Rows of servers in a Wikimedia Foundation data centre

Editorial Analysis

The ADL told AI companies to stop citing Wikipedia. It has not shown one false fact there.

…views

Photo: Victor Grigas / Wikimedia Foundation, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

In four numbers

  • 0

    false facts the ADL showed were added to Wikipedia, per Tech for Palestine

  • 4

    US government letters to Wikimedia in six months of 2025

  • $96M

    from pro-Israel PACs to 23 House signatories, per Tech for Palestine

  • 17

    efforts to skew Wikipedia towards Israel since 2001, per Tech for Palestine

In March 2025 the Anti-Defamation League told the companies that build AI chatbots to stop citing Wikipedia. The Heritage Foundation had already pitched a plan to unmask Wikipedia's editors with facial recognition and hacked passwords. Within six months a US Attorney, 23 members of the House, the chairs of the House Oversight Committee and the chair of the Senate Commerce Committee had all written to the Wikimedia Foundation, the charity that runs the encyclopaedia. The ADL report that members of Congress cited does not show one false fact added to Wikipedia.

That last finding comes from Israel Is Attacking Wikipedia, a 221-page report published this month by Tech for Palestine, which goes through the ADL's accusation claim by claim. We checked the public record around it. The ADL's recommendation, the Heritage pitch, the letters and the ADL's own account of the pressure are all on file. Here they are in order of what they try to change: what AI tells you, who is allowed to write Wikipedia, and whether the charity behind it can stand up to Washington.

The record they are fighting over

Start with what Wikipedia says. Its article on Gaza opens: "The Gaza genocide is the ongoing, intentional, and systematic destruction of the Palestinian people in the Gaza Strip carried out by Israel". That sentence is the record of Israel's genocide in Gaza as genocide scholars, UN bodies and human rights groups have documented it. It is also the kind of sentence a task force, an audit and a list of approved sources could be used to remove, and the sentence an AI model stops repeating once it is told to stop citing Wikipedia.

First, what AI tells you

Wikipedia is where search engines and AI chatbots get much of what they tell people. Senator Ted Cruz's own announcement on Wikipedia notes that its articles "appear in more than 80 percent of desktop search results for common queries". The ADL's March 2025 report, Editing for Hate, included a recommendation addressed to the companies that build large language models:

“Curb how LLMs use Wikipedia in citations: Don't cite Wikipedia but other relevant and trustworthy sources, like Reuters.”

ADL, Editing for Hate, 18 March 2025Read the original

The ADL has the access to press the point. In October 2026 an article produced with the ADL in The Jerusalem Post said the organisation "works directly with the companies building it, testing models from OpenAI, Anthropic, Alphabet, Meta and X". Tech for Palestine reads the two together: the aim is to pull AI away from Wikipedia, which is built on scholarly consensus, and towards US news coverage, which leans towards Israel.

Then, the people who write it

Most Wikipedia editors write under pseudonyms. In January 2025 The Forward reported on a Heritage Foundation pitch to supporters of its Project Esther:

“Employees of Heritage… said they plan to use facial recognition software and a database of hacked usernames and passwords in order to identify contributors to the online encyclopedia, who mostly work under pseudonyms.”

The Forward, 7 January 2025Read the original

The Forward added that it was unclear whether the work had begun.

The ADL wants the pseudonyms gone by another route. Its second report, published in October 2026, asks for identity verification for editors. Tech for Palestine's report names four groups it says are targeting Wikipedia's editors, and says some editors who were doxxed have received death threats.

Then Washington turned on the charity that runs it

  1. 24 April 2025

    The interim US Attorney for DC questions Wikimedia's charity status

    Ed Martin writes that the Foundation "is allowing foreign actors to manipulate information and spread propaganda to the American public" and raises its tax-exempt status. His letter does not mention the ADL.

    Source

  2. 30 April 2025

    23 members of the House cite the ADL

    A bipartisan letter led by Debbie Wasserman Schultz, a Democrat, and Don Bacon, a Republican, tells Wikimedia: "A recent report by the ADL (Anti-Defamation League) identified a group of approximately 30 Wikipedia editors".

    Source

  3. 27 August 2025

    House Oversight opens an inquiry

    Republican chairs James Comer and Nancy Mace demand records from Wikimedia. Their first footnote is the ADL report: "One recent report raised troubling questions about potentially systematic efforts to advance antisemitic and anti-Israel information in Wikipedia articles".

    Source

  4. October 2025

    Ted Cruz repeats the claim

    The Republican chair of the Senate Commerce Committee does not name the ADL in his announcement, but repeats its allegation: "a coordinated group of editors pushed antisemitic narratives on Wikipedia while whitewashing the activities of groups like Hamas."

    Source

Two of those four letters cite the ADL report by name and a third repeats its allegation as fact. Tech for Palestine says the 23 House members who signed the April letter have received more than $96 million from pro-Israel PACs. That figure is its own count. A donation does not prove it bought a letter. It does tell you who these politicians answer to when the subject is Israel.

The ADL's own account

On 15 October 2026 the ADL published its second report, Damage Done. It describes "sustained, multi-front external pressure on the platform", and lists where the pressure came from:

“The pressure came from several directions: congressional scrutiny, including a House Committee on Oversight investigation and a bipartisan Congressional letter from 23 members, federal inquiries from the Department of Justice and the Senate Commerce Committee; enforcement work by Wikipedia's NPOV-policy editors, ADL reporting, and broader media scrutiny.”

ADL, Damage Done, 15 October 2026Read the original

The ADL does not say it directed Congress or the Justice Department. It does list its own reporting among the sources of pressure, and it asks for more: a Wikimedia Foundation task force on antisemitic bias, an audit of articles edited by banned editors, identity verification for editors and continued oversight hearings.

All of it rests on a report that shows no false fact

“ADL has found clear evidence that a group of at least 30 editors circumvent Wikipedia's policies in concert to introduce antisemitic narratives, anti-Israel bias, and misleading information.”

ADL, Editing for Hate, 18 March 2025Read the original

The report was co-produced with Builders For Tomorrow, which the ADL describes as a venture philanthropy and research organisation led by people from the tech industry. Its case rests on statistics about how often the 30 editors worked on the same articles and talked to each other. What it does not contain is the thing an accusation of this kind needs: the false statements those editors are supposed to have put on the page.

Dr Shira Klein, chair of history at Chapman University, is a scholar of antisemitism and Wikipedia whose work the ADL report itself cites. She read it and wrote this in The Forward:

“But where is the evidence of editors repeatedly misrepresenting or contradicting peer-reviewed literature? There is none. The report simply wants us to take the ADL's word for it.”

Dr Shira Klein, The Forward, 16 May 2025Read the original

Tech for Palestine traced each claim in the ADL report back to the Wikipedia edits and sources it cites. Its conclusion: "No claim survived scrutiny. It doesn't show a single false fact, or any antisemitic content added to Wikipedia." Its summary lists what it found instead:

  • methodological flaws and cherry-picked evidence;
  • Arabic content that was mistranslated, in a section on Arabic Wikipedia that the summary says shows little knowledge of Islam or Arabic culture;
  • evidence that was manipulated or misrepresented;
  • inconsistencies in the ADL's own data;
  • invented, scientific-sounding terms that make ordinary Wikipedia editing look sinister.

On the central charge, the summary says the ADL picked editors it did not like and fitted statistical correlations to a conclusion it had already reached. It calls the claimed collusion "likely fabricated". That is Tech for Palestine's judgement, and the group is not a bystander: the ADL's reports name it. What anyone can check is Klein's point. Eighteen months on, the ADL has still not published the false facts. The editors it named were not banned for adding false information.

It has been tried before

Groups have tried to bend the encyclopaedia before. Tech for Palestine documents 17 pro-Israel efforts to manipulate Wikipedia since 2001, nine of them still active. Two are well documented: CAMERA's covert editing campaign in 2008, which ended with editors banned, and the Yesha Council's 2010 courses training settlers to edit. Those efforts failed because Wikipedia's volunteers hold articles to published scholarship. The new approach goes around the volunteers, to the AI companies, to Congress and to the Foundation.

What Tech for Palestine asks for

  • The Wikimedia Foundation should recognise it is under attack from organisations with the resources of a state, and move out of the United States.
  • Congress should investigate the letters its own members sent.
  • Journalists should stop repeating ADL claims about antisemitism without checking them, and should say that the ADL is a pro-Israel lobby group when they report them.

Read the full report at techforpalestine.org/wikipedia-report. It is published by Tech for Palestine.

The ADL made an accusation it could not support. Congress treated it as fact, and the ADL told AI companies to look elsewhere. Wikipedia is still standing because its editors answer to evidence, and that is exactly what this campaign is trying to change.

Conversation

Be specific, respectful and constructive. Comments are public to readers who can access this article. Publishers can hold or remove comments.

Loading the conversation…