The headline states as fact that Andy Burnham's Brexit deal will send energy bills soaring and puts that prediction in quotation marks, but the body says only that it could and attributes the claim to a new report. Tax figures from the anti-EU campaign group Stay Out then appear in the outlet's own voice as settled fact. The body also uses the loaded word surrender for the deal in its own voice.
Headline goes beyond the article
Serious
“will send energy bills soaring for British families”
Why this matters
Puts a prediction in quotation marks in the headline and drops the hedge. The words in quotation marks are 'will send energy bills soaring for British families', while the body's own words are 'could send energy bills soaring'.
The impression it gives
That Andy Burnham's Brexit deal will certainly raise British family energy bills.
The context
The body says the deal could do this and attributes the claim to a new report. S1 says a new bombshell report has claimed it, and S2 names the campaign group Stay Out as the source of its tax figures.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“a new bombshell report has claimed”
Elsewhere in the article“Stay Out, a new anti-EU campaign group, claim some 84 per cent”
Presents the EU as plotting a tax grab in the outlet's own headline voice, with no attribution in the headline.
The impression it gives
That Brussels is deliberately taking British taxes, as an established fact.
The context
The body reports that Stay Out, an anti-EU campaign group, claims rejoining would bring some 84 per cent of British taxes within EU scope. That is the group's claim, not a reported plot.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“Stay Out, a new anti-EU campaign group, claim some 84 per cent”
“This includes 25 per cent directly governed by EU legislation”
Why this matters
States the 25 per cent figure in the outlet's own voice as plain fact. The source of the figure is named only in the sentence before.
The impression it gives
That a quarter of British taxes is directly governed by EU legislation, as established fact.
The context
This is part of the campaign group's own claim. S2 gives the 84 per cent total as the claim of Stay Out, and this 25 per cent figure is one part of that same claim.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“Stay Out, a new anti-EU campaign group, claim some 84 per cent”
“Ministers would be handcuffed from cutting taxes on petrol and diesel beyond the standard rate of VAT”
Why this matters
Gives the group's list of consequences as fact in the outlet's own voice, with the group named only in an earlier sentence.
The impression it gives
That rejoining would certainly stop ministers from cutting fuel taxes, as a settled fact.
The context
S1 says a report has claimed the deal's effects, and S2 names Stay Out as the source of its claims. S4 presents one of those effects as established.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“Stay Out, a new anti-EU campaign group, claim some 84 per cent”
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“Brexit surrender deal”
Why this matters
Calls the deal a surrender in the outlet's own voice, which is a verdict rather than a description.
The impression it gives
That the deal is a capitulation, as an established judgement.
The context
The body describes a deal and a report's claim about its effects. The word surrender carries a verdict that the body's facts do not establish.