COP31 climate talks collapse without agreement as EU rejects final draft
Findings are available in the analysis below.2 findings Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture
The article does not say that the updated draft dropped the call to phase out fossil fuels, nor that the EU rejected it because it stripped out fossil fuel protections. It gives only critics' view that the text lacked ambition. Without this a reader believes the draft was simply too weak, when the documented dispute was over removed fossil fuel language.
How we know
- The National reported“an updated version published on Thursday made no mention of the substances in its 80 articles”Cop31 climate talks overrun in dispute over final deal (opens in a new tab)
- The New York Times reported“rejected a proposed agreement they said stripped out crucial protections and favored countries that export oil, gas and coal”COP31 Talks Collapse in Turkey in a Clash Over Fossil Fuels (opens in a new tab)
Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture
The article never names the countries that opposed the text. Kurum's quote says only that there are parties in this hall who oppose it. The New York Times named Russia, Saudi Arabia and other Arab nations as the holdouts over fossil fuel language, so without that fact a reader does not know who blocked the deal or what the blockade was about.
How we know
- The New York Times reported“Russia, Saudi Arabia and other Arab nations might loosen their opposition to language about fossil fuels”COP31 Talks Collapse in Turkey in a Clash Over Fossil Fuels (opens in a new tab)
- The New York Times reported“pitting nations seeking to wind down the era of fossil fuels against those aiming to prolong it”COP31 Talks Collapse in Turkey in a Clash Over Fossil Fuels (opens in a new tab)
We do not republish articles from Ynet News (English). Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
Read the original article on ynetnews.com (opens in a new tab)What we found (2)
The article reports the collapse of COP31 and quotes the Turkish president's admission that no consensus existed. It never says that the final draft had dropped its fossil fuel language, which other coverage reports as the reason the EU rejected it, so a reader is left believing the draft was merely not ambitious enough. It also does not name the countries that opposed the text, a smaller gap.
Leaves out what changes the picture
Serious
What is missing
The article does not say that the updated draft dropped the call to phase out fossil fuels, nor that the EU rejected it because it stripped out fossil fuel protections. It gives only critics' view that the text lacked ambition. Without this a reader believes the draft was simply too weak, when the documented dispute was over removed fossil fuel language.
How we know
- The National reported“an updated version published on Thursday made no mention of the substances in its 80 articles”Cop31 climate talks overrun in dispute over final deal (opens in a new tab)
- The New York Times reported“rejected a proposed agreement they said stripped out crucial protections and favored countries that export oil, gas and coal”COP31 Talks Collapse in Turkey in a Clash Over Fossil Fuels (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs
Leaves out what changes the picture
Minor
What is missing
The article never names the countries that opposed the text. Kurum's quote says only that there are parties in this hall who oppose it. The New York Times named Russia, Saudi Arabia and other Arab nations as the holdouts over fossil fuel language, so without that fact a reader does not know who blocked the deal or what the blockade was about.
How we know
- The New York Times reported“Russia, Saudi Arabia and other Arab nations might loosen their opposition to language about fossil fuels”COP31 Talks Collapse in Turkey in a Clash Over Fossil Fuels (opens in a new tab)
- The New York Times reported“pitting nations seeking to wind down the era of fossil fuels against those aiming to prolong it”COP31 Talks Collapse in Turkey in a Clash Over Fossil Fuels (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs