The disturbing truth about Oxford University’s platforming of Jason Arday’s accuser Nathan Cofnas
Findings are available in the analysis below.2 findings
We do not republish articles from The Independent. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The Independent reports a planned talk by Nathan Cofnas at Oriel College and the protest against it, quoting petition signers, campaigners, Oriel College, the hosting society and Cofnas himself. In its own voice it calls the hosting society a branch of Reform UK, which the article's own later description says is only 'linked with' the party. It also names the society president as the inviter in the same sentence that says it is not known who invited Cofnas.
overstated affiliation
Minor
“the university’s branch of Reform UK”
Why this matters
In the outlet's own voice these words call the hosting society a branch of Reform UK.
The impression it gives
That the society is a formal part of the party, and that Reform UK itself is hosting the talk at Oxford.
The context
The article's own later description says the society describes itself as 'linked with Reform UK' (S22), and Guardian coverage calls it 'a student group that supports Reform UK' (C1). 'Branch' is the outlet's stronger word, not the society's.
“the president of the society inviting him, Vittorio Cuneo-Flood”
Why this matters
In the outlet's own voice these words name Cuneo-Flood as the president of the society inviting Cofnas, in the same sentence that says it is not known who at OURS invited him.
The impression it gives
That Cuneo-Flood issued the invitation to Cofnas.
The context
The same sentence says it is not known who at OURS invited Cofnas. The sentence shows Cuneo-Flood's office in the society, but not that he issued the invitation.
What it gets right
“This claim comes from Cofnas’ most controversial blog post”
It names where the quoted claim comes from, so the reader can see it is Cofnas's own writing and not a critic's paraphrase.