Lula to Present Italy's Request to Postpone EU-Mercosur Trade Deal at Mercosur Summit

Lula to Present Italy's Request to Postpone EU-Mercosur Trade Deal at Mercosur Summit

18 December, 20252 sources compared
South America

Key Points from 2 News Sources

  1. 1

    Brazil's President Lula will present Italy's postponement request to Mercosur leaders

  2. 2

    European Commission proposed postponing the agreement's signing until January

  3. 3

    Postponement aims to preserve the EU-Mercosur trade agreement

Full Analysis Summary

EU-Mercosur signing delay

Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva said he will raise Italy’s request to delay signing the long‑awaited EU‑Mercosur trade deal at this weekend’s Mercosur summit in Foz do Iguaçu.

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni asked for "a week, ten days, a month" of patience following a phone call with Lula.

The pact, which would create one of the world’s largest free‑trade areas between the EU and Mercosur members - Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay and Uruguay - had been expected to be finalised before the summit.

However, it faces postponement pressure from France and Italy over concerns about impacts on European agriculture.

El País similarly notes the proposal to postpone the signing and frames the delay as part of a broader push by EU leaders to manage domestic opposition ahead of a possible early‑January signing window.

Coverage Differences

Tone

Free Malaysia Today (Asian) presents Lula’s action as a direct response to Italy’s request, emphasising the immediate diplomatic exchange and the size of the pact, while El País (Western Mainstream) frames the story more as an EU‑level management decision — reporting a European Commission proposal to push the signing to early January and focusing on intra‑EU dynamics.

European agricultural delay request

Italy’s request is portrayed in both accounts as driven by domestic agricultural concerns.

Free Malaysia Today highlights that France and Italy are pushing to postpone the pact over concerns about impacts on European agriculture and notes violent farmers’ protests in Brussels.

El País adds political context in Rome, saying Meloni faces pressure from agricultural constituencies and coalition dynamics, notably with Matteo Salvini.

El País also reports that Meloni told Lula she will sign only after the European Commission provides quick, concrete responses to farmers’ concerns.

Both sources therefore link the delay request to farmer resistance and political calculation.

Coverage Differences

Narrative emphasis

Free Malaysia Today (Asian) emphasises the immediate cause — agricultural concerns and protests in Brussels — and quotes Macron’s rejection, while El País (Western Mainstream) places stronger emphasis on internal Italian politics and how Meloni leverages Italy’s position to extract concessions from the Commission.

Trade pact delay fallout

El País reports that EU institutions are attempting to manage the fallout by proposing a postponement from this weekend to early January.

This proposed delay reflects 25 years of negotiations and the pact's potential market of roughly 700 million people across 31 countries.

Free Malaysia Today describes similar stakes, calling the pact one of the world's largest free-trade areas and noting leaders' last-minute maneuvering.

Together the sources present a picture of high-stakes international economics colliding with immediate political barriers.

Coverage Differences

Detail and scale framing

El País (Western Mainstream) supplies numerical framing — ‘25 years’ of negotiation and a potential market of ‘roughly 700 million people across 31 countries’ — giving weight to the long negotiation and scale, while Free Malaysia Today (Asian) stresses the pact’s status as ‘one of the world’s largest free‑trade areas’ and focuses on leaders’ immediate responses and protests.

EU opposition to trade pact

Both sources identify French opposition as decisive.

Free Malaysia Today quotes French President Emmanuel Macron as saying the agreement "cannot be signed" in its current form and links that stance to on-the-ground protests.

El País says EU leaders have largely accepted Macron’s position but are attempting to bring Italy back on board by negotiating concessions and guarantees to reassure farmers.

The combined reporting indicates that while Brazil and Mercosur will discuss Italy’s request at the summit, EU political resistance—especially from France—remains the critical barrier to immediate ratification.

Coverage Differences

Attribution and agency

Free Malaysia Today (Asian) emphasizes Macron’s explicit rejection and the immediacy of protests as context, while El País (Western Mainstream) frames the EU leadership as reacting — accepting Macron’s likely refusal and strategising to ‘win over’ Italy with concessions, thus highlighting intra‑EU diplomatic management rather than simply protest dynamics.

Mercosur summit outlook

Implications for the Mercosur summit are clear: Lula will raise Italy's request, but the outcome depends on negotiations within the EU and between EU and Mercosur members.

Free Malaysia Today centers on the immediate diplomatic action Lula will take at Foz do Iguaçu.

El País stresses that any new timetable likely depends on the European Commission's capacity to offer concessions and on whether leaders can placate domestic agricultural opponents by early January.

The combined reporting suggests a postponed signing is likely unless quick, concrete compromises are found.

Coverage Differences

Predictive emphasis

Free Malaysia Today (Asian) foregrounds Lula’s role at the summit and immediate action, while El País (Western Mainstream) focuses on process and timing — the Commission’s proposal and the need for concessions — suggesting that the pact’s fate hinges on EU internal negotiation rather than the Mercosur summit alone.

All 2 Sources Compared

El País

Brussels proposes postponing the signing of the EU-Mercosur agreement until January to convince Meloni.

Read Original

Free Malaysia Today

Lula says will present proposed EU trade deal postponement to Mercosur

Read Original