The Scotsman, on UK Politics, 10 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found
About this analysis

The Scotsman reports Scottish Conservative MSP Stephen Kerr's call to overhaul the Holyrood list voting system and his claim that the Scottish Greens "gamed" it. The article attributes Kerr's claims to him, notes that he was himself elected on the list, and gives the Scottish Greens a full reply. Nothing in it misleads the reader.

What it gets right

  • “as he says the Scottish Greens “gamed it” to get a “disproportionate” number of MSPs”

    The Scotsman attributes the charge that the Greens gamed the system to Kerr and keeps it in quotation marks, so the outlet does not adopt it as its own description.

  • “despite being elected on the list system themselves”

    The opening sentence tells the reader at once that Kerr is himself a list MSP, which is material context for his call to scrap the list.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Scotsman

  1. 10 NovScottish Labour leader backs rejoining EU in change of position0.0
  2. 10 NovWhy Andy Burnham's EU policy fails his own 'Makerfield Test' in big red flag for Labour – Brian Monteith0.0
  3. 10 NovEdinburgh Airport arrivals experience is an 'insult to a nation' and must be resolved in expansion plan3.0
  4. 10 NovJohn Swinney urged to provide clarity on flagship pledge to bring buses under 'public control'0.0
  5. 10 NovPupils suffered 'dreadful abuse' for 40 years at Edinburgh Academy, inquiry finds0.0

Everything we scored from The Scotsman