Published

Ornate stone building with central tower and green lawn, blue sky, The Hague

Global Politicsupdated 1h ago2 min read

Archive photo · 29 April 2024

7 outlets compared

ICJ To Rule On Whether Gambia’s Rohingya Genocide Case Meets Legal Threshold

The Times of Israel
“could give clues on the court’s treatment of Gaza proceedings”
Haaretz
“What, and how, the judges rule will have a fateful effect on South Africa's genocide case against Israel”
2 Israeli2 West Asian1 Asian2 Other source types

Photo: Thomas Wolf, www.foto-tw.de, CC BY-SA 3.0 de · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

ICJ to rule on whether Myanmar's 2017 Rohingya campaign meets genocide threshold. Decision could influence future genocide cases, including Gaza proceedings.

ICJ weighs genocide proof

The International Court of Justice will issue its ruling on Thursday on whether the Gambia’s case against Myanmar for the ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya meets the legal threshold for genocide. The Convention’s definition requires “the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.” The East-West Street account cited by El País describes how Raphael Lemkin combined the Greek genos and the Latin cidio to kill, and it frames the Convention as stricter and harder to apply than Lemkin’s concept.

The Al Sharq for News framing says the 1948 Convention defines genocide as the commission of five acts with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group as such. The Times of Israel describes the ICJ’s Thursday decision as closely watched and as a potential preview for South Africa’s case alleging genocide in Gaza, which Israel denies.

Ornate palace building behind gates, lawn and people in foreground, The Hague
Ornate palace building behind gates, lawn and people in foregroundThe Hague · 19 July 2025 · Archive photoPhoto: Stck w, CC BY-SA 4.0
Reporting for this sectionEL PAÍS

Rohingya testimony and legal stakes

Hasina Khatun told Reuters that “The military took my husband and other men from the village. We saw it happen with our own eyes,” and she said her husband was gone while her children were crying from hunger and she was pregnant.

Khatun now lives in a nine-by-12-foot (three-by-four meter) shelter made of bamboo and plastic sheeting in Cox’s Bazar, among about 1.2 million Rohingya refugees.

The ICJ already ordered Israel in 2024 to suspend its offensive over Gaza because of the “catastrophic humanitarian situation” in the Strip, and to allow the investigation of the genocide accusation.

Rohingya survivors will enter “the Great Hall of Justice in The Hague” seeking justice for witness NJ’s daughter, a newborn ripped from her mother’s arms, stabbed to death, and thrown into a fire.

The Diplomat also said the judges examined survivor testimony, expert analysis, satellite imagery, U.N. documentation, and extensive legal arguments, while Myanmar’s agents denied responsibility.

What the ruling could change

The ICJ’s Thursday ruling on Myanmar could create jurisprudence that could affect the next case in which the ICJ must rule, still without a date, South Africa’s case against Israel for genocide in Gaza. The judges may conclude Myanmar bears direct responsibility for genocide against the Rohingya, or they may find a narrower breach such as failing to prevent genocide, failing to punish it, enabling it through complicity or incitement, failing to enact the necessary laws, or violating the Court’s earlier orders to protect the Rohingya while the case was pending. States would be expected to review arms transfers, aviation fuel supplies, banking links and economic relationships that sustain Myanmar’s military.

Al Sharq for News said the ruling is expected to clarify how the ICJ assesses conclusions of UN fact-finding reports and the extent to which it relies on them to establish genocide. Gambia asked the court to order Myanmar to pay reparations and ensure the safe return of Rohingya refugees, and it described the ICJ as settling disputes between states and ruling on alleged breaches of international treaties.

Reporting for this sectionEL PAÍS