We do not republish articles from The Guardian. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The article reports Chris Evans's research that British businesses run by Bank of England directors profited from enslavement at El Cobre in Cuba after British abolition. The headline says they illegally profited, but the body says slavery was legal in Cuba at the time, attributes the illegal trade to French and Spanish merchants, and reports that neither Grenfell nor Thompson appears to have faced legal penalties. The headline's claim of illegality therefore goes beyond what the article reports.
Headline goes beyond the article
Serious
“illegally profited”
Why this matters
The headline calls the directors' profits illegal.
The impression it gives
The reader believes the Bank of England directors broke the law by profiting from enslavement in Cuba.
The context
The body says slavery was legal in Cuba at the time, attributes the illegal trade to French and Spanish merchants, and reports that neither Grenfell nor Thompson appears to have faced legal penalties.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“slavery was legal in Cuba”
Elsewhere in the article“involving French and Spanish merchants”
Elsewhere in the article“Neither Grenfell nor Thompson appears to have faced legal penalties”
Research by Chris Evans says British businesses run by Bank of England directors profited from enslavement at El Cobre in Cuba after slavery's abolition in the British empire. Slavery was legal in Cuba at the time, and the illegal trade is attributed to French and Spanish merchants.