The Scotsman opinion piece, on UK Politics, 21 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

Labour must back North Sea oil and AI if it wants to tackle youth unemployment – John McLellan

Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding

We do not republish articles from The Scotsman. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.

Read the original article on scotsman.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The column describes the Holyrood data-centre protest as a crowd dominated by anti-capitalists, Greens and communists. One sentence then lists the crowd's demands as the overthrow of Israel, a ban on fossil fuels and trans rights, and the article quotes no chant, slogan or speaker from the rally to support that list. The rest of the piece argues its case on policy and gives the reader no other finding under the opinion standard.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

  1. Guilt by association

    Serious

    “the same kind of crowd demanding the overthrow of Israel, a ban on fossil fuels, or trans rights”

    Why this matters
    The phrase "the same kind of crowd demanding the overthrow of Israel, a ban on fossil fuels, or trans rights" ties the data-centre protesters to a list of demands that the article never attributes to anyone at the rally. Trans rights and the overthrow of Israel are placed in the same list as the crowd's aims.
    The impression it gives
    A reader comes away believing the people at the Holyrood data-centre protest were pushing demands about Israel and trans rights.
    The context
    The article quotes no chant, slogan or speaker from the rally calling for the overthrow of Israel or for any other demand on that list. The only things it says the crowd carried are angry placards, and it does not say what they said.

    How we know

    • Checked against the whole articleIt never uses the words “chant” and “slogan”.

    Written straight

    A fair report would say the crowd of about 5,000 at the data-centre protest was mixed, with some people opposing a planning application near their homes and others from anti-capitalist, Green and communist groups. It would report only the demands that the rally's own speakers or placards are shown to have voiced.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Scotsman

  1. 21 NovWhy Jack McConnell was the best First Minister Scotland has ever had – Susan Dalgety0.0
  2. 21 NovAndy Burnham’s attempt to save our young generation could be his greatest achievement – Brian Wilson0.0
  3. 20 NovReaders' Letters: Burnham has no authority to bow down before the EU0.0
  4. 20 NovWhen is Andy Burnham’s visit to Brussels for the UK-EU summit? Who is he meeting?3.0
  5. 20 NovHow 100s of journeys via Edinburgh Airport have left me with unhealthily strong views – Alistair Carmichael0.0

Everything we scored from The Scotsman