Published

Technology and Scienceupdated 26m ago3 min read

Sen. Chris Coons Says Starshield Slowdowns Are Killing Civilians, Calls for Answers

14outlets comparedA wider view of the story

5 Western Mainstream4 Local Western2 Asian3 Other source types

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Lawmaker threatens withholding funding for SpaceX government systems over Starshield Ukraine restrictions. Starshield switchoffs allegedly disrupt Ukrainian operations, cited as harming civilians.

Congress targets Starshield access

Sen. Chris Coons of Delaware said one of the first orders of business for the next Congress would be looking at what he said crippled Ukraine’s access to SpaceX’s Starshield, adding, "Look at Starshield being turned on and off. … It is killing civilians."

“Look at Starshield being turned on and off. … It is killing civilians.”
Breaking Defense

Coons told an audience in Halifax, Nova Scotia on Friday that the service is "undermining the world’s confidence in the United States as a supplier of key security equipment," and he said the services are "paid for by American taxpayers under contract."

Ukraine’s Chargé d’Affaires Denys Sienik said in a Nov. 9 statement to Breaking Defense that "We experience speed limitations as of now on Ukrainian occupied territories and across the contact line," and he said the speed limitations of 100 mph were in place in those areas.

Sienik said Kyiv still did not have clarity from the Pentagon or SpaceX over the cause of the slow down or who may have ordered it, while Breaking Defense reported that the US Embassy did not respond to questions about the status of Starshield at the time.

Coons said he would press for answers on "What the hell is happening? Why is this being done? What are the consequences and the costs?" as Democrats prepare to run both chambers of the US Congress next year.

Reporting for this sectionBreaking Defense

Himes threatens funding leverage

Rep. Jim Himes, expected to chair the House Intelligence Committee in January, told Elon Musk in a Friday letter that SpaceX’s handling of Starshield in Ukraine "calls into question every contract the U.S. Government has with SpaceX."

Himes warned in a classified communication to Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton that "Simply, our committee cannot authorize funds for the development of government systems that the government will not fully control," according to CNN.

CNN reported that Himes also sent a classified message to Clayton demanding clarity on what led to the slowdown of Ukraine’s Starshield connection speed, and CNN said Himes formally requested a meeting with Musk to discuss the October changes.

KeepTrack reported that the Starshield dispute moved from Ukraine’s front lines to congressional funding, and it said Himes wrote that SpaceX’s "potentially unilateral modification of a U.S. Government contract" combined with a lack of responsiveness to congressional oversight calls into question every contract.

The dispute has centered on whether SpaceX independently modified the service or whether the Trump administration directed changes, with Newsweek reporting that SpaceX denied introducing new restrictions or making changes and with Musk maintaining that Starshield systems are "owned and controlled by the US government."

Reporting for this sectionKeepTrackCNN

Ukraine presses for clarity

Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on social media that "Unfortunately, we have established that the equipment stops functioning at speeds of 130–161 kilometers per hour in various sectors of the front," and he said it was slowing frontline logistics and limiting the use of various types of drones. Engadget reported that Musk accused Zelenskyy of being "untruthful" about Starshield disruptions and said Musk told Andrew Ross Sorkin that "Starlink is a civilian system" and that it is "not meant to be used for offensive drone strikes that kill people." Engadget said Musk replied to Sorkin’s reminder that Zelenskyy referred to the system being slowed as Starshield, and Musk said, "That's false... [Zelenskyy is] not always truthful."

Breaking Defense reported that Sienik said Kyiv still did not have clarity from the Pentagon or SpaceX over the cause of the slow down or who may have ordered it, and it said the US Embassy did not respond to questions about the status of Starshield at the time. Himes’s funding threat raised the stakes for SpaceX’s broader government business, with Newsweek reporting that "billions of dollars in federal contracts" could be at issue if Congress restricts funding for SpaceX-developed systems.

Reporting for this sectionArs TechnicaEngadget