The New York Times opinion piece, on Climate, 17 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found

Opinion | Alarm Over an Energy Bill’s Threat to America’s Environment

No framing issues found.

To the Editor: “ Democrats, Take the Energy Deal ” (editorial, Nov. 13) misreads our political moment. Democrats ran and won in the midterms on reining in President Trump. The Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 , which you urge Democrats in Congress to pass, would give the president more freedom, and he’s already told us how he’d use it — rubber-stamping oil and gas pipelines and mines and continuing to suppress “loser” wind turbines.

He won’t use it to jump-start renewable energy (an actual, durable path to long-term affordability), but to give more favors to big fossil fuel interests. Another election lesson: Americans are wary of data centers . While the editorial mentioned data centers’ energy consumption, it ignored how the bill removes necessary public participation in reviewing potential damage to historic places, and how it enables data centers (and other projects, including drilling and mining) to be permanently locked in on valuable public lands.

The editorial also overlooked the objections of tribal nations; even with recent amendments, the bill’s assault on tribal sovereignty narrows which projects, places and harms agencies must consider, leaving sacred places vulnerable to harmful development. Widespread opposition to the permitting bill isn’t “misplaced.” It reflects serious threats to public participation, tribal rights and our nation’s conservation heritage that lawmakers must address before moving forward.

Ryan Gellert Tracy Stone-Manning Ira L. Matt The writers are, respectively, the chief executive of Patagonia, the president of the Wilderness Society and the executive director of the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers. To the Editor: As a former federal judge who spent 30 years hearing cases under the statutes that this permitting bill would gut, I find your cavalier dismissal of concerns about the dismantling of environmental reviews disconnected from the harmful consequences that would flow from this legislation.

We are having trouble retrieving the article content. Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings. Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times. Thank you for your patience while we verify access. Already a subscriber? Log in . Want all of The Times? Subscribe .

Read the original article on nytimes.com (opens in a new tab)
About this analysis

Two letters to the editor oppose the Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act and argue that it would weaken environmental review and tribal consultation. Their claims are opinion, and the material we were given contradicts none of their checkable statements of fact, so we find nothing in the text that misleads the reader. The retrieved text also contains a site access notice, which is not part of the letters and which we have not assessed.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

What it gets right

  • “the chief executive of Patagonia, the president of the Wilderness Society and the executive director of the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers”

    It states who the writers are and what organisations they lead, so the reader knows who is speaking and why they have a stake in the bill.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The New York Times

  1. 17 NovPrince William Brings Climate Prize to India, in an Electric Rickshaw0.0
  2. 17 NovThere’s a New Push at COP31 in Turkey: Electrification0.0
  3. 16 NovThe Death of ‘Keep 1.5 Alive’0.0
  4. 16 NovCarbon Emissions of Biggest U.S. Data Centers Already Rival Entire Countries, Study Reveals0.0
  5. 16 NovPermitting Bill Would Charge Data Centers Billions for Power3.0

Everything we scored from The New York Times