Reform UK’s security strategy is stuck in the past
“What I see today is a world at its most dangerous since the end of the cold war, and a government posture that fails to acknowledge this,” warns Reform UK’s Shadow Armed Minister Angus MacIntyre. “Russia, China and Iran present growing threats to our national security, and internal divisions are undermining our ability to meet them.” This sweeping assessment sets the scene for the party’s upcoming National Security Review . The crux of the framework stems from Reform’s view that Britain’s current security posture is both dated in its understanding of where danger lies and cut to the bone in its ability to respond to existing threats.
These include, in leader Nigel Farage’s own words , the “threats from Russia, Iran, China and the rising threat from Islamist extremists”. Reform has declared eight guiding principles for the review, from protecting Britain’s national borders “before we do anything else” to noting that “security is deterrence through denial.” Yet few of these principles will be novel to anyone who has worked around Westminster’s national security, defence and foreign policy establishment.
Successive Conservative and Labour governments have assessed Russia, China and Iran as threats or complex challenges to Britain. Earlier this month, GCHQ’s National Cyber Security Centre publicly stated that “China’s adversarial cyber activity represents the most sophisticated and sustained cyber challenge facing the UK.” The Government is slowly increasing the proportion of GDP spent on defence and is investing in other similar measures to tackle national security risks, such as passing the vast National Security (State Threats) Act earlier this year.
Despite declaring that “the old world order is over”, the Reform framework is stunted in its curiosity for what the new world may contain. China, Russia, and Iran present significant concerns, but Farage’s interest in the tectonic plates driving global geopolitics seems to stop there. There is no mention of artificial intelligence — surely the most consequential technology of our era — despite this again being flagged by intelligence agencies and politicians from both Labour and the Conservative Party.
Reform also conceptualises the world as largely Westphalian in its order. This is a landscape where threats are traditional, emanating from capital cities in autocratic nations. China is simply declared to be a “tyrannical regime”, and the document doesn’t bother to separate the country from the Chinese Communist Party. Russia’s interest in harming Europe is noted, as is its use of “grey zone” violence. Iran threatens British energy and its Jewish community, and is labelled as the “largest state-sponsor of terrorism around the world.”
None of these labels would be out of place in a Seventies Whitehall assessment of the global landscape. But this fails to account for the reality of the current global order. Nearly a quarter of a billion people now live in areas controlled by gangs or guerrilla groups. There are numerous nations that exist more as map markers than states, with terrorist groups passing through porous regional borders, fighting wars along ethnic or tribal divides.
In South America, sprawling prisons have become incubators for a new generation of narco-gangs, which grow like parasites within existing countries, manipulating their institutions for their own ends while their leaders still attend UN conferences. How much of that money and influence, passed through the shadowy criminal underworld and washed in banks across London, helps finance the very crossings Reform cares so much about? Across the African continent, private military groups race to secure assets for foreign governments or powerful corporations, filling the vacuums left behind by collapsed postwar projects.
They sit above commodities that will be critical for Britain’s own prosperity and security. Much of this may be accounted for in Reform’s eventual National Security Strategy. After all, this document is only an opening gambit. But if the party is serious about making Britain “a confident, self-respecting and respected nation once more”, it needs to widen its assessments of the underlying forces that could undermine that reality. Not all of the threats facing Britain in the coming decades will emerge from the places we expect.
Sam Hogg is an independent geopolitics and emerging technology analyst. He previously ran a company analysing geopolitics and worked in Parliament. discoplomacy
Read the original article on unherd.com (opens in a new tab)