LBC, on UK Politics, 8 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

, as party accused of 'big brother' tactics

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findings

Ministers have named eight official databases that could be disclosed with energy firms to prompt them to 'target' future support at certain households. Labour is granting multiple energy firms across the country to access their users' financial records, including HMRC income tax, child benefit records, property valuations, and pension records, in a movement described as a 'Big Brother overreach'. , introduced to Parliament last week.

The bill aims to ban new North Sea oil and gas licences, accelerate clean energy infrastructure, and revamp household energy bills. It aims to give households more control over their bills, with estimated savings for a large portion of gas account holders. Read more: Swinney’s response on oil and gas ‘is incoherent’ Read more: Energy company uses gas network to transport hydrogen in first test of its kind Andrew Bowie, the shadow energy secretary, accused the Government of waging “class warfare” on energy bills.

He said: “Working people did not vote for a big brother state that spies on them and sends them a bigger energy bill." Under the current law, energy companies can access fuel poverty data to determine where to target energy help schemes. However, new laws set out that they would have access to a far greater selection of customers' personal records, and shared by the Government on a case-by-case basis. The scheme states that it will "support those less able to pay, and the costs of the scheme would fall principally on those most able to pay".

According to the document, this would mean a “redistribution" from those who are not currently eligible for support but are funding the scheme, to those who are eligible for support. This would “represent a transfer from primarily high-income households to low-income households”, it added. Simon Francis, the co-ordinator of the End Fuel Poverty Coalition, said Labour’s promise to “implement a long-term plan to help households who are struggling with energy bills” through the energy independence bill was “very welcome”.

He added: "It is disappointing that seeking funding for a social tariff through household bills is the first funding option on the table." A Department for Energy Security and Net Zero spokesman said that naming the plan as “big brother overreach” was “misleading”.

Read the original article on lbc.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

LBC tells its reader that the new data powers "were enforced" as part of the Energy Independence Bill. Its own article says the bill was only introduced to Parliament last week and that the databases only "could be disclosed". Its headline also says Labour "grants" energy firms access to tax records, leaving out the case-by-case limit the body gives.

  1. Makes a false claim

    Serious

    “These new powers were enforced as part of the Energy Independence Bill”

    Why this matters
    The words "were enforced" tell the reader the data powers are already in force.
    The impression it gives
    Energy firms can already see customers' tax, benefit and pension records under a law now operating.
    The context
    The same sentence says the bill was only "introduced to Parliament last week". The article elsewhere says the databases "could be disclosed" and that firms "would have access". A bill just introduced has enforced nothing. These are proposed powers, not powers in force.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“could be disclosed with energy firms”
    • Elsewhere in the article“new laws set out that they would have access”
    • Elsewhere in the article“The bill aims to ban new North Sea oil and gas licences”

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    The powers are proposed in the Energy Independence Bill, introduced to Parliament last week, and would only take effect if the bill becomes law.

  2. Headline goes beyond the article

    Minor

    “Labour grants energy firms access to customer tax records”

    Why this matters
    The headline uses the plain present "grants" and names tax records as handed over, with no condition attached.
    The impression it gives
    Energy firms now have general access to their customers' tax records.
    The context
    The body says ministers named databases that "could be disclosed", shared "on a case-by-case basis", through a bill only just introduced to Parliament. The headline turns a proposal with limits into a completed, general handover.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“could be disclosed with energy firms”
    • Elsewhere in the article“shared by the Government on a case-by-case basis”
    • Elsewhere in the article“introduced to Parliament last week”

    Show it in the article

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from LBC

  1. 8 NovSchools to stop teaching GCSEs before Year 10 in major curriculum overhaul0.0
  2. 8 NovLisa Nandy rejects 'really crass' accusations she insulted veterans with Remembrance Sunday ‘EU pitch’3.0
  3. 8 NovBurnham vows to tackle veteran homelessness3.0
  4. 8 NovRemembrance is not just about looking back, it is about the responsibility we carry forward, writes Mike Tapp MP0.0
  5. 8 NovHonour the fallen by doing better for those still serving0.0

Everything we scored from LBC