ITV News, on UK Politics, 16 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

PM ‘must rule out Scotland being left worse off’ after Milburn review – Swinney

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 findingSee it marked on itv.com

Andy Burnham must rule out Scotland’s budget being left “worse off” as a result of a UK review into tackling youth unemployment, John Swinney has said. With the number of 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in education, employment or training (Neets) topping one million across the UK, former health secretary Alan Milburn has produced an independent report into how to tackle the problem. While the Scottish First Minister pledged his government will “examine the full detail” of that report when it is published on Tuesday, Mr Swinney made clear that if changes in it resulted in Scotland’s funding being cut, that would be “unacceptable”.

Mr Swinney’s comments came amid – with the First Minister warning this could have “huge implications for Scotland’s budget in future years”. Mr Milburn has already made clear one of his suggestions will be for a “legal guarantee” of work, training or employment support for young people, with those who refuse to take up the offer potentially losing benefits. Meanwhile, Westminster’s Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden has stated that “there will be people in the future who will not get what they would get today”.

And Mr Swinney said it was “concerning” to see suggestions “that the review will be used as a pretext to cut support from younger disabled people”. John Swinney said Scotland had a ‘positive track record’ when it came to youth employment Credit: Jane Barlow/PA Writing in the Daily Record newspaper, the First Minister said this “would not just potentially leave those who need our help with even less support, at a time when people are really struggling, it could also have huge implications for Scotland’s budget in future years”.

The SNP leader said: “Coming at a time when the Labour UK Government has already cut Scotland’s budget for next year by £650 million in real terms, the idea that we could see even further cuts coming down the line as a result of the Milburn review would be unacceptable. “So when he responds to the review’s publication, the Prime Minister must rule out Scotland being left worse off as a result of any Westminster decisions.” Mr Swinney made his remarks as he promised the Scottish Government would “examine the full detail of the report when it is published, because all of us want to support people into work whenever that is possible”.

Former health secretary Alan Milburn was due to publish his report on Tuesday Credit: Jeff Moore/PA But he stressed that Scotland has a “positive track record” when it comes to youth employment, with the First Minister noting 93.6% of 16 to 19-year-olds are in education, training or employment, with 95.7% of teenagers in a “positive destination” three months after leaving school. He spoke out as it emerged the Milburn review could propose reducing employer contributions over five years for 21 to 24-year-olds, starting in retail and hospitality.

The former Labour health secretary is to recommend doubling the threshold at which businesses start paying national insurance on earnings from this age group from £5,000 to £10,000, the BBC reported. Meanwhile, the Prime Minister said the politically sensitive review will be a “watershed” moment, but stopped short of promising to accept its recommendations in full. He has also insisted that paying for the reforms would not mean “more money” but “spending differently” in government.

Benefits must become the backstop, not the starting point. The system will no longer begin by establishing which benefits a young person is entitled to receive. It will understand their ambitions and identify the help they need to achieve them Prime Minister Andy Burnham Writing in The Guardian, Mr Burnham promised “generational” reform with benefits as “the backstop, not the starting point” for young people. The Prime Minister said government spending will shift away from “paying for failure” and towards “investing in success”, with intervention throughout childhood to help those falling behind.

He said: “Benefits must become the backstop, not the starting point. The system will no longer begin by establishing which benefits a young person is entitled to receive. “It will understand their ambitions and identify the help they need to achieve them.”

Read the original article on itv.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

ITV News reports John Swinney's demand that the Prime Minister rule out a worse settlement for Scotland, and attributes his figures and the remarks of Andy Burnham and Pat McFadden to them. It calls the possible benefit cuts speculation, although its own earlier report quoted Alan Milburn saying some young people would receive less financial support under his proposals. That softening is minor, and the rest of the article keeps its claims attributed and its figures sourced.

  1. Drops what it reported before

    Minor

    “speculation that benefits to some young people could be cut”

    Why this matters
    Describes the possible cuts to some young people's benefits as speculation.
    The impression it gives
    That cuts to young people's benefits are only a rumour.
    The context
    The outlet's own earlier article reported that Alan Milburn said some young people would receive less financial support under his proposals, and this article reports Pat McFadden saying some people will not get what they would get today.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

What it gets right

  • “the BBC reported”

    The article names the outlet that reported the national insurance proposal, so the reader can check where the figure comes from.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from ITV News

  1. 16 Nov'Widening disparity': Finance Minister O'Dowd says Northern Ireland is underfunded0.0
  2. 16 NovUK ‘seriously underprepared’ for emergencies and threats, peers warn0.0
  3. 16 NovCut national insurance for under-25s to help tackle Neets crisis, Milburn to say0.0
  4. 16 NovSpecial portrait of Andy Burnham to feature on front page of Big Issue0.0
  5. 16 NovLeading headteacher warns that feminism has become ‘unfashionable’0.0

Everything we scored from ITV News