Labour kickstarts Green council divorce proceedings
Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding We do not republish articles from The Spectator. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
Read the original article on spectator.com (opens in a new tab)What we found (1)
The Spectator reports Labour ending co-operation with Green groups in 11 councils. In its own voice it says Andy Burnham has a 'track record of pandering to Islamists', and nothing in the piece backs that charge.
Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.
Smears a named person
Serious
“given Andy Burnham’s track record of pandering to Islamists”
- Why this matters
- The Spectator states as settled fact, in its own voice, that Andy Burnham has a 'track record of pandering to Islamists'.
- The impression it gives
- The Labour leader has an established history of courting extremists, so his action against the Greens is out of character.
- The context
- The article offers no example, source or quote for this charge. The same day's coverage reports Burnham saying Labour would have 'nothing to do' with the policy, and the article itself shows his party taking a hard line. The word 'Islamists' is the outlet's own label, attached to unnamed people with no evidence.
How we know
- The Telegraph reported“Andy Burnham said Labour would have “nothing to do” with the “anti-Semitic” policy”Labour set to end almost half of Green council coalitions over Zionism row (opens in a new tab)
- Elsewhere in the article“Labour has today formally begun divorce proceedings”