ITV News, on Climate, 16 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found

Greens to use Holyrood debate to force a vote on drilling at Rosebank

No framing issues found.

The Scottish Government must “draw a line” against backing Rosebank, Green MSPs have insisted ahead of a Holyrood vote on the controversial oil field. Greens are to bring a motion on Wednesday, which insists that drilling at what is the UK’s largest untapped oil field would be “incompatible” with the UK’s commitments under the Paris Climate Agreement. The motion, which makes clear it “opposes the development of the Rosebank oil and gas field”, would not be binding if it were to be passed by Holyrood.

But Scottish Green climate action spokesperson Mark Ruskell said the vote would give the Parliament the opportunity to make its voice heard on the issue. (Press Association Graphics) Credit: Press Association Graphics A decision on whether drilling at Rosebank – which lies about 130km north west of Shetland – is to be made by the UK Government. The field, together with the Jackdaw gas field to the east of Aberdeen, had previously been consented by the Conservatives, but that decision was later ruled by the courts to be unlawful.

The Labour government recently gave the go ahead to Jackdaw, to the dismay of environmentalists, who fear the impact it would have on the planet if Rosebank was also to be permitted. Mr Ruskell, who will lead Wednesday’s debate in the Scottish Parliament, insisted that “MSPs have a responsibility to this generation and the next”. He added: “We must leave behind a greener, safer and more liveable planet, not saddle our children and grandchildren with the consequences of inaction.

“That means being honest about the choices we face and taking a clear public stand against new fossil fuel exploration, including Rosebank. This week, MSPs have the opportunity to show where they stand by voting to reject it.” The UK was one of almost 200 countries that signed the landmark Paris agreement back in 2015, with nations committing to try to limit global warming to 1.5C from pre-industrial levels. Holyrood will debate the Rosebank development on Wednesday – but it is the UK Government that will determine if drilling there goes ahead Credit: Jane Barlow/PA ” width=”2148″ height=”3300″ /> Green MSP Mark Ruskell wants Holyrood to take a stand against stand against ‘further oil and gas exploration in our seas’ (Fraser Bremner/Scottish Daily Mail/PA)[/caption]However Mr Ruskell said efforts to achieve this were “dangerously off track, with global temperatures reaching record highs and the risks to human life growing”.

He added: “We cannot keep expanding fossil fuel production and expect a different outcome. If we are serious about tackling the climate crisis, we must move away from fossil fuels, not open up new fields.” But despite this he said “we have seen the UK Government approve Jackdaw, with the Scottish Government welcoming the decision despite serious environmental concerns and legal challenges”. He was also critical of the Scottish Government’s decision to approve a new gas-fired power station at Peterhead.

“If the Scottish Government is serious about its climate commitments, it must draw a line at Rosebank,” the Green MSP declared. Mr Ruskell continued: “We cannot keep talking about climate leadership while backing decisions that lock us into further fossil fuel dependence. “This week, I am urging MSPs across the chamber to put future generations ahead of short-term political interests. Stephen Gethins is the Scottish Government’s energy minister Credit: Liam McBurney/PA “Our children and grandchildren deserve better than a future shaped by our failure to act.

Vote to reject Rosebank and stand against further oil and gas exploration in our seas.” Stephen Gethins, energy minister in the Scottish Government, said: “We need to see a parallel track approach to the energy transition, in which oil and gas production is managed alongside the increasing deployment of renewables such as offshore wind, where Scotland is world-leading. “The Scottish Government has consistently called on the UK Government to approach decisions on North Sea oil and gas projects on a rigorously evidence-led, case-by-case basis, with climate compatibility and energy security as key considerations.

“And it is absolutely critical that if any new production goes ahead, then the economic benefits should be felt in Scotland and aid with the energy transition, rather than flowing to the Treasury.”

Read the original article on itv.com (opens in a new tab)
About this analysis

The article reports a Green motion on the Rosebank oil field and gives the Green MSP and the Scottish Government energy minister their own words. It attributes the claim that drilling is incompatible with Paris to the Greens' motion and states that the motion would not be binding. Nothing in the material shows that it misleads its reader.

What it gets right

  • “would not be binding if it were to be passed by Holyrood”

    It tells the reader the vote has no legal effect, so the headline's 'force a vote' is not read as a decision on drilling.

  • “Greens are to bring a motion on Wednesday, which insists that drilling”

    It attributes the claim that drilling would be incompatible with Paris commitments to the Greens' motion rather than stating it in the outlet's own voice.

  • “that decision was later ruled by the courts to be unlawful”

    It gives the reader the legal history of the earlier Conservative consent, which explains why the field is back before decision-makers.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from ITV News

  1. 16 NovIce warnings in force with motorists urged to take care0.0
  2. 16 NovPrince and Princess of Wales begin three-day visit to India for Earthshot Prize0.0
  3. 15 NovHuge waves pummel the California coast, forcing the closure of iconic piers0.0
  4. 15 NovForecasters warn of disruption as snow warning issued0.0
  5. 15 NovYellow warnings for ice issued across parts of Scotland and England0.0

Everything we scored from ITV News