BBC News, on UK Politics, 27 October 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

DUP MLA joins Carla Lockhart's calls for First Minister removal

Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding

DUP MLA joins Lockhart's call for O'Neill's removal as first minister Image source, PA Media Image caption, Diane Forsythe said there was "immense" anger among unionists over Michelle O'Neill's actions By Brendan Hughes Political reporter, BBC News NI Published 27 October 2026, 00:00 GMT A Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) assembly member has joined MP colleague Carla Lockhart's calls for Stormont's First Minister Michelle O'Neill to be "removed from office".

Diane Forsythe said "profound consequences" pledged over the Sinn Féin vice-president's handling of the Drumcree parading dispute "must be honoured". Lockhart last week stepped down from the DUP's officer board in response to party leader Gavin Robinson not removing their deputy first minister to force O'Neill from the joint office. It follows unionist anger over the first minister's involvement in protests on the Garvaghy Road , which blocked a contentious Orange Order parade from passing along the mainly nationalist street in Portadown, County Armagh.

O'Neill and several other senior Sinn Féin figures have been interviewed by police investigating the demonstrations, with unionists accusing the party of acting unlawfully. The Sinn Féin deputy leader has defended her attendance at the demonstrations last month, saying she would "continue to stand with the Garvaghy Road residents". The political row has sparked differences of opinion over how to respond within the DUP, which shares power with Sinn Féin in Stormont's devolved government.

Forsythe is an assembly member for the South Down constituency and part of the DUP's party officer team. In a post on Facebook on Monday night, Forsythe said she was "pleased" to show her support for Upper Bann MP Lockhart at a recent rally in Portadown . She accused Sinn Féin of "arrogance" and described the feelings of anger in the unionist community over O'Neill's actions as "immense". "There have been commitments made to deliver profound consequences and that it cannot be business as usual.

These must be honoured," she added. "It is my view that Michelle O'Neill should be removed from office. The assembly and other ministerial offices would continue until the next election." Forsythe added that in the absence of such "meaningful action", official engagements as first minister through the joint Executive Office should be stopped immediately as a "bare minimum". Last week Robinson said he was "sorry" to see Lockhart quit the DUP's officer board but added that she remained "a key part of our team".

Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture

The article prints Forsythe's claim that 'the assembly and other ministerial offices would continue until the next election' without saying that withdrawing the deputy first minister would effectively collapse the Executive, and that the Assembly could continue to sit for only a further six months. Without this a reader may think O'Neill's removal would leave Stormont running normally until an election.

How we know

Speaking on the BBC's The View programme, the DUP leader said the party had reached a democratic decision on how to deal with the Drumcree fallout. He questioned whether it was necessary to "punish everyone in Northern Ireland when actually we should be punishing those who broke the law". "We have considered all options and we keep all options on the table," he added. Related topics Drumcree Carla Lockhart Portadown DUP (Democratic Unionist Party) Michelle O'Neill Sinn Féin

Read the original article on bbc.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

BBC News reports a second DUP politician, Diane Forsythe, backing Carla Lockhart's call for Michelle O'Neill's removal. It attributes the claims of unlawfulness to unionists, gives O'Neill's own defence and the DUP leader's opposing view. The only gap is that Forsythe's claim that the Assembly would carry on until the next election goes unqualified, when other reports say it could sit for only six more months.

  1. Leaves out what changes the picture

    Minor

    What is missing

    The article prints Forsythe's claim that 'the assembly and other ministerial offices would continue until the next election' without saying that withdrawing the deputy first minister would effectively collapse the Executive, and that the Assembly could continue to sit for only a further six months. Without this a reader may think O'Neill's removal would leave Stormont running normally until an election.

    How we know

    Show where it belongs

What it gets right

  • “with unionists accusing the party of acting unlawfully”

    The BBC attributes the claim of unlawfulness to unionists rather than stating it in its own voice, while police inquiries are still under way.

  • “saying she would "continue to stand with the Garvaghy Road residents"”

    The article gives O'Neill's own defence in her words, so the target of the removal calls is heard.

  • “He questioned whether it was necessary to "punish everyone in Northern Ireland when actually we should be punishing those who broke the law".”

    The DUP leader's opposing case is reported, so the article shows the split within the party rather than only one side of it.

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from BBC News

  1. 27 OctTwo charged over alleged plot to assist Iran in RAF Fairford incident3.0
  2. 26 OctBedford Borough Council speaker denies making threats to kill0.0
  3. 26 OctCare home given more time to improve - or face closure0.0
  4. 26 OctAn insider's guide to Budget Day: 'Don't fall off the kerb'0.0
  5. 26 OctLabour leader wants Worcester Greens to denounce Zionism motion0.0

Everything we scored from BBC News