FA Reignites Debate After Argentina Loss as Guardiola Verbal Agreement Emerges
Image: Vietnam.vn

FA Reignites Debate After Argentina Loss as Guardiola Verbal Agreement Emerges

17 July, 2026.Sports.22 sources

The story in 15 seconds

  • Guardiola reportedly had a verbal agreement to manage England in 2024 before Tuchel's appointment.
  • Revelation reopens debate over Tuchel's England tenure after 2026 World Cup semifinal loss.
  • FA backed Tuchel and extended his contract, with no exit clause beyond Round of 16.

The divide · 1 of 3

talkSPORT and Metro heavily blame Tuchel, while others stress contract clauses and continuity

Who skipped what

Blind spots

If you only read Western Mainstream outlets, you would not know:

  • Rooney says don’t sack Tuchel unless Guardiola available

Skipped by Foot Mercato, Football365, OneFootball, Ouest-France, The Independent, talkSPORT

How each outlet frames it

Every outlet we compared, the headline it ran, and a link to the original article.

Source Diversity
22 sources
Western Mainstream
10
Other
6
Western Tabloid
3
Local Western
2
Asian
1

Western Mainstream

BBC
BBC

Stick with Tuchel unless Guardiola is available - Rooney

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
Foot Mercato
Foot Mercato

Angleterre : la menace Pep Guardiola plane au dessus de Thomas Tuchel

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
Football365
Football365

Tuchel exit 'clauses' with one condition revealed with Guardiola 'verbal agreement'

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
Goal
Goal

Post-World Cup revelation: Guardiola has agreed to take the reins of England's national team.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
L'Équipe
L'Équipe

Pep Guardiola had an agreement with England and could have been the manager in place of Thomas Tuchel in 2024.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
Le Figaro
Le Figaro

World Cup 2026: Pep Guardiola in place of Thomas Tuchel? England had an agreement with the Spanish coach.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
OneFootball
OneFootball

Pep Guardiola estuvo cerca de dirigir a Inglaterra antes del Mundial 2026

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
Ouest-France
Ouest-France

World Cup. Pep Guardiola could have been on England's bench in place of Thomas Tuchel.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
talkSPORT
talkSPORT

England must hire fearless Pep Guardiola to replace 'cowardly' Thomas Tuchel and end 60-year drought

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
The Independent
The Independent

Pep Guardiola ‘had verbal agreement’ to become England boss as Thomas Tuchel exit clauses revealed

17 July, 2026

Read the original →

Local Western

DHnet
DHnet

Pep Guardiola could have been in Thomas Tuchel's place: he would have had an agreement with England.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
INFO.FR
INFO.FR

Tuchel Shielded by the FA: Why England Cannot Sack Him After the Semifinal Loss

17 July, 2026

Read the original →

Other

El Desmarque
El Desmarque

Pep Guardiola coge fuerza como sustituto de Thomas Tuchel en Inglaterra

16 July, 2026

Read the original →
Fichajes
Fichajes

La amenaza de Pep Guardiola planea sobre Thomas Tuchel

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
Panamericana TV
Panamericana TV

Bombshell in England! Guardiola was one step away from...

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
RPP
RPP

England reached an agreement with Guardiola prior to Thomas Tuchel's arrival, according to the British press.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
SPORT
SPORT

Guardiola was supposed to be England's national team coach at the World Cup.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
TribalFootball
TribalFootball

Rooney names Guardiola as ideal Tuchel alternative for England

17 July, 2026

Read the original →

Western Tabloid

Metro.co.uk
Metro.co.uk

Wayne Rooney names the manager England should sack Thomas Tuchel for

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
The Mirror
The Mirror

Pep Guardiola's huge England U-turn as Thomas Tuchel exit clauses emerge

17 July, 2026

Read the original →
The Sun
The Sun

Pep Guardiola 'had verbal AGREEMENT' to be England manager before Three Lions turned to Thomas Tuchel

17 July, 2026

Read the original →

Asian

Vietnam.vn
Vietnam.vn

Pep Guardiola reached an agreement to coach England instead of Tuchel.

17 July, 2026

Read the original →

Full story

Guardiola nearly England

England’s World Cup 2026 semifinal defeat to Argentina reignited debate over the FA’s choice of Thomas Tuchel, after the Three Lions led 1-0 but conceded a late comeback to lose 2-1.

- Published Wayne Rooney thinks the Football Association should stick with Thomas Tuchel as England head coach unless a move for Pep Guardiola is possible

BBCBBC

OneFootball said The Athletic reported the Football Association (FA) had “very advanced” talks to bring Pep Guardiola in 2024, with a verbal agreement for him to take charge of the Three Lions.

Image from BBC
BBCBBC

The same report said Guardiola then renewed with Manchester City, forcing the FA to seek another option and leading to Tuchel’s official appointment in October 2024 and his start in early 2025.

Foot Mercato added that Tuchel’s future seemed uncertain after the loss, but the FA “semble maintenir sa confiance envers son sélectionneur” and kept him in place through Euro 2028.

Ouest-France also framed it as a missed opportunity, saying The Athletic reported Guardiola had given consent to become head coach for the 2026 World Cup before retracting his decision.

Rooney and FA backing

After England’s capitulation against Argentina, Wayne Rooney urged the FA to not sack Thomas Tuchel as England boss unless Pep Guardiola was available.

Metro.co.uk quoted Rooney saying, “I don’t see anyone else out there at the minute, unless you go and get Pep Guardiola,” and added that Rooney believed England should “pounce” if Guardiola showed interest.

Image from DHnet
DHnetDHnet

The Independent reported that there were calls for Tuchel to be sacked, but it said the FA reaffirmed its commitment to the German after the defeat and that his contract included clauses that would only be activated if England had been knocked out before the quarter-finals.

Football365 tied the debate to The Athletic’s account that the FA’s first target was Guardiola, with a “verbal agreement,” before it turned to Tuchel.

Ouest-France said the FA publicly supported Tuchel and that a clause in his contract would have allowed a separation if England had been eliminated before the quarterfinals, which did not happen.

Exit clauses and next match

Multiple outlets described contract exit clauses around England’s World Cup 2026 run, with Foot Mercato saying Tuchel’s deal had clauses allowing an early separation if England were eliminated in the groups, last 32, or last 16.

El alemán, muy señalado tras la derrota en semifinales ante Argentina Borja Iglesias ya avisó de qué haría ante un posible saludo con Donald Trump La derrota de Inglaterra dejó muy señalado a Thomas Tuchel

El DesmarqueEl Desmarque

Foot Mercato also said an exception was made for the last-16 match against Mexico at the Estadio Azteca, because the FA considered that elimination in that context “n’aurait pas forcément constitué un échec.”

The Independent added that an exemption was added once it became apparent England would face Mexico at the Estadio Azteca in the last-16, and it said Tuchel’s side went on to win 3-2.

Ouest-France said England’s third-place playoff is against the Blues this Saturday in Miami (11:00 p.m.), and it reiterated that the quarterfinal-triggering scenario did not occur because England reached the last four.

OneFootball concluded that, despite elimination and criticism, Tuchel would continue as England manager with his contract extended until after Euro 2028, while Guardiola remained the “gran oportunidad” that had been close to becoming real.

The deep audit

How victims, perpetrators and terms are handled across outlets.

More on Sports