The Sun's headline places the £430bn total welfare state forecast beside the 8.4m Universal Credit claimant count, so the total reads as the cost of Universal Credit. The article's own figures give Universal Credit at £110.7bn a year and the state pension and pension credit bill at almost £210bn. The piece also uses loaded phrases in its own voice, such as 'lay bare the true scale' and 'massive bill'.
Uses figures that mislead
Serious
“Taxpayers face £430bn welfare bill as record 8.4m claim Universal Credit”
Why this matters
The headline places the £430bn figure beside the 8.4m Universal Credit claimant count, so the total and the claimants read as one bill.
The impression it gives
The £430bn is what Universal Credit claimants will cost taxpayers by 2031.
The context
The £430bn is the OBR forecast of the total cost of the welfare state by 2031 (S11). Universal Credit alone is forecast at £110.7bn a year (S12), and the state pension and pension credit bill at almost £210bn (S13).
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“the total cost of the welfare state will skyrocket”
Elsewhere in the article“Universal Credit alone will cost the country £110.7billion a year”
Elsewhere in the article“state pension and pension credit bill is also projected to soar to almost £210billion”
Official forecasts put the total welfare state cost at £430billion by 2031, with Universal Credit projected at £110.7billion a year and the state pension and pension credit bill at almost £210billion.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“absolutely no requirements to look for work”
Why this matters
The words absolutely no requirements put the category, in the outlet's own voice, as one with no obligation at all, and the sentence never says who falls into it.
The impression it gives
More than half of claimants are under no obligation whatever, and nothing explains who they are.
The context
The article never mentions health. Coverage of the same benefit describes the Universal Credit health element as paying people whose health conditions limit their capacity to work, a group the no-requirements figure is never tied to in the piece.
Checked against the whole articleIt never uses the words “health”.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“lay bare the true scale of Britain’s spiralling benefits crisis”
Why this matters
In its own voice the outlet says the official figures reveal a crisis of hidden scale, using lay bare, true scale and spiralling benefits crisis.
The impression it gives
The official figures have uncovered a crisis that was being hidden from the public.
The context
The release is a count of claimants and a forecast. The words crisis and true scale are the outlet's own verdict, not something stated in the figures it cites.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“leaving taxpayers to foot the massive bill”
Why this matters
In the outlet's own voice the phrase presents the five million people without jobs as a cost that taxpayers must carry, with massive added.
The impression it gives
These five million people are a bill that taxpayers are paying for.
The context
The five million matches the 37.6% in employment figure in S9 applied to 8.4 million. The only cost figure for Universal Credit is the forecast in S12, which covers the whole caseload rather than those people in particular.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“stands at just 37.6%”
Elsewhere in the article“Universal Credit alone will cost the country £110.7billion a year”