Al-Monitor, on West Bank, 17 November 2026

8.7out of 10Severe

West Bank's displaced Palestinians hold little hope for post-Netanyahu era

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findingsSee them marked on al-monitor.com

After Israeli forces pushed him and thousands of others out of the West Bank refugee camp of Tulkarem last year, Adel Darsieh held onto his hope of returning home, but it is fading fast. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has vowed no return for the displaced people from the camp near the northern city of Jenin, . He is now fighting for his political life after his party lost seats in Israel's general election last month and former general Gadi Eisenkot was tasked with trying to form a new government.

But even the prospect of an end to Netanyahu's rule is not enough to lift Darsieh's hopes. "Whether it's this government or a new one, what does it change?" said the 64-year-old. "They're two sides of the same coin." The Israeli military carried out a major operation in the north of the occupied Palestinian territory in early 2025, during a temporary ceasefire in Hamas-ruled Gaza, having vowed to root out extremists. Shortly before the election, Netanyahu announced that no one removed from Tulkarem would be allowed back.

For Palestinian families, it is a second form of displacement. The Tulkarem camp was set up in 1950 for refugees who fled or were forced out during the creation of the state of Israel two years earlier. The West Bank has been occupied by Israel since 1967. "Successive generations have lived through displacement without being able to return to their homes. If our grandparents and parents couldn't return, how can we believe that our return will be possible?"

Darsieh said. According to UN figures, the Israeli operation launched last year displaced 12,100 people from the Tulkarem camp. - 'Empty stomachs' - With the Israeli military keeping up periodic operations around the region, Darsieh is living near the camp in a modest, makeshift home with a sheet metal roof. His wife uses a wheelchair. He went to receive trays of mansaf, a dish of rice, meat and fermented yoghurt, prepared by Fazaa Kitchen, a solidarity group that serves food to the displaced.

Working from the building of the Wadi al-Hawarith charity, volunteers in orange jackets fill, seal and package portions of food in an assembly line. The group prepares and distributes some 1,200 meals to 400 families. "If we weren't cooking, families would be going to bed with empty stomachs," said the organisation's head, Hussein al-Sheikh Ali, 60, who himself is displaced. He described Israel's actions in the West Bank since the Gaza war -- a conflict launched in response to the unprecedented attack on Israel by Hamas on October 7, 2023 -- as "collective punishment".

Netanyahu's now-caretaker government, which includes far-right figures, rapidly expanded Israeli settlements in the West Bank . "Some Palestinians hope that a new Israeli government might emerge with a less extremist, more moderate tone," Ali said. "Yet the fear remains that the same policies towards the Palestinians will persist, even if the political figures themselves change." Faisal Salama, who heads Tulkarem camp's popular committee, which represents residents, called Netanyahu's decision to stop residents returning illegal.

But he held out guarded hope for an end to military operations. He pointed to how Israel, soon after the election, ended an operation in Hebron that displaced 3,000 Palestinians, which was launched after gunmen shot dead two Israeli soldiers. - 'Scale of suffering' - Even if residents could return, much of the camp has been destroyed. Houses have been razed, buildings emptied and businesses burnt down. Eisenkot, who commanded forces in the West Bank during the second Intifada, a Palestinian uprising from 2000 to 2005, has sought to appeal to a broad spectrum including liberals but has only taken some distance from Netanyahu on security.

Eisenkot backs the existence of the major settlements but has also spoken out forcefully against extremist settlers who have attacked Palestinians with virtual impunity. Beth Oppenheim, a policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said a consensus has emerged among Jewish Israelis on key policies on the West Bank, including opposition to the creation of a Palestinian state. Still, she said that Eisenkot as prime minister could be more flexible on allowing a return to Tulkarem.

"I think that given the political atmosphere in Israel today, this will be done through a security pretext," she said. "They would make the case that this is necessary to stabilise the situation in the West Bank and that having people displaced could create the conditions for unrest," she said. For Asia Assaf, 44, a Fazaa Kitchen volunteer whose home was destroyed in March 2025, political debates are far away from her daily concerns. "One cannot truly grasp the scale of suffering until one has experienced it firsthand," she said. anr/sct/th/dcp/ceg

Read the original article on al-monitor.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

Al-Monitor writes that the settlements are 'considered illegal under international law', hedging a July 2024 International Court of Justice finding as if it were one view among others. It also describes the Tulkarem camp in its own voice as 'known as a hub for militants' with no source given for that label.

  1. Hedges the documented record

    Severe

    “which are considered illegal under international law”

    Why this matters
    The words considered illegal under international law turn a finding of the International Court of Justice into one view among others.
    The impression it gives
    That the illegality of the settlements is a contested opinion that some people hold.
    The context
    The ICJ's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal under international law. The outlet's own earlier article said they were deemed illegal by UN bodies and most countries, though Israel disputes this.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    The International Court of Justice found in July 2024 that Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem are illegal under international law.

  2. States one side's claim as fact

    Serious

    “known as a hub for militants”

    Why this matters
    Describes the camp in the outlet's own voice as a known hub for militants, a label stated as settled fact inside a sentence about Netanyahu's vow.
    The impression it gives
    That the camp's residents are militants and that the camp is a recognised militant base.
    The context
    The article gives no evidence for the label. Its own text describes the camp's residents as families displaced by the operation.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“displaced 12,100 people from the Tulkarem camp”

    Show it in the article

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Al-Monitor

  1. 13 NovPalestinian teen reunites with family after month in Israeli jail0.0
  2. 12 NovPro-Palestinian group seeks ban on Israeli real-estate fair in Paris3.0
  3. 3 NovIsraeli ex-generals condemn settler violence, help Palestinian farmers8.0
  4. 2 NovDisplaced Palestinians return to damaged Hebron quarter as Israeli troops withdraw6.0
  5. 2 NovIsrael army withdraws after Hebron operation6.0

Everything we scored from Al-Monitor