The Independent, on UK Politics, 24 October 2026

The Independent reports Gillian Mackay's conference speech urging John Swinney to state a position on new North Sea drilling, keeping her attacks inside attributed quotation marks and printing the Scottish Government's reply in full. Nothing in the piece states a party's contested claim as the outlet's own fact, and the one line of the outlet's own characterisation, that the SNP has shifted to a softer position, is backed by the Swinney quote that follows it. Nothing in it misleads the reader.

0.0

Nothing found

out of 10

Scottish Greens urge John Swinney to say where he stands on energy policy

Become an Independent member to bookmark this article Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today. Join today Already a member? Log in John Swinney must take a position on new oil and gas drilling, Gillian Mackay has said, as she hit out at the UK Government for approving the Jackdaw gas field. The Scottish Greens co-leader, speaking during her keynote speech at the party’s conference in Inverness , accused the First Minister of “years of swithering”. The SNP has moved towards a softer position on oil and gas under Mr Swinney’s leadership following years of opposition to new fields under Nicola Sturgeon. Mr Swinney has previously said any new oil and gas field should pass a “climate compatibility test”, rather than stating his support or opposition. He said the UK Government’s decision to approve Jackdaw would provide “certainty” to workers. open image in gallery (PA Graphics) ( PA Graphics ) With the decision on the much bigger Rosebank still to be announced, Ms Mackay urged the SNP leader to oppose it. She said: “After years of swithering (the SNP) seem to be happy with Jackdaw too, or maybe not – they don’t seem to have made up their minds. “They’ve welcomed the ‘certainty’ of Burnham’s decision but don’t seem to be able to find any certainty about whether they agree with it or not. “Labour in Westminster and the SNP in Holyrood – both of them seem unable to take the climate crisis seriously, they don’t seem able to make the just transition into a reality.” With energy reserved to Westminster, Ms Mackay urged Prime Minister Andy Burnham not to let the “disastrous” Rosebank project, the biggest untapped field in the North Sea, go ahead. “But the SNP need to decide what they think about Rosebank too,” she said. “They can’t keep hiding behind Westminster – what do they really think? open image in gallery First Minister John Swinney’s stance on oil and gas has been questioned (Michael Boyd/PA) ( PA Archive ) “John Swinney needs to decide as a matter of urgency where the SNP is going on oil and gas and the climate emergency. “Are they going back to being the pro-oil party of the past? The first person to welcome Jackdaw was Donald Trump – do they really want to fall in line behind that tangerine eejit? “Are they going to turn their back on Nicola Sturgeon’s legacy, of a more responsible approach to oil and gas that followed the climate science? “The SNP can double down on fossil fuels. “Or they can protect our future generations from climate breakdown. But they can’t do both. “First Minister, we know where we stand but what about you? “It’s time to put people and planet before the profits of money-hungry corporations, like Shell, Equinor and BP. “First Minister, do you have the courage to oppose Rosebank?” A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “The Scottish Government’s position is clear – the UK Government must make decisions on North Sea oil and gas projects on a case-by-case basis, with climate compatibility and energy security as key considerations. “And it is absolutely critical that if any new production goes ahead, then the economic benefits should be felt in Scotland, rather than flowing to the Treasury. “The UK Government must also replace the energy profits levy with a fair system to protect jobs, energy security and investment in our energy sector. “The Scottish Government committed in the programme for government to publishing a refreshed energy strategy to provide long-term certainty for industry and communities.”

Read the original article on independent.co.uk (opens in a new tab)

What it gets right

  • “Gillian Mackay has said”

    The opening sentence puts the demand on Swinney where it belongs, as the Green co-leader's claim, rather than as the outlet's own assertion about the First Minister.

  • “rather than stating his support or opposition”

    It sets out Swinney's actual stated position in plain words, so the reader can judge the Greens' charge of swithering against the record instead of taking it on trust.

  • “A Scottish Government spokesperson said”

    The party being attacked is given its own answer, quoted at length, in a piece built around a rival party's speech.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Independent

  1. 26 OctBurnham to host rough sleeping summit ahead of Budget cash boost6.0
  2. 25 OctReform tells councillors to do as little as possible in first 100 days – as Farage pledges the opposite3.0
  3. 24 OctSNP says UK must rule out use of Scottish revenue for English nuclear energy3.0
  4. 24 OctAndy Burnham is a magician: he hasn’t really done anything and yet he is popular0.0
  5. 23 OctPensioners to lose £1,600 under Labour’s plans to scrap triple lock, new analysis shows3.0

Everything we scored from The Independent