Published

Cricket match at stadium, bowler delivering and batsman on strike, Perth

Sportsupdated 26m ago2 min read

Archive photo · 2 December 2022

7 outlets compared

Pat Cummins Faces Sandpapergate Scrutiny Ahead of Perth Test vs New Zealand

SMH.au
“It will be brought down by its resistance to transparency, its self-serving ‘crisis management’,”
The Guardian
“For eight years, I shared the burden of this story for the whole team.”
5 Western Mainstream1 Other1 West Asian

Photo: Calistemon, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Bancroft claims the entire Australian team knew about ball-tampering during the 2018 South Africa tour. Pat Cummins faces captaincy scrutiny amid ongoing sandpapergate fallout ahead of Perth Test.

Cummins under pressure

Pat Cummins is due to lead Australia in the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December, but the BBC framed his captaincy as being at a crossroads in the wake of the sandpapergate controversy. Cameron Bancroft’s 4,000-word account, delivered in his local newspaper The West Australian on Wednesday, has intensified scrutiny of who knew what during Australia’s 2018 tour of South Africa.

“He is due to lead Australia in the first Test against New Zealand in Perth on 9 December.”
BBC

The BBC’s Agnew said the “spotlight has fallen on Pat Cummins,” and the build-up to the Perth Test is expected to be dominated by questions about sandpaper, who knew, and who said what. The BBC also said Cummins “has said he never wants to talk about sandpaper again,” while the same piece described the Perth crowd as a “litmus test” for whether Cummins remains in the role by then.

Stadium interior, cricket field and sparse spectators in the stands, Perth
Stadium interior, cricket field and sparse spectators in the standsPerth · 21 January 2018 · Archive photoPhoto: Photographs by Gnangarra...commons.wikimedia.org, CC BY 2.5 au
Reporting for this sectionBBC

Bancroft expands claims

Cameron Bancroft claimed that the entire Australian team had known about ball-tampering during a 2018 tour of South Africa, and he said he lied about the extent of the plot to protect Cricket Australia’s investigation.

Bancroft wrote, “It was not just the three of us — Steve Smith, David Warner and I — who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa. It was the whole team,” and he added that he withheld details when questioned during Cricket Australia’s investigation.

Cricket Australia said on Wednesday it would open an independent forum for all those who were on the 2018 South African tour, and the board told the public, “We respect that Cameron Bancroft has told his story, and we will take time to consider his comments.”

The New York Times argued that Cummins’ position is “untenable,” and it said there is “surely no way back for Cummins after Cameron Bancroft’s extraordinary 4,000-word account” was published.

Perth Stadium seen from parkland, river and landscaped foreground, Perth
Perth Stadium seen from parkland, river and landscaped foregroundPerth · 7 March 2021 · Archive photoPhoto: Calistemon, CC BY-SA 4.0
Reporting for this sectionAl JazeeraThe New York Times

Calls for change

Chadd Sayers told the radio network on Thursday that he was “pretty comfortable,” and he said it was “just probably bad timing for me” that kept him from speaking earlier about what he knew. Ian Healy told SEN that Cummins “doesn’t need to stand down,” but he warned that pushing the skipper out would repeat 2018 “panic mode” from CA bosses.

SEN’s Gerard Whately said Neil Maxwell’s statement on behalf of Pat Cummins “beggars belief,” and Whately added, “I would sack my manager because that’s rank advice.” The BBC’s Agnew said the Test at Bancroft’s home city, in the state of the newspaper where his 4,000-word testimony was first published, could determine whether Cummins survives the immediate fallout, and it described the Australian media as unlikely to “let up” even if he gets through that match.

Reporting for this sectionNine.au