The Guardian, on Climate, 18 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found

‘Phantom forests’ in Australia’s arid outback used to create carbon credits meant to offset emissions, report claims

No framing issues found.

We do not republish articles from The Guardian. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.

Read the original article on theguardian.com (opens in a new tab)
About this analysis

The article reports that researchers, in a report released by the Australian Conservation Foundation, claim some carbon credit forest regeneration projects in north-west NSW are phantom forests. It sets their findings beside the rebuttals of Green Collar, Climate Friendly and the Clean Energy Regulator, and the headline's 'report claims' attribution matches the body.

What it gets right

  • “Led by Prof Andrew Macintosh”

    It names the lead researcher and his former federal role, so the reader knows who made the claim and why they are credible.

  • “it had rejected non-complying areas that could have received 6.7m carbon credits”

    It places the regulator's own enforcement record beside the researchers' criticism, so the reader gets the scheme's response in its own terms.

  • “expressed frustration that the report had not been publicly released or published in a peer-reviewed journal”

    It puts the developer's objection about the report's status on the record in the developer's own words.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Guardian

  1. 18 NovEnergy bills in Great Britain forecast to rise by 26% to £2,166 from January0.0
  2. 18 NovTag team: dual waterspouts appear in San Francisco Bay amid stormy weather3.0
  3. 18 NovUK will miss climate targets if it weakens EV sales rules, advisers warn3.0
  4. 18 NovHugh Jackman, Rebel Wilson and 150 Australian artists join call to block Woodside gas development near Scott Reef0.0
  5. 17 NovGuardian Media Group publishes 2025/26 Sustainability Report0.0

Everything we scored from The Guardian