Trump Accuses Pope Leo XIV of Endangering Catholics Over Iran Nuclear Bomb
Image: Yeni Safak English

Trump Accuses Pope Leo XIV of Endangering Catholics Over Iran Nuclear Bomb

07 May, 2026.USA.19 sources

The story in 15 seconds

  • Trump publicly attacks Pope Leo XIV, straining US-Vatican relations.
  • Pope Leo XIV denounces Iran-related threats, advocates peace and diplomacy.
  • Americans oppose Trump's pope criticisms and back Leo’s peace appeals.

The divide · 1 of 3

Why Rubio meets Pope Leo

Frames the meeting as political reset versus stated humanitarian agenda.

Who skipped what

How each outlet frames it

Every outlet we compared, the headline it ran, and a link to the original article.

Source Diversity
19 sources
Western Mainstream
11
Other
4
Local Western
2
Western Alternative
1
West Asian
1

Local Western

Action News Jax
Action News Jax

A year in, what's on Pope Leo XIV's to-do list? And what has he done so far?

08 May, 2026

Read the original →
Detroit Catholic
Detroit Catholic

Americans disapprove of Trump's comments about Pope Leo XIV, poll shows

07 May, 2026

Read the original →

Western Mainstream

Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Australian Broadcasting Corporation

Bank hung up on pope when he tried to update his details, Chicago priest says

08 May, 2026

Read the original →
CNN
CNN

Six key things we learned about Pope Leo in his first year

08 May, 2026

Read the original →
El HuffPost
El HuffPost

Under the shadow of Francisco The Catalan journalist was one of the first to bet on the name Robert Francis Prevost, when the press ignored him in the Conclave odds, and defines the pope as a continuity of the dogma of his predecessor, Francisco. To explain this position, in a telephone conversation with El HuffPost, he recalls his first Apostolic Exhortation Dilexi te, in which he put at the center of his speech Christ and the poor, marginalized, refugees and immigrants. “[The new Pope] continues Francis’s movements, which invite the Church to leave the palaces and accompany the wounded of the world spiritually and in the material,” explains the Catalan correspondent in his conversation with this newspaper. “He will be a Pope of the 21st century.” Unlike Lozano, Jesús Bastante, deputy editor of Religión Digital, and author of El aprendiz de Gaudí (Esfera de los Libros, 2026), explains in conversation with El HuffPost that the doctrinal line followed by the new pope is very different from that of Francisco. “He’s a pope very different from Francisco. He’s a much more contemplative, less explosive, less prophetic and more organized.” “León’s will is to deepen the path started by Francisco, always prioritizing the unity of the Church.” This has a clear implication and “some issues can be cooled.” He believes topics such as “sexual morality, blessings of gays or issues related to liturgy” can be paused. “The more controversial issues either are cooling down, or are being left for later, when there is greater consensus,” he concludes on this. That said, everything related to synodality, to participation within the Church, and to the push for openness will be maintained. “The more social topics. The issues relating to synodality, the participation of the Church… will be his bet,” Bastante continues. First destination: Africa His first pontifical trip is a test of the pastoral continuity that characterizes Leo XIV’s early steps as head of the Catholic Church. “It is deeply symbolic. Africa is experiencing a new resource colonization and, like Pope Francis, Leo XIV visits the peripheries, where Catholicism is minority,” Lozano explains. His past is revealing, having been Bishop of Chiclayo (Peru) for years: “He knows both worlds.” During April, the pope Leo visited four countries in 11 days: Algeria, Cameroon, Angola and Equatorial Guinea. The objective, clearly pastoral: to address the needs of the continent where more than a fifth of the world’s Catholics live. According to statistics published by the Vatican, Africa is today the main growth engine of the Church and provides the majority of new baptisms and a growing number of priestly and religious vocations, with countries such as Angola and Cameroon among the most notable in seminarians. The center of gravity of world Catholicism thus moves south. For Bastante, this trip is “clearly foundational.” “It was personally decided by Leo XIV. The previous ones—to Turkey or the planned one to Spain—were already largely agreed upon,” he explains in his conversation with this newspaper. “He has shown that he is not afraid of big trips or contact with people. That said, his destinations are more predictable: Francis constantly improvised; Leo does not improvise. No surprises,” he ends. “This trip is a before-and-after,” he continues. “Africa is today the great nursery of vocations in the world, which reinforces the symbolism of the trip,” he explains. In addition, “there is a personal dimension: Leo is Augustinian and Saint Augustine was born in Hippo, one of the first places he visited in Algeria.” “An unprecedented tension” History could not be more ironic, and once again it has surprised with a first North American pope and Donald Trump in the White House. Bastante is clear: “An unprecedented and inevitable tension.” In recent months, the relationship between Leo XIV and the U.S. president has plainly shown the differences that distance them. The volley of reproaches and Trump’s continual provocations, posting on social networks photos posing as God or similar, have dominated headlines in the media, and even sparked a rupture between the Trump administration and Giorgia Meloni’s government, his biggest ally in Europe, which stands with the Bishop of Rome. During the pastoral trip to Africa, the Pontiff answered the American president after showing skepticism about his diplomacy. “I’m not afraid,” he said. “The gospel message is very clear: Blessed are the peacemakers. This is what I think I have to do, what the Church has to do. We are not politicians, we do not deal with international politics with the same perspective he may have. I believe in the gospel message that is the one about building peace,” he added in statements that circulated around the world. “Trump crossed a line when he threatened to destroy ‘an entire civilization’ in Iran, an admission of war crime. That is when the Pope said: ‘I will not bow to anyone.’ Defending dialogue does not mean silencing those barbarities,” Lozano explains, recalling the “grotesque provocations” of the president: “Dressing as the Pope, messianic images… It was necessary to say enough.” “He is not ready to broach that topic.” Moderate progressivism has characterized the first months of Leo XIV in the Vatican and has been the subject of scrutiny by the Church’s more conservative voices. Before being elevated to the highest office, Robert Prevost did not depart from the Church’s traditional stance on issues such as mandatory priestly celibacy. As El País reports, on issues such as the mandatory celibacy of priests, the Pope has kept silent, but on others, such as the ordination of women, he has been firm: “Clericalizing women does not necessarily solve a problem; it could generate a new one,” he said when he was Cardinal Prevost in 2023. On doctrinal advances regarding the rights of LGTBI+ people, under Pope Francis, which allowed the blessing of same-sex unions, the current Leo XIV stressed that the application of that declaration “should take into account the cultural differences of each religion.” But Prevost’s positions were even more radical. Then he lamented that the media and popular culture showed “sympathy for beliefs and practices that are in conflict with the Gospel,” such as “the homosexual lifestyle.” “It is true that he has shown himself very much against changing doctrine. But he has also said something interesting: he warned that Catholics are very obsessed with sexual morality and that the Bible is much more than that,” explains the expert. That said, he confirms that he is against blessing homosexual people. “There is a lot left to do and I think Prevost is not ready to broach that topic.” “He has withstood campaigns from the more conservative wing.” Both Bastante and Lozano conclude that he has been the target of smear campaigns by the more conservative wing that have sought to discredit his authority. Especially with allegedly false accusations about his attitude toward sexual abuse when he was Bishop in Peru. “The recent accusations are fabrications by the Sodalicio de Vida Cristiana, a very powerful organization in Peru that Francis dissolved before dying and that now seeks revenge,” Lozano explains in El HuffPost. “During the conclave they tried to reignite documentary forgeries against Prevost. All of it is false,” recalls the correspondent, who has an important list of sources beyond the gates of St. Peter’s. “These campaigns will be repeated, as happened with Francis: a dirty war driven by ultras. We’ll see them in the coming months,” he predicts. In this first year, he believes the new Pope has pushed investigations worldwide and “has forced,” for example, “to compensate the Spanish victims.” A position he shares with Bastante, who thinks that “institutionally there is still much to do.” “In his speeches he has been clear, but there is always more that can be done,” he ends. A look to the future Lozano notes that Leo XIV is aware of many realities surrounding current events, such as the power of the media, social networks and artificial intelligence. In the past year he has denounced the instrumentalization of religion in politics and “has warned of the power of radical minorities supported by the international far-right, finance and the great technological magnates.” “A pope prepared for the problems of the twenty-first century.”

09 May, 2026

Read the original →
EL PAÍS
EL PAÍS

Leo XIV: The first year of a centrist pope

09 May, 2026

Read the original →
National Catholic Register
National Catholic Register

A Year Into His Papacy, Pope Leo XIV ‘Still Difficult to Read’

08 May, 2026

Read the original →
RTVE.es
RTVE.es

The discreet pope: a year of Leo XIV's pontificate.

07 May, 2026

Read the original →
Sky TG24
Sky TG24

Papa Leone XIV, un anno dall'elezione: il bilancio dei primi 12 mesi di Pontificato

08 May, 2026

Read the original →
The Guardian
The Guardian

Vatican stresses need for peace as Rubio meets pope amid strained relations

07 May, 2026

Read the original →
The Guardian
The Guardian

Americans hail Pope Leo XIV as ‘breath of fresh air’ one year in, as Trump clashes linger

08 May, 2026

Read the original →
The Washington Post
The Washington Post

Poll finds broad rejection of religion-related messages from Trump, Hegseth

07 May, 2026

Read the original →
USA Today
USA Today

Papal peacemaker? Making nice with Pope Leo is Marco Rubio’s latest job

07 May, 2026

Read the original →

Other

Corriere Roma
Corriere Roma

A Year of Prevost. The Many Small Moves for the Unity of the Church and His America.

07 May, 2026

Read the original →
National Catholic Reporter
National Catholic Reporter

The future Pope Leo XIV grew up amid a changing Chicago

08 May, 2026

Read the original →
Religion News Service
Religion News Service

Rubio visits Vatican amid escalating tensions between Trump and Pope Leo

07 May, 2026

Read the original →
U.S. Catholic
U.S. Catholic

Readers weigh in on the first year of Leo’s papacy

08 May, 2026

Read the original →

Western Alternative

EWTN News
EWTN News

Poll: Most Americans dislike Trump’s jabs at Pope Leo XIV, favor Leo’s call for peace

07 May, 2026

Read the original →

West Asian

Yeni Safak English
Yeni Safak English

Rubio meets Pope Leo XIV at Vatican amid tensions

07 May, 2026

Read the original →

Full story

Rubio Meets Pope Leo

President Donald Trump has been throwing broadsides at Pope Leo XIV, accusing the first American-born pontiff of “endangering” Catholics with his opposition to the Iran war, and the secretary of state has said Marco Rubio’s Vatican meeting on May 7 involves urgent matters including humanitarian aid to Cuba and the persecution of Christians.

Rubio’s trip to see the pontiff provides an opportunity to mend a rift

USA TodayUSA Today

Rubio insists his visit is not about making nice with the pope, but Republican pollster Brent Buchanan, founder of the Washington, DC-based firm Cygnal, said: “It’s an unnecessary fight among a key voter group.”

Image from Action News Jax
Action News JaxAction News Jax

In a May 4 interview with conservative radio host Hugh Hewitt, Trump accused Leo of being “OK” with Iran having a nuclear weapon, and Trump told Hewitt: “I think he’s endangering a lot of Catholics, and a lot of people.”

Asked during a May 6 event in the Oval Office what message he wants Rubio to deliver, Trump said his "only message" is that Iran can't get a nuclear bomb, as the ongoing attacks could complicate any effort by Rubio to reach a détente with the religious leader who is also a head of state.

SourcesUSA TodayUSA Today

Poll Shows Disapproval

A Washington Post-ABC News-Ipsos poll published May 6 found most Americans disapprove of President Donald Trump’s comments about Pope Leo XIV, with the poll conducted April 24-28 and reporting that Pope Leo has a 25-point net favorable margin among Americans overall.

The poll found 41% favorable, 16% unfavorable, and 43% saying they have no opinion of the pontiff, while Trump’s approval rating dropped to 37%, down from 45% in February 2025.

Image from Australian Broadcasting Corporation
Australian Broadcasting CorporationAustralian Broadcasting Corporation

Two-thirds of Americans, 66%, said they had a positive reaction to Pope Leo asking Americans on April 7 to contact their congressional lawmakers to work for peace and to reject war, while 57% had a negative reaction to Trump posting "I don't want a Pope who thinks it's OK for Iran to have a Nuclear Weapon."

Among American Catholics, 70% said they had a positive reaction to Pope Leo asking Americans to contact Congress, and 61% said they had a negative reaction to Trump’s post about the pope and nuclear weapons, and the poll also reported that 76% disapproved of Trump’s social media post threatening that "a whole civilization will die tonight" if Iran did not make an agreement with the U.S.

Public Reaction and Stakes

As Pope Leo XIV concludes his first year as the first American pope on Friday, the Guardian reported Americans shared how they feel about the 70-year-old pontiff who has increasingly found himself at odds with Donald Trump.

Pope Leo is bringing Jesus’s teachings forward instead of church dogma

The GuardianThe Guardian

Brock Horton, a 69-year-old retired public school teacher in San Antonio, Texas, said: “Pope Leo is bringing Jesus’s teachings forward instead of church dogma … If you can’t welcome strangers and treat everyone with love and dignity, you have no place leading anyone,” and Kelly Raghavan, a 64-year-old medical interpreter in San Diego, California, hailed the pope’s willingness to speak out.

The Guardian also reported that Trump accused the pope of “endangering a lot of Catholics” through his condemnation of the war, which has killed at least 3,400 Iranians and 13 US service members, and Trump has described the pope as “weak on crime and terrible for foreign policy” while Pope Leo dismissed the criticism by saying: “I’m not afraid of the Trump administration.”

In parallel, the Washington Post-ABC News-Ipsos poll described in the Washington Post said Americans are deeply uncomfortable with recent religion-related statements by Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, as the comments overwhelmingly criticize Trump and question his moral values and religious sincerity.

NewsCord Digest

Get every USA story like this one, in one email

Daily or weekly, only the topics you follow, each with the difference our analysis found across the outlets covering it.

Set up your digest

More on USA