The Guardian, on West Bank, 26 October 2026

The Guardian reports the mass expulsion of Palestinians from Hebron with named witnesses, the municipality's figure and a direct challenge to the army's account, and it calls the West Bank occupied. But it puts the killing of the two Palestinian men in a passive parenthesis with no one doing the killing, and it carries the army's claim that residents left voluntarily without Israeli defence minister Israel Katz's admission that his forces forcibly displaced about 2,000 people and would not let them return. Its sentences on the flattening and emptying of two districts also leave the force out.

7.3

Serious

out of 10

What we found

  1. Hides who did it

    Serious

    “(both of whom were killed on the spot)”

    What the words do
    Puts the killing of two Palestinians in a bracket, in the passive, with no one doing the killing.
    What a reader comes away believing
    That the two men somehow died in the course of the attack, with no identified party responsible for their deaths.
    What is actually the case
    Israeli occupation forces shot both men dead at the scene, as other outlets reporting the same event state plainly.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    Ein Deir Baha was allegedly home to at least one of the two men involved in the attack; Israeli forces shot both men dead at the scene, according to Israeli accounts.

  2. Leaves out what changes the picture

    Serious

    What is missing

    Israel's defence minister, Israel Katz, publicly acknowledged that Israeli forces had forcibly displaced around 2,000 Palestinians in Hebron and said they would not be allowed to return until what he called Hamas infrastructure was dismantled. Without it a reader takes the forced nature and the scale of the expulsion to be the municipality's claim, contradicted by the army.

    How we know

    Show where it belongs

  3. Drops what it reported before

    Minor

    “the displaced population had left voluntarily”

    What the words do
    Carries the army's denial that anyone was forced out, answered in the next sentences only by one resident's outrage.
    What a reader comes away believing
    That whether the expulsion was forced is a matter of a resident's word against the army's.
    What is actually the case
    The Guardian itself reported two days earlier that Netanyahu publicly ordered the army to clear the attackers' neighbourhood house by house, and Israel's defence minister has since acknowledged that forces forcibly displaced around 2,000 people. Neither appears here.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

  4. Hides who did it

    Minor

    “had been sealed off and the neighbourhood of Farsh al-Hawa, closest to the site of Friday’s attack, had been flattened”

    What the words do
    Describes the sealing of a city of 250,000 and the destruction of a whole district in the passive, with no one named as doing either.
    What a reader comes away believing
    That the district collapsed into rubble through some unattributed process rather than by the act of a named force.
    What is actually the case
    The Guardian's own earlier report on the same demolitions named the actor: Israeli troops levelled the neighbourhood with bulldozers.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

    “another district a few kilometres away was being systematically emptied”

    What the words do
    Writes the expulsion of a second district as something that happened to it, with the force doing the emptying left out of the sentence.
    What a reader comes away believing
    That the district emptied of its own accord, which is close to the army's claim that residents left voluntarily.
    What is actually the case
    Soldiers ordered families out at midnight and at 1.30am, as the article's own witnesses describe, and the Guardian earlier reported Israeli troops driving families from their homes.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“we refused to leave until we were faced by three military vehicles and they forced us out”

    Show it in the article

  5. Leaves out what changes the picture

    Minor

    What is missing

    Netanyahu said of the neighbourhood the gunmen allegedly came from that Israel would destroy the place and that the army would evacuate the residents. Without his own words a reader cannot see that the clearing of Ein Deir Baha was ordered at the top as collective punishment rather than carried out as a local safety measure announced over loudspeakers.

    How we know

    Show where it belongs

Every underline is part of a finding. Press one to see why.

‘It’s collective punishment’: nearly 2,000 Palestinians in Hebron displaced as Israeli forces take over homes

H ebron, the biggest city in the West Bank, had paid little attention to Israel’s looming elections until it found itself suddenly in the midst of them, a proving ground for Benjamin Netanyahu’s security credentials in the run-up to Tuesday’s vote. A gun attack on an Israeli military checkpoint on Friday in which two soldiers were killed brought immediate televised visits from Netanyahu and his finance minister, Bezalel Smotrich, whose ruling coalition is narrowly trailing with two days of campaigning left. They vowed abrupt and sweeping retribution, and the prime minister warned of imminent military operations on a scale the West Bank has not seen in nearly 60 years of occupation. Within hours, the whole city of 250,000 people . By Sunday morning, there was nothing left but rubble of an industrial area that had been full of car workshops, a big ceramics plant and other enterprises. Map of the West Bank, marking the Palestinian communities As the bulldozers were at work there, . Ein Deir Baha was allegedly home to at least one of the two men involved in the attack , and on Friday its residents paid the price. The imam from the local mosque, Fahed Ahmaro, was woken at about midnight by the loudspeakers from military vehicles patrolling the street, telling homeowners to vacate their homes immediately for their own safety. View image in fullscreen Fahed Ahmaro, who was forced to flee his home in the Deir Baha area of Hebron by Israeli security forces, looks at his house from a distance. Photograph: Quique Kierszenbaum/The Guardian Ahmaro had 30 members of his family living in his house. He rushed his frail mother and some of his grandchildren to his daughter’s house in another part of Hebron, and was on his way back in the hope of picking up some of his possessions when his neighbour phoned him. “He told me not to come back, and the army had blown up the gates to the house. I don’t know what they have done to it by now. I heard they destroyed the furniture,” Ahmaro said. “You don’t know what you have until you lose it. Now I realise how devastating it is to lose your home.” View image in fullscreen Fahed Ahmaro’s house in Hebron, now a military position, with netting over its upper floors Photograph: Quique Kierszenbaum/The Guardian At midday on Sunday, he was in a Hebron market shopping for a change of clothes for his grandchildren, uncertain how long the family’s exile would last. He had heard that the house was being used as a base by Israeli soldiers and looking up at the house, perched on the side of a steep hill, he could see some lights on but no sign of life. The Hebron municipality said that 370 families, nearly 2,000 people, had been displaced by the army sweep through Ein Deir Baha. In its official comments, the Israeli army had said that , that “civilians who wished to evacuate were permitted to temporarily leave the area”. Ahmaro was outraged at the suggestion that he had any choice about fleeing. “Never, never, never. Why should I leave my house?” he asked. Abdul Halim al-Tamimi tried to stay put when the military came at 1.30am. The 77-year-old was told his family had only 10 minutes to vacate their home. “An intelligence officer told me if we didn’t go, they would displace us the same way they have done it in Gaza,” he said. “We stood there in front of the house, and we refused to leave until we were faced by three military vehicles and they forced us out.” By the time the Tamimi family left, it was 3am on Saturday morning. On Sunday morning their home was festooned with large Israeli flags and ringed with military vehicles. The army had turned the substantial villa into its headquarters. In its statement, the Israeli military claimed that 2,000 local people were from the Jaba’a clan, from which the gunmen were allegedly drawn, and which the army claimed was “associated with Hamas”. The claim drew consternation and derision from people in Ein Deir Baha. They numbered the extent of the Jaba’a clan at 150 at most, with no known reputation for radicalism. “We are from a completely different family. We are innocent people. We have nothing to do with the whole thing,” Tamimi said. “I don’t know what they are using it for, other than maybe election publicity.” Palestinians in the occupied West Bank have no vote in Tuesday’s elections, but their lives could be deeply affected by the outcome. View image in fullscreen Wasam Sadi, a Palestinian driver, has difficulties with his vision after he was attacked in his truck by Israeli settlers near the entrance of Hebron. Photograph: Quique Kierszenbaum/The Guardian By Sunday evening, all roads in and out of the city remained closed to cars, with heavy steel barriers swung across them. The only traffic was on foot, with taxi drivers squabbling for fares. The driver of a delivery truck, Wasam Sadi, pulled in at one checkpoint with the cab windshield smashed and glass fragments in his eyes. He had been attacked by settlers at a nearby junction, he said. “It’s collective punishment,” said Hebron’s mayor, Yousef al-Jabari. “They have dragged people from their houses, and they have prevented the media from getting into the district in order to cover up what is happening. “Netanyahu and his gang are using Palestinian land to displace Palestinian people, closing the city, closing the mosque, in order to achieve their political goals.” Explore more on these topics West Bank Israel Palestine Middle East and north Africa Benjamin Netanyahu Internally displaced people features Share Reuse this content

Read the original article on theguardian.com (opens in a new tab)

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Guardian

Everything we scored from The Guardian