Andy Burnham's U-turn on EU free movement may prove irreparable with working-class voters

Andy Burnham's U-turn on EU free movement may prove irreparable with working-class voters The Prime Minister should prioritise post-industrial Britons over metropolitan liberals, writes GB News columnist Paul Embery Sign up to the Opinion Newsletter I agree to receive updates and information about my account, the GB News Community, and related products and services from GB News. Email address Sign up By signing up you agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy and Community Rules.

Thank you for signing up! See the latest from GB News here . Choose GB News on Google - add us as a preferred source Choose GB News Support GB News Champion free speech and independent journalism while unlocking exclusive benefits. Support us The date: December 7, 2016. The venue: House of Commons. A Labour backbencher rises during a debate on Brexit and, in a short but powerful speech, confronts his fellow MPs over an issue that, for many of them, has become an article of faith.

“The status quo for free movement was defeated at the ballot box,” he tells them. “In an era of increasing globalisation, free movement has arguably been providing greater benefit to larger companies than it has to the most deprived communities.” Then, in a rebuke to his own party colleagues, he says: “There is nothing socialist about a system of open borders that allows multinationals to treat people as commodities and move them around Europe to drive down labour costs and create a race to the bottom.”

TRENDING Stories Videos Your Say The MP also aims his fire at all those seeking to overturn Brexit, telling them: “It is time to move beyond the re-running of the referendum arguments and accept what people voted for.” So, who was this bold speaker? Why, none other than our current Prime Minister, Andy Burnham. To an old school, pro-Brexit leftist like me (yes, we do exist), speeches such as Burnham’s were, during those febrile times, music to the ears.

For they showed not everyone in the Labour Party had caught the open-borders bug. There is indeed nothing socialist about free movement. On the contrary, the labour supply was once understood by most on the Left to be a market dynamic which, like all market dynamics, needed to be subjected to strict regulation, the better to allow governments to plan around employment, housing and welfare, and to prevent downward pressure on wages. Does Andy Burnham think free movement has somehow become a socialist ideal in the past decade? | GETTY The open-borders position was, by contrast, the preserve of fringe voices – anarchists, Trotskyists and the like – who were not taken seriously.

But as the Labour movement’s love affair with the EU began to blossom, that all began to change. Support for free movement began to be seen as the ultimate high-status marker, while opposition to it put one squarely in the camp of those horrible far-right populists. Burnham’s speech in the Commons 10 years ago was thus a refreshing reminder of the Labour movement’s historical position on this issue. So how depressing he has now disavowed his own eminently sensible words and is making the case for free movement as part of a broader strategy to place Britain back under the yoke of Brussels.

Does Burnham think free movement has somehow become a socialist ideal in the past decade? That everything he said about its negative impact on deprived communities no longer applies? That it is a good idea to return to a system that allows bosses to shunt workers from low-wage to high-wage economies in a bid to save on labour costs? Sure, such a U-turn might go down well among well-heeled urban liberals who will never know what it’s like to suffer the effects of wage depression caused through an oversupply of labour and whose professional status may grant them the opportunity to live and work abroad.

But try making the argument to someone from a hard-pressed corner of post-industrial Britain who experienced none of the upsides of free movement but only its drawbacks. LATEST DEVELOPMENTS Nigel Farage skipped Budget following 'physical altercation' with MP John Healey doesn’t blame Brexit for slow UK growth – Chancellor’s six biggest Budget announcements Andy Burnham's Brexit U-turn sparks Cabinet civil war as PM undermines Shabana Mahmood again It beggars belief, at a time when immigration continues to be a running sore in British society – not least because of the State’s inability to control the nation’s borders – anyone in Government should think it a wise idea to throw open our doors to 450 million citizens across Europe.

And, by the way, that figure now includes around 3.5 million people from countries such as Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq who, since Britain left the Single Market in 2020, have been granted an EU passport and would, if free movement were to return, have the right to move to Britain. One does not need to be some rabid racist or possess the powers of a clairvoyant to believe that a new influx of migrants would, in the current economic and social climate, heap further pressure on our creaking infrastructure, deepen existing social tensions, and exert further downward pressure on wages across a number of industries.

The Prime Minister might also want to consider such a development would almost certainly lead to a draining of support in Labour’s traditional working-class heartlands – just as the calamitous second referendum policy did at the 2019 general election – with Nigel Farage and Reform the most likely beneficiaries this time around. This is a reality which some "Red Wall" Labour MPs have recognised. In some cases, these MPs were passionate Remainers.

But they know any return to free movement would go down like a lead balloon in their constituencies. Burnham would do well to heed the words of Melanie Onn, for example. Onn, who campaigned for Remain in the referendum, represents Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes, where around 70% of the electorate backed Leave. Of the proposed return to free movement, she wrote earlier this week: “Freedom of movement was one of the defining issues of the ‘once in a generation’ Brexit referendum.

For many, it raised fundamental questions about immigration, contribution and fairness. These concerns have not simply disappeared.” Onn also quite properly reminded her leader that Labour’s manifesto at the 2024 general election explicitly ruled out a return to free movement. Burnham tries to persuade us that leaving the EU has made it harder to control immigration numbers. That is gaslighting of the highest order. While it is true that the number of arrivals went through the roof after Brexit, that was the consequence of government failure – or, in some cases, deliberate policy choices – and not because Britain was no longer in the Single Market.

It is, in fact, a gross insult to suggest to 17 million Leave voters their decision somehow made phenomena such as the “Boriswave” inevitable. Burnham would be utterly foolish to rip the scab off a wound that was slowly beginning to heal. There is no case economically, electorally or otherwise for a return to free movement. The Prime Minister should, on this issue, prioritise the wishes of working-class communities in the post-industrial north and Midlands over those of the metropolitan liberal class.

Anything else would be certain to cause a new and massive rupture between the Labour Party and its Red Wall base. And this time it may prove irreparable. Our Standards: The GB News Editorial Charter Opinion Donald Trump’s border chief has exposed the main flaw in Britain’s border policy Analysis Opinion How King Charles navigated the slavery question on his Bahamas visit Opinion Israel’s election won’t change the fundamentals of war and peace in the Middle East Opinion A whopping £1.75 a month in supermarket savings?

Please, John Healey, don't insult our intelligence Opinion Taxpayers could once again be left footing the bill after John Healey’s growth gamble Opinion Labour have not provided a fundamental answer to the housing crisis Opinion John Healey's Budget has kicked the can down the road and left Britain more vulnerable to future shocks Opinion John Healey must reverse Rachel Reeves's harmful jobs tax before it kills growth​ Opinion The poppy is sacred and bigger than whether you believe military action taken by the UK is right or wrong Opinion The campaign for abortion has always ignored the fact that there are two lives, not one Opinion Sadiq Khan must tell the Met to abandon DEI targets and get police officers back to fighting crime Opinion Britain cannot afford for John Healey's Budget to be another tax raid on job creators Opinion Tower Hamlets must champion Muslim soldiers instead of hosting Islamophobia talk during Remembrance Day silence Opinion If Commonwealth nations press ahead with reparations, they don’t deserve a British royal at their head Opinion The Gulf War memories that came flooding back this week Opinion As the clocks go back, it's time to ask why we still put up with this nonsense Opinion The Traitors has proven it's still the biggest show on TV - but it's time it came to an end for good Opinion Britain has forgotten how to build – it’s time to bulldoze the rules holding us back Opinion Labour has gone from promising hope to preparing us for the end of the world Opinion Britain must put slavery reparations debate to bed and focus on the Commonwealth’s future Opinion It's time to ban the oppressive burka and stop balaclava-clad thugs running rampant in Welsh towns Opinion Emmanuel Macron must take responsibility for his failures instead of blaming Brexit and Donald Trump Opinion Jackdaw approval is a victory for common sense.

Now it's Rosebank's turn Opinion ​John Healey must spare ordinary Britons from his first Budget tax raid Opinion Is the King in danger of an ambush following Guyana's demands for a formal slavery apology? Opinion Britain's welfare loophole for polygamous households exposes the fundamental failure of multiculturalism Opinion Football fans pay through the nose to watch football, not endure political lectures Opinion How dare pro-Gaza activists hijack Remembrance Day with their Palestine poppies Opinion France is burning but Andy Burnham still wants drag Britain back into the EU Opinion Labour’s bonkers branflakes tax will punish families while doing nothing to tackle obesity