NHS and fire service warn Rayner over zero hours contracts crackdown
Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding
We do not republish articles from The Telegraph. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The article attributes the warnings from the NHS Alliance, NHS Employers and fire service bosses to their speakers and sets the Government's reply beside them. One phrase in the outlet's own voice, 'despite Labour promises', adds a verdict on waiting lists that the sentence does not argue for.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“despite Labour promises to reduce them by the next election”
Why this matters
The word 'despite' joins the October rise in waiting lists to a Labour pledge in the outlet's own voice, so the rise reads as a broken promise.
The impression it gives
That Labour has broken a promise to cut waiting lists.
The context
The sentence states the rise and the pledge as two separate facts and gives no figure for either, so the verdict is the outlet's own and is not argued in the sentence.
What it gets right
“NHS Alliance, which represents hospital trusts, said”
It names the organisation making the warning and says what it represents, so the reader knows who is speaking.
“The official analysis, commissioned by the Government, also found workers often prefer a zero-hours contract to fixed hours for the same role.”
It gives the government-commissioned counterpoint to the warnings, so the reader hears evidence on the other side of the argument.