The Irish Times opinion piece, on Climate, 19 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found

Is Eamon Ryan’s optimism on climate measures misplaced?

No framing issues found.

Sir, – Eamon Ryan finds grounds for optimism in home retrofits, brewery heat pumps and electric tuk-tuks. ( “Low-carbon beer and electric tuk tuks give me hope”, November 17th ). These are welcome developments, but examples of things getting better do not establish that things are getting better fast enough. Retrofitting houses reduces their energy requirements. It does not answer whether our overall demand is falling sufficiently. Electrifying a brewery tackles its heating emissions, it does not dispose of the wider emissions in food and drinks production – particularly livestock.

Electric tuk-tuks improve urban transport. They do not establish that the world’s transport emissions are declining, or declining at the necessary pace. The relevant question in every sector is the same: what is happening to total emissions and how quickly? Ryan acknowledges that we are currently losing the race against climate change , yet his confidence that we will meet and even exceed an electrification target sits alongside his admission that the target itself has yet to be agreed.

A prospective agreement is a fragile foundation for reassurance. Prof Vittorio Bufacchi’s distinction between hope and complacency ( “Not complacent about optimism” , Letters, November 17th) is pertinent here. Hope can sustain the determination to act. Optimism can make insufficient action feel sufficient. – Yours, etc, PAUL O’SHEA, Planet Before Profit CLG, Shankill, Dublin 18,

Read the original article on irishtimes.com (opens in a new tab)
About this analysis

This opinion letter argues that examples of progress on home retrofits, brewery heat pumps and electric tuk-tuks do not show that total emissions are falling fast enough. Nothing in the material contradicts its facts, and it makes no claim about the science or climate policy that the record disproves, so it has no findings. It does not mislead its reader about the events it discusses.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

What it gets right

  • “Prof Vittorio Bufacchi’s distinction between hope and complacency”

    It names the scholar whose distinction it draws on and gives the date of his letter, so a reader can trace the reference.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Irish Times

  1. 19 NovFinn McRedmond: Greta Thunberg looks more and more like an ideologue in search of an ideology 0.0
  2. 19 NovTransition away from fossil fuels roadmap lacks clear direction 3.0
  3. 18 NovUtilities regulator denies it breached climate legislation with data centre framework0.0
  4. 18 Nov‘Inadequate’ plan to wean Ireland off fossil fuels condemned for lack of detail, timelines0.0
  5. 18 NovThe good and the bad of climate change policy0.0

Everything we scored from The Irish Times