Andy Burnham faces growing revolt against Rosebank as Labour donor Dale Vince warns he'll bankroll a legal challenge against North Sea oilfield
Findings are available in the analysis below.2 findings
Left out here: Drops what it reported before
The article says as many as 100 Labour MPs could end up signing the private letter, but does not say that 75 MPs had already signed it, which the outlet reported the day before. Without that figure a reader believes the revolt is only starting, when a substantial number have already signed.
We do not republish articles from Daily Mail. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The article reports Dale Vince's pledge to fund a legal challenge against Rosebank largely through his own quoted words, and it sources the court history clearly. Its main gap is that it says as many as 100 Labour MPs could end up signing the letter, without saying that 75 had already signed it, a figure its own earlier article reported. It also calls Mr Vince's change of stance a flip-flop in its own voice, a verdict word the article's facts do not carry.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“flip-flopped”
Why this matters
The outlet's own voice labels Mr Vince's change of position a flip-flop, a word about his consistency rather than a report of what he said.
The impression it gives
That Mr Vince contradicted himself without a stated reason.
The context
The article reports his August BBC statement that he dropped his opposition and that his support depended on price control (S25), so the reason is in the article, and the verdict word goes beyond what the reader is shown.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“if new drilling was combined with”
Drops what it reported before
Minor
What is missing
The article says as many as 100 Labour MPs could end up signing the private letter, but does not say that 75 MPs had already signed it, which the outlet reported the day before. Without that figure a reader believes the revolt is only starting, when a substantial number have already signed.
“was given by the previous Conservative government but was later withdrawn when a court ruled consent was granted unlawfully”
It names which government gave the first approval, and says a court withdrew it, so the reader knows how the Jackdaw and Rosebank approvals came to be reopened.