Published

Tall stone chapel tower with ivy on lower walls against blue sky, University of Chicago

Indiaupdated 25m ago2 min read

Archive photo · 15 June 2018

5 outlets compared

Rahul Gandhi Backs India-Israel Defense Ties, Condemns Hamas October 7 Attacks

2 West Asian2 Western Alternative1 Asian

Photo: Rizka, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Rahul Gandhi says India should maintain strong strategic and defence ties with Israel. He condemns Hamas October 7 attacks and Israel's Gaza offensive; one wrong cannot justify another.

Sources

5 outlets in this story. Read their headlines below.

Gandhi backs Israel ties

Rahul Gandhi said India should continue to maintain strong strategic and defence ties with Israel despite the war on Gaza, and he framed the issue as one of national interest rather than external pressure. Gandhi told an audience at the University of Chicago during a discussion with political scientist Robert Pape that, "We have good relations with Israel, and we buy weapons from them," and he added, "I fully support maintaining good relations with Israel."

Gandhi also condemned the October 7, 2023 attacks led by Hamas, saying the killing of civilians was unacceptable, while he briefly condemned Israel's actions in Gaza. Gandhi said India, with a population of 1.5 billion, should base its foreign policy on what is good for it, and he argued, "But we are a much bigger country, with a population of 1.5 billion, and our foreign policy should be based on what is good for us, not on what is good for others," in the same remarks.

Reporting for this sectionMiddle East Eye

Contract and criticism

India's defence ministry announced a $211m contract with Israel Aerospace Industries to upgrade the Barak point-defence missile systems installed on Indian Navy ships, and the agreement was described as signed on 18 November. Gandhi's remarks came the same day as that defence ministry announcement, and Gandhi defended continued military cooperation with Israel.

Apoorvanand Jha, a professor in the Hindi department at the University of Delhi, criticised Gandhi's position by saying, "India does have strong relations with Israel and India does buy weapons from Israel and these are facts - but doing so is detrimental to peace". A local activist who asked to remain anonymous told Middle East Eye that Gandhi was "contradicting himself," arguing that Gandhi said foreign policy should be what is good for India while also advocating strategic ties with Israel.

Reporting for this sectionMiddle East Eye

What the stance means

Gandhi's comments drew criticism from activists and academics and opened debate about how Indian political stances align with international anger at Israel's war on Gaza. The Internet Freedom Foundation reported that Home Minister Amit Shah had approved the National Investigation Agency’s purchase of a phone-unlocking tool from Israeli surveillance company Cellebrite, with activists raising concerns about Israeli phone-extraction technology.

Gandhi's statements came during a visit to the US, after which he shared footage of the discussion on X to reiterate that India should pursue its own interests on the international stage. Gandhi said, "One wrong cannot justify another," as he condemned both the October 7 attacks and Israel's Gaza offensive, and he added that India must not be constrained by anyone in its role on the global stage.

Reporting for this sectionMiddle East EyeMathrubhumi English