Do not bow to MP pressure to block Rosebank, business leaders tell Andy Burnham
Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding
We do not republish articles from The Scotsman. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The Scotsman reports the opposing Labour letter as signed by 'up to 100' MPs, while other coverage of the same story gives 75 signatures so far, though the article hedges the figure with 'reportedly'. This is a minor gap in precision and does not change the picture of a sizeable Labour rebellion.
Uses figures that mislead
Minor
“a group of up to 100 Labour backbenchers”
Why this matters
The words give the number of Labour MPs who signed the opposing letter as up to 100 and say they have signed it.
The impression it gives
That up to 100 Labour MPs have already put their names to the letter.
The context
Coverage of the same story reports that 75 Labour MPs have signed and that up to 100 could sign later.
“have urged the Prime Minister not to go ahead with Rosebank”
Why this matters
The words repeat the figure of up to 100 as a count of MPs who have urged the Prime Minister, so the unconfirmed number reaches the reader a second time.
The impression it gives
That up to 100 MPs have already urged the Prime Minister to block Rosebank.
The context
Coverage reports 75 signatures, and gives 100 only as a figure campaigners hope will be reached later.