The Spectator opinion piece, on UK Politics, 2 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

Labour kickstarts Green council divorce proceedings

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

Labour has today formally begun divorce proceedings with Green council groups that failed to disavow the antisemitic ‘Zionism is Racism’ motion. Co-operation agreements in 11 local authorities are set to end. In a surprising twist, , Green councillors were handed an ultimatum last month: distance themselves from the policy or stop working with Labour colleagues on town halls. The responses were reviewed by Labour’s ruling National Executive Committee, which confirmed today that the conditions had not been met in 11 local authorities.

Among them are Derbyshire Dales, Sheffield, Wealden, West Devon, West Suffolk and Warwick. Six councils did meet the conditions set by Labour chair Bridget Phillipson: rejecting the policy and calling on the party’s national leadership to reconsider it. Those ever so slightly more principled councils – the bar being extremely low – are Broadland, Monmouthshire, North Somerset, Rother, West Oxfordshire and West Sussex. Commenting on the break-up, Phillipson said: Labour has been clear from the start that the “Zionism is Racism” policy crosses a line and we cannot work with any party that supports it – at any level of government.

This isn’t an issue of party politics; it’s about doing what is right and upholding the values anyone holding public office should share. The Labour Party fought hard to root out antisemitism within our own party and ensure it had no place in our politics. Our action is a demonstration of how today’s Labour Party will not shirk from the responsibility we have to uphold those same standards in our relationships with other parties. Responding, a Green spokesperson said: ‘We are a democratic party that trusts local leaders to make the right decisions for the people they represent.

The range of responses to the ultimatums reflects the diversity and anti racist nature of our Party and of local circumstances and partnerships across the country. ‘The Green Party believes top-down directives to break up and disrupt locally-run services are not in the interests of the residents we represent. We trust local communities, local councillors and local leaders to know what is best for them. We ask that others do the same.’

Read the original article on spectator.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The Spectator reports Labour ending co-operation with Green groups in 11 councils. In its own voice it says Andy Burnham has a 'track record of pandering to Islamists', and nothing in the piece backs that charge.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

  1. Smears a named person

    Serious

    “given Andy Burnham’s track record of pandering to Islamists”

    Why this matters
    The Spectator states as settled fact, in its own voice, that Andy Burnham has a 'track record of pandering to Islamists'.
    The impression it gives
    The Labour leader has an established history of courting extremists, so his action against the Greens is out of character.
    The context
    The article offers no example, source or quote for this charge. The same day's coverage reports Burnham saying Labour would have 'nothing to do' with the policy, and the article itself shows his party taking a hard line. The word 'Islamists' is the outlet's own label, attached to unnamed people with no evidence.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Spectator

  1. 2 NovHas Sayeeda Warsi’s appointment as Islamophobia tsar been blocked?3.0
  2. 2 NovAndy Burnham’s fatal show of weakness3.0
  3. 1 NovTories tool up for economy scrap0.0
  4. 1 NovThe pro-EU camp aren’t living in the real world3.0
  5. 1 NovIs now the time to bring back national service?0.0

Everything we scored from The Spectator