65% of Labour voters want Government to approve Rosebank oil field – survey
Findings are available in the analysis below.2 findings
We do not republish articles from The Independent. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The Independent reports a poll commissioned by Offshore Energies UK on Rosebank and Jackdaw but never tells readers that OEUK is the North Sea oil and gas trade body, and it runs its chief executive's call to approve North Sea projects unqualified. No opponent of Rosebank is quoted and they appear only in a photo caption, while OEUK and the Conservative shadow energy secretary get most of the quotes and the last word.
Hides who the source is
Serious
“OEUK chief executive David Whitehouse said the survey results”
Why this matters
The Independent introduces David Whitehouse only by job title and lets him say the public backs approving "the pipeline of North Sea projects", with no word that he speaks for the companies that would develop them.
The impression it gives
A reader hears his call to approve North Sea projects as a reading of public opinion, not as an industry body arguing for its members' interests.
The context
Whitehouse heads the oil and gas industry's trade association. His comments in S10 to S12 are advocacy for its members' projects, and nowhere in the article is OEUK described as such.
How we know
Checked against the whole articleIt never uses the words “trade” and “association”.
Written straight
Polling commissioned by Offshore Energies UK (OEUK), the trade association for North Sea oil and gas companies, found 65% of those who backed Labour in 2024 wanted the project approved.
One side gets the space
Minor
“Environmental campaigners are urging ministers to reject drilling at Rosebank”
Why this matters
The only mention of opposition to Rosebank sits in a photo caption, with no named voice and no reason given for the opposition.
The impression it gives
A reader sees one side quoted at length while those against the field appear only as an unnamed caption, and is never told why the field is called controversial.
The context
OEUK's chief executive gets three sentences and the Conservative shadow energy secretary gets six, closing the article. No campaigner or opponent of Rosebank is quoted. Other coverage of the same poll records Ed Miliband calling the field "climate vandalism".