Police Charge Two Men With Kidnapping, Torturing and Murdering 85-Year-Old Pensioner in Mistaken Identity Case

Police Charge Two Men With Kidnapping, Torturing and Murdering 85-Year-Old Pensioner in Mistaken Identity Case

25 February, 202614 sources compared
Australia

Key Points from 14 News Sources

  1. 1

    Two men, aged 29 and 24, were charged with kidnapping and murder of Chris Baghsarian.

  2. 2

    Police say the February 13 abduction was a case of mistaken identity.

  3. 3

    Human remains found near a Pitt Town golf club prompted arrests and search warrants.

Full Analysis Summary

Sydney abduction case

Police in Sydney arrested two men, aged 24 and 29, and charged them over the abduction and death of 85-year-old pensioner Chris Baghsarian after he was taken from his North Ryde home on Feb. 13.

Human remains later identified as his were found near a Pitt Town golf club following an extensive search.

Authorities say CCTV showed him being forced into an SUV and that a video of him being assaulted circulated alongside a ransom demand, prompting raids and arrests in Sydney’s north-west.

Detectives described the suspects’ actions as part of a "joint criminal enterprise" and say more arrests are expected as inquiries and forensic testing continue.

Coverage Differences

Tone

Some sources emphasise procedural facts and police statements (dates, arrests, searches), while others highlight graphic imagery or family descriptions; these reflect differing editorial tones between mainstream reporting and tabloid/other outlets.

Searches, seizures and arrests

Police executed multiple search warrants at properties in Kenthurst, Castle Hill and Lake Macquarie.

They seized vehicles, electronics and clothing, and towed a Toyota thought to be linked to the abduction.

Two men were detained in early-morning raids and have been identified by detectives as participants in the alleged joint criminal enterprise.

Some outlets include footage and vivid descriptions of the arrests, while police outlets and mainstream broadcasters focused on the items seized and the locations searched as part of 'Strike Force Chobat'.

Coverage Differences

Unique Coverage

Tabloid coverage (Daily Mail) emphasises arrest footage and vivid arrest details, whereas mainstream sources and police‑focused outlets (Sky News Australia, aapnews) prioritise search‑warrant locations, seized evidence and the formal name of the investigation.

Naming Suspects

Some reports (Sky News Australia) name arrested men as 'Mr Andrews' and 'Mr Stevens', while most other sources do not provide suspect names in their initial reports.

Ransom-related murder charges

Authorities have formally charged two men with murder and kidnapping with intent to ransom; court documents and police said both were refused bail and are due to appear at Blacktown Local Court.

Detectives described the alleged offence as ransom‑motivated and reported that a video of the assault accompanied a ransom demand, but at least one outlet says investigators have not publicly disclosed how Baghsarian died.

Police continue to seek at least one other person and say further arrests are likely as they review seized evidence.

Coverage Differences

Fact Omission

Some outlets explicitly state detectives have not disclosed the cause of death (RNZ), while other reports (SBS, 7NEWS) include police allegations that Baghsarian was killed after being taken to a makeshift stronghold and allegedly tortured — reflecting differences in how outlets report unconfirmed investigative claims.

Alleged mistaken-identity abduction

Police say the abduction was likely the result of mistaken identity.

Investigators allege the intended target was a relative of an underworld-linked Sydney businessman, with several outlets naming Dimitri Stepanyan in that context.

Media reports also say screenshots and online posts show kidnappers demanding an AU$50 million ransom, though outlets differ on how explicitly they connect those materials to the formal police account.

Police have said the victim and his family have no criminal or underworld links.

According to some reports, relatives repeatedly told kidnappers they had the wrong man.

Coverage Differences

Narrative Framing

Mainstream sources (CBS, aapnews, RNZ) report police statements stressing mistaken identity and the family's lack of underworld links, while others (1News, Sky News Australia) emphasise the alleged connection to an underworld‑linked figure, naming Dimitri Stepanyan; some outlets report the AU$50 million ransom demand as circulating online rather than as a confirmed police statement.

Family reaction and media coverage

Family members and community sources described Baghsarian as a gentle, amiable family man.

Relatives have asked for privacy while police continue their probe.

Investigators warned more arrests are possible as they review seized devices.

Community and ethnic outlets emphasise the personal loss and dignity of the victim.

Mainstream broadcasters echo police procedural language and court updates.

Tabloid outlets foreground dramatic footage from raids and arrests.

Coverage Differences

Tone

Community and ethnic coverage (Armenian Weekly) focuses on the victim’s character and the family's grief; mainstream broadcasters (CBS, RNZ) foreground police statements and legal steps; tabloids (Daily Mail) emphasise arrest footage and dramatic visuals.

All 14 Sources Compared

1News

Pair charged over Sydney grandfather's kidnapping and murder

Read Original

7NEWS

Chris Baghsarian: Gerard Andrews and Daniel Stevens charged over kidnapping, murder of Sydney grandfather

Read Original

9News.au

Two men charged over alleged kidnapping, murder of Sydney grandfather

Read Original

aapnews.aap.au

Duo charged over grandfather's kidnapping and murder

Read Original

Australian Broadcasting Corporation

Man accused of Sydney grandfather's killing 'no mastermind', lawyer says

Read Original

CBS News

85-year-old widower kidnapped and murdered in apparent case of mistaken identity in Australia

Read Original

CNN

Alleged kidnappers mistakenly abduct and kill the wrong man, police say

Read Original

Daily Mail

Wild moment man is arrested pantless after alleged bungled mistaken identity kidnapping death of 85-year-old grandfather

Read Original

dailytelegraph.au

Charged: Men accused of grandfather’s kidnapping, murder

Read Original

RNZ

Two men charged over alleged abduction and murder of Chris Baghsarian

Read Original

SBS Australia

Police charge two people over alleged kidnapping and murder of Chris Baghsarian

Read Original

Sky News

Pair charged with alleged murder of 'mistakenly-kidnapped' pensioner Chris Baghsarian in Sydney

Read Original

Sky News Australia

Names of men charged with alleged murder of Sydney grandfather revealed

Read Original

The Armenian Weekly

Suspects arrested in kidnapping and murder of 85-year-old Armenian in Sydney

Read Original