On 17 November the Labour government published Alan Milburn's review of young people and work, From a Welfare State to a Working State. The same day the cabinet endorsed it, promised a White Paper in the new year, and made Milburn chair of a new Youth Opportunities Unit that reports to Prime Minister Andy Burnham and delivers his own review.
Most of the headlines were about getting young people into work. Far fewer said how the review pays for it, which is by cutting disabled young people's benefits.
The biggest of those benefits is PIP, the Personal Independence Payment. It is the main disability benefit for adults, and it helps with the extra costs of a long-term illness or disability, such as getting around, care and equipment. It does not depend on income, and it is paid whether or not someone has a job. About 465,000 people aged 16 to 24 in England and Wales were getting it in 2025/26.
What Milburn wants to cut
For everyone under 25, the review recommends:
- The Universal Credit health element is abolished, along with the Work Capability Assessment.
- PIP is replaced by a local discretionary fund, a narrower Additional Cost Allowance, and an insurance scheme for the most severely disabled that few are meant to reach.
- It applies to people already claiming, at their next reassessment. Milburn says that if it applied only to new claimants, "The fiscal benefits would also be lower and slower."
- Take part or lose your benefit. Young people on the health element have no work conditions today. Under Milburn's plan they would have a new "duty to engage", and anyone who "persistently refuses to engage" would "ultimately lose their Youth Allowance benefit". Milburn says this "is not intended to be a punitive sanctions regime" and that sanctions "should be rare". It is a punishment all the same. The only permanent exemption is for those on the new insurance for the most severely disabled, and of that route he writes: "Intentionally it should be a very high bar."
Milburn claims young people with "anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism", who he says are the majority of new PIP claimants, "should be particular beneficiaries" of his plan. Later in the same report he tells them what that means.
“The changes proposed here will make some young people less well off at first: the health element of Universal Credit is gone, and for many the settlement that replaces PIP would pay less cash, at least to begin with.”
Alan Milburn, From a Welfare State to a Working State, 17 November 2026Read the original
Apparently, being "less well off" makes them "particular beneficiaries".
The review counts on £3.6bn a year in welfare savings by 2036/37. Of the £8.8bn the government expects to spend on young people's health and disability benefits that year, £8.1bn is PIP. So most of the saving has to come from PIP, a benefit that helps with the extra costs of disability and which, as Milburn admits, "is not conditional on being out of work and many recipients do work."
Very little of that money is saved. By the review's own figures, £5.8bn of new spending in 2036/37 is matched by about £6bn in welfare savings and other gains to the public finances, which leaves a net saving of around £200m a year. The money is moved out of disabled young people's benefits and into new services and £1.1bn a year of payments to employers for hiring.
The review's suspect numbers
The review's headline promises all rest on one assumption: that 440,000 more young people will be in work.
- The jobs need a rate Britain has not seen. The model takes the share of young people not in education, employment or training down to 6.8%. The review itself says that rate "has barely been below 10% in 25 years."
- The poverty figure includes the assumed jobs. The review says 50,000 fewer people would be in poverty, but only after those 440,000 jobs exist. It gives no figure for the benefit cuts on their own. When Labour planned its 2025 disability cuts, the department's own assessment found they would push 250,000 more people into poverty.
- Nobody will say how many young people lose PIP. The savings model sorts young claimants into the new benefits or out of eligibility using "illustrative assumptions". The proportions are not published.
Milburn knows what a cut does without the jobs. "Cutting benefits on its own moves relatively few people into work," he writes. "For most, it simply reduces income."
The minister selling the plan misdescribed its headline figure. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told the Commons that the country spends "£25 on the consequences of inactivity for every pound that we spend on opportunity". That makes it sound as if the £25 is spent on young people who are not working. It is not.
The review's own annex says the £25 is every pound of Universal Credit, PIP, Disability Living Allowance and the other main benefits paid to anyone aged 16 to 24. That includes young people who have a job, and disabled young people whose PIP has nothing to do with whether they work. The £1 counts only the department's own employment programmes and a tenth of the Jobcentre budget, so what the country spends on colleges, sixth forms and apprenticeships is left out. McFadden compared nearly all benefit spending on young people with a small part of the spending on their opportunities, and labelled the former "the consequences of inactivity".
We asked the Department for Work and Pensions how many young people would lose PIP, what the cuts would do to poverty before any assumed jobs, and whether it stands by McFadden's description of the £25. It gave neither number and did not answer on the £25. It told us only that impact assessments will be published in the usual way.
Who the government did not listen to
Labour had two other reviews to draw on. One was led by a clinician. The other is being written with disabled people. Milburn's plan ignores what the first found and does not wait for the second.
The clinician. Professor Peter Fonagy's review of mental health, ADHD and autism reported to the Health Secretary on 9 October. It found that "The rise in mental health problems is real, is affecting everyday functioning and cannot be explained by greater awareness alone". It also found that when people's incomes fall, their mental health gets worse.
“First, the design of the benefits system is itself a mental health intervention, for better or worse. The rollout of Universal Credit in England was associated with a 6.6 percentage-point increase in psychological distress among those affected”
Professor Peter Fonagy's review, Independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism, 9 October 2026Read the original
Milburn's report cites the Fonagy review 14 times. It never mentions this evidence.
Disabled people. After Labour MPs rebelled against the 2025 cuts, ministers promised that PIP would not change until the Timms review, which is being written jointly with disabled people, had finished. Its interim report in July said PIP is "widely described as essential to financial stability and independent living". Only 2% of the people who responded to it put the rise in mental health conditions among young people down to exaggeration or overdiagnosis.
The Timms review has not reported. Milburn recommends replacing PIP for under-25s anyway, and the cabinet has endorsed his plan. We asked the department to rule out changing PIP for under-25s before Timms reports. It would not. It said it will consider Milburn's recommendations "alongside the Timms Review".
A government that promises disabled people a say, then adopts a plan to cut their benefits before they have had it, is treating that promise with contempt.
Who the government did listen to
So who did Labour listen to? Alan Milburn was Tony Blair's Health Secretary, the minister who opened NHS treatment to private providers. Since leaving office he has advised businesses including the private equity firm Bridgepoint and PwC. His consultancy, AM Strategy Ltd, paid £4.89m in dividends in the four years to March 2023, according to its accounts.
Here is what the records and the replies to our questions show about PwC:
- Milburn advises PwC through his own company. The Department of Health and Social Care's register of interests lists him as "an adviser to PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC)". An earlier register says he provides those services "through A.M. Strategy Ltd".
- The government paid PwC to support his review. PwC confirmed this to us on the record.
- PwC's lead partner for the department worked on it. Milburn's acknowledgements thank "Katie Johnston from PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC)" for "lending me their expertise". PwC's own announcement in January 2025 says Johnston is "PwC's lead partner for the Department of Work and Pensions". The department told us she was appointed under its contract with PwC.
- The report declares none of it. There is no statement of the author's interests anywhere in its 278 pages.
We put this to PwC. Its reply, in full:
“PwC UK was contracted by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to provide support on the Young People and Work Review, following a competitive process run by DWP. Alan Milburn is an adviser to PwC UK. His advisory work for PwC is separate from his work on the Review.
PwC has strict processes in place to prevent conflicts of interest.”
A PwC spokesperson, 19 November 2026
And the Department for Work and Pensions:
“Alan Milburn declared his relevant interests to the Department and it assessed and managed any potential conflicts in line with existing guidance and processes. There is no requirement for these to be published in the final report.
We will carefully consider all the recommendations alongside the Timms Review and will set out next steps on welfare reform in the coming weeks before a White Paper in the new year.”
A DWP spokesperson, 19 November 2026
That is a conflict of interest, and the government chose not to tell the public about it. The author of a government review advises a firm through his own company, and the government paid that firm to help him write it.
PwC did not tell us what it was paid, whether it was paying Milburn's company while he wrote the review, or whether it will bid for work delivering what the review recommends. That last question matters, because the review's centrepiece is a new Youth Opportunity Service in every area of England, and Johnston leads PwC's work for local and devolved government.
Nothing we have seen shows that the review was written to benefit PwC. But nobody outside government can check, because the declarations, the safeguards and the contract are all unpublished. Rules on declaring interests exist so that the public can see for itself that a decision was made for the right reasons. Here the public has been told to take it on trust.
We also sent questions for Milburn through the Cabinet Office, which runs his new unit, including whether he will keep advising PwC while he chairs it. The Cabinet Office has not responded.
Tory policy, then Starmer's, now Burnham's
None of this is new thinking. In April 2024 Conservative Prime Minister Rishi Sunak announced a "new welfare settlement for Britain". Milburn's subtitle is "a new settlement for the next generation". Here are the two side by side.
Rishi Sunak, 19 April 2024
“we need to be more ambitious about helping people back to work. And more honest about the risk of over-medicalising the everyday challenges and worries of life.”
Rishi Sunak, Prime Minister's speech on welfare, 19 April 2024Read the original
Alan Milburn, 17 November 2026
“The business model is essentially cash for diagnosis”
Alan Milburn, on private providers of ADHD and autism assessments, From a Welfare State to a Working State, 17 November 2026Read the original
Sunak's government said it would consider "shifting the responsibility for issuing the fit note away from already stretched GPs". Milburn writes: "Responsibility for long-term sickness absence should be moved out of general practice".
Labour won the 2024 election, and in March 2025 Keir Starmer's government announced about £5bn of cuts to health and disability benefits. Labour MPs rebelled and the government backed down on PIP. In November 2025 it commissioned Milburn.
Then Starmer went, and Andy Burnham was sold as the change: Labour's turn to the left, and its answer to Zack Polanski's Greens. Burnham had urged Labour MPs to vote against the 2025 cuts. Four of the ministers now in his cabinet opposed them too: Louise Haigh and Anneliese Midgley signed the amendment to block the bill, Angela Rayner argued in a leaked memo for tax rises instead, and Miatta Fahnbulleh named the cuts to disabled people's support among Starmer's mistakes when she resigned.
That cabinet has now endorsed the kind of cut its own members fought. Burnham's Chancellor, John Healey, told the BBC in October: "We have to bring the benefits bill down."
And it will not stop at 25. Milburn calls young people's benefits "just the tip of a far bigger potential iceberg". He says his design "could be applied to the older cohort of claimants" and tells the government to "act with urgency" on a new system for everyone aged 25 and over. Burnham agrees. He told The Times that the "same philosophy" could be applied "right through the age range". Disability and incapacity benefits for working-age people cost £55bn a year, and the plan for under-25s is the model for what comes next.
In 2010, when Milburn went to advise David Cameron's coalition, Burnham called it "a return to the old politics of New Labour at its worse". Sixteen years later Burnham has given the same man a unit at the centre of government and the job of redesigning support for disabled young people.
What is still unpublished
- How many young people would lose PIP under the review's own assumptions.
- What the cuts would do to poverty before any assumed jobs.
- What Milburn declared to the department, and how the conflict with PwC was managed.
- What PwC was paid, and whether it can bid to deliver the review's recommendations.
The White Paper is due in the new year. Disabled young people are being asked to accept less money now, on the promise of jobs that exist only in a model, from a review whose author advises a firm the government paid to help write it.
How we did this
Sources and right of reply
Figures and quotations are from the review, its analytical annex and data tables, Pat McFadden's Commons statement of 17 November, the Fonagy review's final report, the Timms review's interim report, DHSC's registers of board members' interests, AM Strategy Ltd's accounts at Companies House and PwC's announcement of 23 January 2025. We sent written questions to the Department for Work and Pensions, the Cabinet Office (including questions for Alan Milburn), PwC and the Department of Health and Social Care on the evening of 18 November 2026. PwC and DWP replied on 19 November and their on-the-record statements appear in full above. DWP also told us that Katie Johnston was appointed under its contract with PwC. DHSC confirmed Milburn remains its lead non-executive director and referred questions about the Youth Opportunities Unit to the Cabinet Office. The Cabinet Office has not responded. Freedom of Information requests for the PwC contract, Milburn's declarations and the unpublished PIP figures are with DWP and the Cabinet Office.
Conversation
Be specific, respectful and constructive. Comments are public to readers who can access this article. Publishers can hold or remove comments.
Loading the conversation…
