The i Paper opinion piece, on Climate, 5 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found
About this analysis

Simon Kelner argues in a column that a planned mileage-based tax on electric cars, and the idea of recording mileage through in-built connectivity, will put drivers like him off going electric. He quotes the Budget wording directly and attributes the surveillance warnings to the people who made them. Nothing in the piece makes a checkable false claim about the climate, electric car emissions or the grid, and his argument is not a finding.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

What it gets right

  • “The small print in the Budget says: “As more people choose to switch to cleaner, greener electric cars … fuel duty receipts will decline.”

    The columnist quotes the government's own Budget text, so the reader sees the stated purpose of the tax rather than a paraphrase.

  • “This “in-built connectivity”, they say, would reduce tax fraud and make the process simpler and more accurate for both drivers and the Treasury.”

    Before arguing against the proposal, the column gives the government's stated reasons for it, attributed to the government.

  • “This may be scaremongering”

    The columnist flags that the campaigners' warnings he has just quoted may be overstated, so he does not pass them off as established fact.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The i Paper

  1. 10 NovThe counties that could face water restrictions this winter3.0
  2. 8 NovHMRC could share tax records with energy firms to determine who pays higher bills0.0
  3. 8 NovI’m tempted to give up my EV – but not for the reason you think0.0
  4. 8 NovI’ve started using plug-in solar panels – I’m set to save at least £160 a year0.0
  5. 6 NovHow the polar vortex could affect UK weather for the rest of the winter0.0

Everything we scored from The i Paper