HuffPost UK, on UK Politics, 3 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

'Do You Want To Apologise?' BBC Presenter Skewers Top Tory Over His Party's Immigration Record

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

A BBC presenter skewered a top Tory over his party’s immigration record while in office. Jon Kay showed shadow home secretary Chris Philp evidence of the soaring numbers who entered the UK while Boris Johnson was prime minister and asked him: “Do you want to apologise?” Net migration – the difference between the numbers entering and leaving the country – peaked at more than 900,000 during the so-called “Boriswave” at the start of the decade.

On BBC Breakfast this morning, Kay told Philp: “It’s because those people are now getting to the five year point of being here that they are in the position of applying for indefinite leave to remain. “You yourself were working as a minister in the Home Office when that wave reached its peak, weren’t you? Do you want to apologise for creating this problem in the first place?” Philp replied: “I did not have personal responsibility for immigration in the Home Office.

But let me be honest, that should never have happened. “That was wrong, and under Kemi as leader and me as the new shadow home secretary, that will never happen again.” As Philp on to home secretary Shabana Mahmood’s U-turn on her own immigration crackdown, Kay said: “Let’s stick with you. Do you want to apologise for that wave that happened on your watch in government?” Philp said: “I’m not going to personally apologise because it wasn’t my policy area, but I will say it was wrong and it should not have happened.”

Listen to Commons People, the podcast that makes politics easy. Every week, Kevin Schofield and Kate Nicholson unpack the week’s biggest stories to keep you informed. Join us for straightforward analysis of what’s going on at Westminster.

Read the original article on huffingtonpost.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

HuffPost UK reports a BBC Breakfast exchange in which Jon Kay pressed shadow home secretary Chris Philp to apologise for net migration under Boris Johnson, and it quotes Philp's answers at length. The one weak spot is a single phrase in the outlet's own voice that calls Philp's point about Shabana Mahmood an attempt to deflect, without quoting what he said.

  1. Uses a loaded word

    Minor

    “tried to deflect attention”

    Why this matters
    The words "tried to deflect attention" tell the reader, in HuffPost's own voice, why Philp raised Shabana Mahmood's U-turn.
    The impression it gives
    A reader believes Philp's point about Mahmood was only an evasion, with no substance worth hearing.
    The context
    The article never quotes what Philp said about Mahmood, so the reader cannot judge the point for themselves. The verdict on his purpose rests on the outlet's word alone.

    Show it in the article

What it gets right

  • “the difference between the numbers entering and leaving the country”

    It defines net migration before giving the figure, so the reader knows what the 900,000 measures.

  • “I’m not going to personally apologise because it wasn’t my policy area, but I will say it was wrong and it should not have happened.”

    It gives Philp's full answer in his own words, so his position is not reduced to the presenter's challenge.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from HuffPost UK

  1. 2 NovShabana Mahmood U-Turns On Immigration Crackdown After Labour Backlash3.0
  2. 2 Nov'Air Miles Andy': Burnham Slammed After His Plane To Caribbean Picks Him Up In Manchester3.0
  3. 2 NovSorry, Not Sorry: Is Andy Burnham About To Apologise For Britain's Role In The Slave Trade?6.0
  4. 2 NovKemi Badenoch Torched By Antigua Prime Minister Over Opposition To Slavery Reparations3.0
  5. 2 NovShabana Mahmood Set To U-Turn On Immigration Crackdown After Labour Backlash3.0

Everything we scored from HuffPost UK