Middle East Eye, on West Bank, 20 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

'Collective deterrence': Detention of Palestinian student in Israel fuels fears of wider crackdown

Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding

“Mahdi has a shadow of an identity, a shadow of freedom, and a shadow of the sky.” Chanting these words, around 200 people gathered outside a court in Jerusalem on Thursday to demand the release of Mahdi Tounsi, a 26-year-old student at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Tounsi, a Palestinian resident of occupied East Jerusalem studying criminology and sociology, was detained from his university accommodation without his family’s knowledge.

They still do not know why he was arrested. “Even his laptop and other belongings were left in his room,” Maysam Tounsi, Mahdi’s sister, told Middle East Eye, questioning what evidence the authorities had against him. The family discovered his arrest only after spending three days searching for him. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters “I used to chat with him a lot on WhatsApp.

The last time I heard from him was on Saturday,” Maysam told MEE. “When I texted him and he didn’t answer, I initially thought he was busy because he is very active and involved in many activities.” But as the days passed without a response, the family grew increasingly concerned. “I reached out to his friends, who started looking for him. They even went to the police station to report him missing, only to discover that he was under arrest,” she said.

Nasser Odeh, the lawyer representing Tounsi, told MEE that Israeli authorities had issued a six-month administrative detention order against him after failing to establish sufficient grounds for criminal charges. Thursday’s hearing was postponed until 24 November because representatives of the Shin Bet, Israel’s domestic intelligence agency, did not attend. As a result, Odeh said, the court has yet to examine the secret evidence used to justify the detention order. 'This sends a message to all activists that there is no safe space, no space to express your opinion as others can' - Nasser Odeh, Lawyer Instead, the hearing addressed allegations of violence during Tounsi’s arrest and his need for medical treatment.

Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture

The Shin Bet's stated allegation. Times of Israel reports that Tounsi is accused of conspiracy to commit a terrorist act, and that the Shin Bet sought six months' detention on that basis.

How we know

Administrative detention is a controversial practice under which Israeli authorities hold people without charge or trial for indefinite periods, based on secret evidence. It is used predominantly against Palestinians from the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, and rarely against Jewish Israelis. Odeh said the case was particularly concerning because administrative detention was being used against a Palestinian university student involved in political and social activism.

“This sends a message to all activists that there is no safe space, no space to express your opinion as others can,” he told MEE. He warned that the case could set a precedent for using administrative detention against other Palestinian political activists, including journalists and members of political parties. “This is collective deterrence through a single individual case,” he said. University administration criticised Tounsi’s arrest has also raised concerns among Palestinian students at the Hebrew University, where student activists say they fear further political persecution.

Mohammad Mahajne, a 21-year-old law student and member of the Jafra student organisation, told MEE that students were struggling to understand the circumstances of Tounsi’s arrest, particularly as the allegations against him remain unclear. “Even his lawyer doesn’t know exactly what is happening or why he was arrested,” Mahajne said. Jafra is planning another demonstration on campus on Monday, following Thursday’s protest outside the court.

Mahajne said Jafra representatives had met the university’s dean of students, who promised to help ensure that Tounsi’s absence would not adversely affect his academic record. How an election defeat triggered a carnival of racism against Palestinians Read More » However, he criticised the university’s response to the arrest, saying its public statement failed to reflect the seriousness of the incident. In a statement to the university community, the administration said university officials had been informed of the police operation only minutes before it took place and that police had presented a court-issued arrest warrant.

The university also stressed that Israeli police have the legal authority to operate on campus without its permission. “No university representatives, including members of the university’s security staff, were present during the arrest,” the statement said. The administration added that police had subsequently informed it that the arrest had taken place “without any unusual incidents”. That account contradicts testimony given to MEE by witnesses who said Tounsi was beaten and forcibly removed from his dormitory room.

The university said it was concerned about the student’s well-being and was in contact with his family. ‘We are afraid too’ Tounsi’s arrest comes amid a wave of incitement against Palestinian citizens of Israel by senior Israeli politicians and lawmakers, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Three suspected hate crimes targeting Palestinian citizens of Israel were reported earlier this week, including an arson attack on a mosque.

There have also been several reports of attacks on Palestinian students in the streets and on public transport, particularly in Jerusalem. Palestinians in Israel face wave of attacks after Netanyahu's incitement campaign Read More » Mahajne warned that the arrest, alongside the growing attacks and political persecution, could discourage Palestinian students from participating in political and even social activities on campus. He said Jafra and other student organisations were trying to keep a low profile and organise activities more carefully to avoid putting students at risk.

“We are trying to reassure the students, but we are afraid too, because we don’t know the circumstances of the case,” Mahajne told MEE. “We operate within the law, but right at its limits.” According to Mahajne, most students are willing to participate in activities, but their families are often the ones who discourage them out of fear. “Parents tell their children: You came to university to get a degree and go home. We don’t want problems, and we don’t want arrests,” he said.

Despite these concerns, Mahajne believes Palestinian students should continue their political and social activities. “We have a responsibility not just to come to university, get our degrees and leave,” he said. Secret evidence Hadeel Abu Saleh, an attorney at the Palestinian legal rights organisation Adalah, explained that although administrative detention orders are subject to judicial review, the evidence used to justify them is often classified and withheld from both detainees and their lawyers.

“The judge is expected to independently decide whether a person poses an actual threat based on secret evidence that neither the detainee nor the defence team can examine,” Abu Saleh told MEE. She said this created a fundamental obstacle to the right to a fair trial, leaving lawyers to challenge allegations without knowing the evidence on which they were based. 'We're seeing the transformation of administrative detention from an exceptional measure into an everyday tool of repression' - Hadeel Abu Saleh, attorney at Adalah “You are essentially working in the dark,” she said.

“You are trying to guess what the judge is thinking, what the Shin Bet has written, and what conclusions have been presented to the court.” Under Israel’s Emergency Powers (Detentions) Law of 1979, the defence minister can issue administrative detention orders for up to six months at a time. The orders can be renewed without criminal charges being brought against the detainee. Abu Saleh said authorities often resorted to administrative detention after criminal investigations failed to produce sufficient evidence to file an indictment.

She also pointed to what she described as a sharp increase in the use of administrative detention against Palestinian citizen of Israel and residents of East Jerusalem since October 2023. According to data obtained by Adalah through freedom of information requests, courts reviewed 297 administrative detention cases involving these groups between 7 October 2023 and 21 May 2025. For Abu Saleh, the concern extends beyond the individual detainees.

She said that, in some cases, administrative detention orders were based not on specific actions but on assessments of a person’s political views, ideology or possible future behaviour, including private conversations. “What we are seeing is the transformation of administrative detention from an exceptional measure into an everyday tool of repression and deprivation of liberty,” she said. Copyright © 2014 - 2026 . Middle East Eye. All rights reserved.

Only England and Wales jurisdiction apply in all legal matters. Middle East Eye ISSN 2634-2456

Read the original article on middleeasteye.net (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The article gives a detailed, mostly attributed account of Mahdi Tounsi's detention, with his family, lawyer, Adalah and fellow students speaking and the university's account set against witnesses. The one gap kept is minor: it does not report the Shin Bet allegation of conspiracy to commit a terrorist act that Times of Israel carried, though it does tell readers the evidence is secret and the allegations unclear.

  1. Leaves out what changes the picture

    Minor

    What is missing

    The Shin Bet's stated allegation. Times of Israel reports that Tounsi is accused of conspiracy to commit a terrorist act, and that the Shin Bet sought six months' detention on that basis.

    How we know

    Show where it belongs

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Middle East Eye

  1. 19 NovHow British sanctions are already having a material impact in the West Bank0.0
  2. 19 NovIsraeli non-profit helping Britons move to occupied West Bank to tour UK cities0.0
  3. 18 NovIsraeli settlers establish outpost in Palestinian-controlled Area A of West Bank0.0
  4. 18 NovIsraeli prison guard ‘slapped and tore off hijab’ of Palestinian detainee 0.0
  5. 17 NovIsraeli settlers kill Palestinian grandmother in her home in Jericho0.0

Everything we scored from Middle East Eye