The Scotsman, on UK Politics, 29 October 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

Firefighters 'contaminating children's bedrooms' because of a lack of station facilities, MSPs told

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

Firefighters are contaminating their children’s bedrooms because they cannot shower at Scotland’s inadequate stations Concerns “huge swathes” of the nation are left without fire service cover, MSP have been told. The stark warning from the Scottish Fire Brigades Union (FBU) comes ahead of Deputy First Minister and Finance Secretary, Jenny Gilruth, delivering her draft budget in December. Holyrood’s justice committee heard concerns around a lack of funding for fire services, as well as Police Scotland, legal aid and defence solicitors.

Colin Brown, executive council member of the FBU, told MSPs that “the justice sector is creaking in every single area”. He warned that retained, on-call firefighters cover around 80 per cent of Scotland’s land mass, but added that there were “over 1,000 vacancies on the RDS system in Scotland”. He added: “That’s huge swathes of Scotland’s land mass without fire cover. “The system right now isn’t serving Scotland particularly well.” Mr Brown argued that fire services in Scotland have been “underfunded to the tune of in excess of £800m in the last 13 years”.

He added: “It’s left firefighters unable to decontaminate in their own workplace, it’s left children’s bedrooms contaminated by fire contaminants that only have come from an incident ground because firefighters can’t shower on the stations that they work from. “That should be a mark of shame on this government, it should be a mark of shame on this government.” —including their children's bedrooms because fire stations do not have adequate decontamination facilities.

David Kennedy, general secretary of the Scottish Police Federation, bluntly told the committee that “Scotland needs more police officers”, which he argued should be “a genuine sustained increase in the number of police officers available to protect our communities”. He added: “The reality is we’re asking fewer police officers every day with more increasing demands. “The trauma that police officers are facing day in day out is having a massive impact on them.

To be frank, that cannot just continue.” Mr Kennedy pointed to figures for June 2026 that show there are 16,402 police officers in Scotland. “Ten years ago, we had 17,242 - that’s a reduction of 840 officers”, he added. “When we account for sickness, absence, annual leave, training, rest days and other necessary abstractions, the number of officers actually available to respond to incidents is considerably lower than the headline figure suggests.”

Mr Kennedy told the committee that “crime is only part of the picture”. He said: “One of the greatest pressures facing policing today is the increasing demand arising from incidents that are not criminal in nature. Mental health crises, welfare concerns, missing persons and vulnerable people require assistance. “In just 13 months, police officers dealt with more 576,000 non-crime incidents. That’s an extra-ordinary level of demand. “We cannot continue to rely on the goodwill, resilience and personal sacrifice of police officers to compensate for inadequate staffing when they don’t have enough police officers.”

The committee also heard from Tracey Mulholland, president of the Scottish Solicitors Bar Association, who raised concerns about "the haemorrhaging of defence agents, particularly to the Crown and the Scottish government”. She added: “Previously it had been more lucrative to staying at the defence and that was a career that you had. That’s no longer the case. There’s a bit of a cliff-edge coming. Ms Mulholland warned that funding for defence agents, primarily through the Scottish Legal Aid Board, should increase as Crown funding also rises if Scotland is to “continue to have a robust defence system”.

Read the original article on scotsman.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The Scotsman reports evidence from fire, police and defence solicitor representatives to Holyrood's justice committee and mostly attributes their claims clearly. In two places it puts a union or federation claim into its own voice with no source: an unnamed body of evidence on firefighter contamination, and a statement that police demand has risen significantly. Both are minor, and nothing in the material contradicts them.

  1. States one side's claim as fact

    Minor

    “Evidence has found that firefighters are unknowingly bringing highly toxic, carcinogenic material back to their homes”

    Why this matters
    The words "Evidence has found" present the FBU's argument about contamination and its cause as an established finding in the outlet's own voice, without naming any study or source.
    The impression it gives
    A reader takes it that an independent body of evidence has settled both the contamination and that inadequate stations cause it.
    The context
    The only source for the claim in the article is the FBU's Colin Brown, who makes it as part of an argument that the government has underfunded the service. The article names no study and gives no response from the Scottish government or the fire service.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“it's left children's bedrooms contaminated by fire contaminants”
    • Elsewhere in the article“Mr Brown argued that fire services”

    Show it in the article

    “Yet during the same period, the demands placed upon policing have increased significantly.”

    Why this matters
    The sentence states in the outlet's own voice, with no quotation marks or attribution, that policing demand has risen significantly. This sits inside a passage otherwise attributed to Mr Kennedy.
    The impression it gives
    A reader takes the rise in demand as the paper's own established fact, not the Scottish Police Federation's case for more officers.
    The context
    The claim comes from Mr Kennedy's evidence. The article gives figures for officer numbers but none for overall demand over the ten-year period.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“Mr Kennedy pointed to figures for June 2026”

    Show it in the article

What it gets right

  • “MSPs told”

    The headline keeps the union's words in quotation marks and attributes them to evidence given to MSPs, not to the paper.

  • “Mr Brown argued that fire services in Scotland have been”

    The £800m underfunding figure is clearly given as the union official's argument, not as the outlet's own finding.

  • “Ten years ago, we had 17,242 - that’s a reduction of 840 officers”

    The police figure is given with its base, its period and its comparison, so a reader can check the scale of the fall.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Scotsman

  1. 29 OctUK Budget 2026: Healey’s standstill Budget highlights a debilitating fiscal status quo0.0
  2. 29 OctThe BBC is worth defending. Scotland has much to lose if we forget it - Stephen Kerr0.0
  3. 28 OctSNP under attack for 'appalling' drop in new homes despite declaring housing emergency0.0
  4. 28 OctMinisters accused of 'catastrophic failure' for approving gas power station amid climate and energy bill fears0.0
  5. 28 OctElectric vehicle drivers left 'high and dry' as SNP-backed scheme sees decline in charging points6.0

Everything we scored from The Scotsman