche now in charge of steering the department.

BBC

CNN also said the case is the second effort by Trump’s Justice Department to convict Comey, noting that in September of last year the Justice Department first brought charges accusing Comey of lying to Congress over leaks to the press, and that the case was dismissed late last year by a federal judge who found that the interim US Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia had been improperly appointed.

BBC reported that this marks the second time the justice department has brought criminal charges against Comey, and it said Comey pleaded not guilty in October before the case was dismissed in November.

Al Jazeera said the indictment marks a renewed push by Trump’s Justice Department to target perceived political enemies of the president with criminal prosecution, and it described how the dispute hinges on the meaning of “86” and whether the post was intended as a threat.

WION reported that the case comes amid ongoing tensions between Trump and Comey, and it said Trump has repeatedly called for Comey’s prosecution.

In the immediate aftermath, CNN reported that Comey is expected to self-surrender on Wednesday to law enforcement at federal court in the Eastern District of Virginia, and BBC said his next court appearance is expected in North Carolina, where a federal grand jury returned the indictment on Tuesday.