Sportsupdated 18m ago3 min read
Archive photo · 23 June 2026Tuchel Sparks England Goalkeeper Debate With Jordan Pickford and James Trafford Rotation
“Jordan Pickford is still England’s number one, but the question of who follows him is now being asked in public.”
“Pickford remains Tuchel's undisputed first choice, he believes the head coach's recent strategy is a sensible one.”
Photo: Bryan Berlin / WikiPortraits, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped for layout
This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.
Tuchel rotated Pickford and James Trafford in the last international break, sparking competition debate. Tuchel maintains Pickford as England's first-choice despite Trafford's form.
Save coverage image
Tuchel rotates keepers
England head coach Thomas Tuchel sparked debate by alternating Jordan Pickford and Leeds United goalkeeper James Trafford during the last international break, with Trafford playing in the 3-2 loss to Spain and the victory against Czech Republic before Pickford returned for the Wembley win against the Czechs and the 7-0 rout in Croatia. England then meet Croatia at Wembley on Thursday before facing Spain in Madrid on Sunday, and Tuchel’s suggestion that he may use a rotation system again kept scrutiny on England’s goalkeeping position. BBC Sport highlighted Pickford’s record since his debut in a 0-0 draw against Germany at Wembley in 2017, and it cited Opta stats showing Pickford has made only two errors leading to goals in 93 appearances, with 46 clean sheets and a 74% save ratio.
“England meet Croatia at Wembley on Thursday before facing the biggest test of their Uefa Nations League campaign when they play Spain in Madrid on Sunday.”
Paul Robinson told BBC Sport that Tuchel’s approach made sense because “We are so guilty as a nation of taking one goalkeeper to a tournament who has 70, 80, 90 caps, then the two of three below him could have less than double figures combined.” The debate also centered on Trafford’s early England experience, with BBC Sport noting he is 24 and has four caps, including two competitive appearances, as Tuchel prepared for a situation where Pickford might not be available or might drop in form.
Pickford still first choice
Tuchel maintained that Pickford remains England’s number one, and he framed the rotation as competition rather than a change in the pecking order. The Arabic-language outlet الجريدة نت said Tuchel told the public: “No, Pickford remains the first-choice goalkeeper, and nothing has changed.” BBC Sport’s Paul Robinson also argued that the rotation was planning rather than threat, saying Trafford only challenges Pickford “if Jordan Pickford isn’t playing very well and Jordan Pickford is making errors”.
The False 9 described the same core question in public terms, saying “Pickford or Trafford: BBC Asks If England's No 1 Faces Real Competition,” while it also stated that Tuchel suggested he may rotate the goalkeepers again across the two games. As England prepared for Croatia at Wembley and Spain in Madrid, the competing narratives kept the goalkeeper debate alive even as Tuchel’s stance stayed consistent that Pickford was still the default starter.
What happens next
The next England matches were positioned as a test of Tuchel’s management of the goalkeeping file, with the BBC noting England host Croatia at Wembley on Thursday and then travel to face Spain in Madrid on Sunday. The False 9 set the match times as 19:45 on Thursday 12 November for Croatia at home and 19:45 on Sunday 15 November for Spain in Madrid, and it said Tuchel’s rotation plan would keep the argument alive. Yorkshire Evening Post quoted Leeds United striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin saying, “I think we're fortunate now that we've got two exceptional goalkeepers,” as he argued that competition for minutes should be appreciated rather than treated as a problem.
“England host Croatia in the Nations League at 19:45 on Thursday 12 November, then travel to face Spain in Madrid at 19:45 on Sunday 15 November.”
The same Yorkshire Evening Post report added that Calvert-Lewin insisted, “I don't think that can be so quickly disregarded at all,” referring to Pickford’s nine years at Everton and his England career. With Tuchel’s camp already including Pickford, Trafford, and Jason Steele as the goalkeepers in the group, the sources framed the immediate consequence as a continuing contest for the England No.1 spot during the Nations League run.