Al-Monitor, on Iran, 30 September 2026

The headline editorialises, passive voice hides who attacked, and allied groups are reduced to proxies.

3.5

out of 10, scored on 6 of 11 checks.

The double standard

US and Iraqi deaths are reported with named actors and precise figures, while Iranian and Iranian-aligned deaths are absent entirely, leaving the reader with a one-sided casualty ledger in a war the article calls mutual.

How it builds, in Iraq withdrawal and casualty accounting paragraphs

  1. Iraqi civilian deaths: actor named, figure given

    More than 200,000 Iraqi civilians were killed in chaos unleashed after US forces toppled dictator Saddam Hussein in 2003.

    Named actor, sourced figure, active framing

  2. US troop deaths: precise figure, named context

    Iran's allies were celebrating on Wednesday after Washington withdrew the last of its forces from neighbouring Iraq, where 4,500 US troops died in the biggest US war of the century.

    Precise figure, named actor, historical framing

  3. US service member deaths: named, counted, sourced

    Of the 18 US service members listed as killed since Trump launched "Operation Epic Fury" in February, seven died in Iraq.

    Named actor, precise figure, official listing cited

  4. Iranian deaths in eight-month war: no figure given

    With the US-Israeli war against Iran now entering its eighth month

    No casualty figure, no named victims, war duration only

  5. Iranian suffering framed as economic, not human

    The war has intensified an economic crisis inside Iran, but Tehran has retained the ability to strike its neighbours and menace ships in the strait

    Harm described in economic and strategic terms, no human casualties

The same decision, both sides

Whether a casualty figure is provided for deaths in the conflict

US and Iraqi deaths are given precise, sourced figures in the same article.

where 4,500 US troops died in the biggest US war of the century. More than 200,000 Iraqi civilians were killed

Iranian deaths in eight months of active war are given no figure at all.

With the US-Israeli war against Iran now entering its eighth month

Whether the actor causing deaths is named in the sentence

The actor causing Iraqi civilian deaths is named directly in the sentence.

More than 200,000 Iraqi civilians were killed in chaos unleashed after US forces toppled dictator Saddam Hussein in 2003.

No sentence names who has killed Iranians or how many; harm is described only in economic terms.

The war has intensified an economic crisis inside Iran

Whether armed groups' violence is attributed to a state sponsor

Iran-backed groups' attacks are attributed to Iran as sponsor in every instance.

Washington blames Iran-backed groups in Iraq for striking neighbouring countries, most recently knocking out a big Saudi oil pipeline three weeks ago.

US-backed or US-allied strikes on Iran are described in neutral or strategic language with no equivalent attribution chain.

Trump launched "Operation Epic Fury" in February

What a reader is left with. A reader finishes the article knowing exactly how many Americans and Iraqis died, who killed them, and when, but has no equivalent information about Iranian deaths, leaving the impression that the eight-month war has cost Iran only economically rather than in human lives.

Iran says it receives US response to latest proposal as Washington pulls out of Iraq

By Ahmed Rasheed, Jana Choukeir and Andrew Mills BAGHDAD/DUBAI, Sept 30 (Reuters) - Iran said on Wednesday it had received a US response to its latest proposal to resurrect the collapsed ceasefire in the Gulf, days after President Donald Trump said he had rejected it. Iran's allies were celebrating on Wednesday after Washington withdrew the last of its forces from neighbouring Iraq, where 4,500 US troops died in the biggest US war of the century. More than 200,000 Iraqi civilians were killed in chaos unleashed after US forces toppled dictator Saddam Hussein in 2003. Tehran views the pullout as a victory for its "axis of resistance" of allied armed groups, and a step towards its aim of driving US forces out of the region. With the US-Israeli war against Iran now entering its eighth month, Iran put forward a proposal last week under which the United States would lift its blockade of Iranian ports and Iran would reopen the disrupted Strait of Hormuz within seven days. Trump said on Sunday he had rejected the proposal, although Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi said Tehran had not received a formal rejection. In a post on X on Wednesday, an Iranian government spokesperson said Araqchi had conveyed a US response to the Iranian government. Iran says its plan aims to restore an interim agreement which collapsed weeks after it was signed by Trump and Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian in June. Last week, Qatari mediators shuttled between US and Iranian envoys in New York on the sidelines of a meeting of the United Nations, the first proximity talks between the warring sides since the ceasefire unravelled. An official briefed on the talks, who is not Iranian and spoke to Reuters on condition of anonymity, said the Qataris had briefed Araqchi on the US response on Tuesday when Araqchi stopped off in Doha on his way home from New York. According to the official, the sides largely agree about the steps that are needed but still disagree about the order in which to take them. Iran wants an eventual deal to grant it control over the Strait of Hormuz, the world's most important oil shipping route, which runs past its coast. Shipping through the strait has increased in recent weeks, with shippers charging high fees to brave the risk of attacks. But flows of crude oil, refined products and natural gas remain substantially disrupted. In the latest incidents, Britain's UKMTO maritime security body reported on Wednesday that two ships had been hit by projectiles the previous day. US WITHDRAWAL SEEN IN IRAQ AS DEFEAT FOR WASHINGTON US and Iraqi officials announced the withdrawal of the last American troops from bases in Iraq on Wednesday, fulfilling a plan agreed in 2024 under President Joe Biden and carried out by the Trump administration while it wages war with Iran next door. The withdrawal was celebrated by Iran and its allies. It marked an "​historic victory for the Iraqi Islamic resistance groups and honorable Iraqis, and a crushing defeat for the American project," said Abu Mojtaba al-Yasiri, a commander in the Islamic Resistance in Iraq, an umbrella group of Iran-backed armed factions. Iraq, which the United States invaded in 2003, has a Shi'ite majority like Iran, and Tehran has established broad political and military influence there. The country has frequently become a proxy battlefield between the United States and Iran. Of the 18 US service members listed as killed since Trump launched "Operation Epic Fury" in February, seven died in Iraq. Washington blames Iran-backed groups in Iraq for striking neighbouring countries, most recently knocking out a big Saudi oil pipeline three weeks ago. The US withdrawal raises "the possibility that Iran's proxies will feel increasingly empowered in the absence of a Western military presence," said Baghdad-based political analyst Ahmed Younis. "These groups may attempt to expand their role in shaping state policies and consolidating their presence within ​key institutions." At home in the United States, polls show the Iran war was unpopular from the outset. The disruption to global energy supplies and resulting surge in fuel prices have hurt Trump's Republicans, trying to hang on to both houses of Congress in legislative elections five weeks away. Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps urged Americans on Tuesday to vote out Trump's allies. "Remove from power the evil, deceitful, and violent politicians who are responsible for America’s current state," they wrote in a 26-page letter to US voters. "Make sure your politicians understand that the world has changed." The war has intensified an economic crisis inside Iran, but Tehran has retained the ability to strike its neighbours and menace ships in the strait, where a fifth of global oil transited before the war. Trump says the war will be over soon and Iran will ultimately surrender. "I don't know if they are going to give up yet but they'll give up," he told reporters on Tuesday. "They are doing very poorly." (Reporting by Ahmed Rasheed and Muayad Hameed in Baghdad, Jana Choukeir in Dubai, Kanishka Singh in Washington, Menna AlaaElDin in Cairo, and Andrew Mills Writing by Peter GraffEditing by Philippa Fletcher)

Read the original article on al-monitor.com (opens in a new tab)

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Al-Monitor

  1. 30 SeptUK PM says 'strong indications' Iran involved in airbase incident4.7
  2. 30 SeptIran receives US feedback on seven-day trust-building plan0.0
  3. 30 SeptIran appeals to US voters as American troops leave Iraq3.1
  4. 29 SeptTrump says he does not know if Iran is going to 'give up yet'2.9
  5. 29 SeptUS imposes sanctions on 13 tied to Iran weapons procurement0.0

Everything we scored from Al-Monitor