The Guardian, by Fiona Harvey, on Climate, 17 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findings

We do not republish articles from The Guardian. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.

Read the original article on theguardian.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

The article reports a Carbon Brief analysis ranking Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia as the biggest exporters of fossil fuel CO2 since 1850, and it explains that the ranking counts emissions by where the fuel was extracted. Its two findings are minor: a headline that states the ranking as settled fact, and a loaded phrase that calls Saudi Arabia a standing obstructive force with only recent negotiating positions behind it. Its named sources, including the Saudi ministry, are attributed.

  1. Uses a loaded word

    Minor

    “an obstructive force at the annual UN climate summits”

    Why this matters
    In the outlet's own voice the phrase 'an obstructive force' gives the country (Saudi Arabia, named in S4) a standing verdict on its conduct across many years of summits.
    The impression it gives
    Saudi Arabia has a long, established record of blocking UN climate talks.
    The context
    The only conduct the article cites is recent: many countries, Saudi Arabia among them, have hardened their negotiating positions since Dubai (S20).

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“have hardened their negotiating positions since Dubai”
  2. Headline goes beyond the article

    Minor

    “named as biggest CO2 exporters in history”

    Why this matters
    The headline states the ranking as settled fact, using the passive 'named as' with no source named, while the body says it is one analysis.
    The impression it gives
    Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are plainly the biggest CO2 exporters in history, as an uncontested finding.
    The context
    The body (S1) says the ranking comes from one analysis, by Carbon Brief, that counts emissions by where the fuel was extracted, a method the article itself says differs from most analyses (S15). Saudi Arabia disputes that method (S32).

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“apportions responsibility for CO 2 emissions based on the country extracting the fossil fuels”
    • Elsewhere in the article“It would therefore be misleading to place responsibility”

    Show it in the article

What it gets right

  • “apportions responsibility for CO 2 emissions based on the country extracting the fossil fuels, in contrast to most analyses”

    It names the analysis and its source, Carbon Brief, and says how it counts emissions, which the whole ranking depends on.

  • “A representative for the Saudi ministry of energy told the Guardian”

    It attributes Saudi Arabia's 1% figure to a named office, so the reader knows it is the country's claim.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Guardian

  1. 17 NovFifa accused of climate ‘record of failure’ due to Aramco deal and tournament expansion0.0
  2. 16 NovCop31 summit spells out stark warnings for athletes and sport organisations0.0
  3. 16 NovDelaware hit by rare November tornado0.0
  4. 16 NovWeakening UK electric vehicle targets would hurt car industry, ministers told3.0
  5. 16 NovControversial efforts to suck carbon from atmosphere championed at UN climate talks0.0

Everything we scored from The Guardian