The Independent, on UK Politics, 9 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

Conservatives call for SNP minister to correct comments about Israel and Gaza

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

Become an Independent member to bookmark this article Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today. Join today Already a member? Log in The Scottish Conservatives are calling for an SNP minister to correct the record following a Holyrood debate on the government’s approach to Israel and Gaza. External affairs minister Stephen Gethins said that the Scottish Government “must ensure that there is consistency in our approach” in reference to 13 situations around the world under investigation by the International Criminal Court (ICC).

However, the Tories have said the minister has not set out the government’s approach to the other international situations. In a letter written by Russell Findlay, the Scottish Conservative leader accused Mr Gethins of attacking “the only democracy in the Middle East”. Mr Findlay had also lodged two questions in parliament to Mr Gethins asking for proof of what the Scottish Government had done in response to the 13 ICC situations. Mr Gethins did not reply to the first question, and, according to the Tories, his response to the second question did not provide any details, instead referencing Myanmar’s military coup in 2021. open image in gallery Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay. (Jacob King/PA) ( PA Wire ) “This confirms that there is no ‘consistency’ in the Scottish Government’s approach to these matters and, consequently, that your comments were false.

“Therefore, you misled parliament and, by extension, the paying public. “Worse than misleading parliament is the revelation that your government remains almost wholly fixated on the action of one country – Israel. “You use government time and resource to attack the only democracy in the Middle East , a valued ally of our country, while saying virtually nothing about atrocities carried out by despotic regimes worldwide.” It adds: “I ask – why do SNP focus on the world’s only Jewish state while ignoring what’s happening elsewhere?

“This obsessive hostility towards Israel is evidence of a disturbing antisemitism gripping the SNP and other left-wing parties at Holyrood. “Having misled parliament, I request that you correct the record, regardless of the bad example set by John Swinney who recently refused to do so after he misled parliament in relation to pensions.” The Scottish Government was approached for comment.

Read the original article on independent.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The Independent reports a Scottish Conservative letter accusing SNP minister Stephen Gethins of misleading parliament. It quotes seven sentences of Russell Findlay's letter, including his charge that the SNP's focus on Israel shows antisemitism, while Mr Gethins appears only through one short phrase about consistency. Beyond a line saying the Scottish Government was approached for comment, the article gives the minister's side no space.

  1. One side gets the space

    Minor

    “Mr Findlay’s letter says:”

    Why this matters
    This line opens seven sentences of Findlay's letter, quoted at length. Mr Gethins appears only through one short phrase in S5.
    The impression it gives
    A reader hears the Conservative case in full and the minister's position only as a fragment.
    The context
    The story concerns both the minister's remarks and the Tory charges against him. Only one side is heard at length.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article““must ensure that there is consistency in our approach””

    Show it in the article

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Independent

  1. 9 NovUK military chief issues stark warning over Russian threat0.0
  2. 9 NovRoyal Navy launches its first autonomous squadron of uncrewed boats0.0
  3. 9 NovGen Zs ‘buoyed’ by Budget but older investors feeling worse off, survey finds3.0
  4. 9 NovSNP deliberately killing working-class people in ‘genocide’, says Reform deputy0.0
  5. 8 NovNandy acknowledges ‘trade-offs’ for Britain if it gets closer to EU0.0

Everything we scored from The Independent