Ynet News (English), by Lior Ben Ari, on Iran, 16 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

'Wrong bet': These are

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 findingSee it marked on ynetnews.com

A New York Times investigation published Sunday named the two Iranian generals who were allegedly abducted by Israel over the past two decades, one from Syria and the other from Turkey. The first, Abdullah Saberi, was reportedly kidnapped in Damascus using an oversized cardboard box designed to transport refrigerators. The second, and better known of the two, was Alireza Asgari, who disappeared in Istanbul in 2006, sparking years of questions and speculation about his fate.

According to the investigation, Asgari was interrogated for weeks by the Mossad over a possible connection to the disappearance of Israeli Air Force navigator Ron Arad. The questioning, conducted aboard a boat, produced no useful information. Mossad operatives subsequently killed him and, according to one former senior American official, his body was dumped into the Black Sea. Asgari was a commander in Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and, according to reports published over the years, was considered one of the senior Iranian intelligence officials operating in Lebanon during the 1990s in cooperation with Hezbollah.

He had also served as Iran's deputy defense minister. For years, Asgari remained a mysterious figure whose fate was unknown. Some claimed he had cooperated with foreign intelligence agencies, while others alleged that he had been abducted by the United States and Israel. In 2024, the Iranian opposition news channel Iran International published an extensive investigation into Asgari, claiming that he was living in the United States under a new identity.

The investigation alleged that Asgari had supplied the United States with "precise and sensitive military information." According to the channel, its report was based on interviews with three American intelligence officials, a senior diplomatic source, a former Revolutionary Guards commander, a relative of Asgari's wife and three of his acquaintances. The report also claimed that Asgari had been recruited in Thailand in 2005. However, the details published in The New York Times investigation contradict Iran International's account. 'The wrong bet' and a shift toward Lebanon Danny Citrinowicz, former head of the Iran Branch in the IDF Military Intelligence Research Division and now a senior researcher in the Iran and Shiite Axis Program at the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), spoke to ynet about the new details surrounding Asgari's fate.

"There were rumors that he was in the United States or Israel. The investigation touches on an important point: Israel's mistaken assumption that Iran was responsible for Ron Arad's disappearance, which ultimately led to flawed decision-making," he said. "According to all assessments, Arad was killed in 1988 and was never transferred to Iran. Israel's mistaken assumption led to the abduction of someone like Asgari in an attempt to understand what had happened to Arad.

Because Arad was not in Iran, they got nothing out of Asgari. The proof is that, even after Asgari was abducted and killed, Arad was not found." Citrinowicz added that Asgari "was very close to Hezbollah, and they probably assumed that, even if Iran was not responsible for the incident, his connections to Hezbollah might provide the information." "Clearly, that was not enough, because Ron Arad is still not in our hands, and Israel carried out operations to search for his remains just recently, during the latest war.

That indicates that Asgari himself was the wrong bet." The second abducted Iranian general mentioned in The New York Times investigation, Abdullah Saberi, was taken from Syria in 2021. An article published that year by Iran International cited a report in the Arabic edition of The Independent, claiming that "the Mossad abducted a Revolutionary Guards member named Saberi in Syria several months ago and brought him to Tel Aviv to obtain information about Ron Arad.

However, when they failed to obtain reliable intelligence, the man was transferred to South Africa and released." At the time, it was also alleged that the Mossad had abducted Saberi using a vehicle while he was traveling from his home to the Iranian Embassy in Damascus. The account published by The New York Times, however, describes an entirely different operation. According to the investigation, Saberi had left his apartment for a morning jog on the day of his abduction.

While he was running, two men posing as movers passed him carrying a refrigerator inside an oversized cardboard box. Suddenly, they attacked him, forced him into the box and loaded it into a vehicle. The investigation reported that the Mossad later abandoned Saberi on a street in Johannesburg, South Africa, leaving him with a small amount of money and a telephone number to call the Iranian Embassy and ask to be collected. In October 2025, an X account in Persian attributed to the Mossad published a post claiming that the Israeli intelligence agency had indeed abducted Saberi.

"A few details you may not have known about Abdullah Saberi," the post read. "As part of his duties, he lived in the Al-Mazzeh neighborhood. We knew exactly where he lived, and we even took him on a little trip. Perhaps later we'll tell you more about the trip and the things Saberi told us along the way. He turned out to be quite a talker! Ask him yourself, and he'll tell you exactly what kind of trip we arranged for him." The abduction has never been officially confirmed.

A new focus on Lebanon Another figure mentioned in The New York Times investigation is Ahmad Shukr, a former senior Lebanese officer who was reportedly abducted by the Mossad on Lebanese soil in late 2025, according to Lebanese and other Arab media reports. Shukr had already been linked in those reports to the possible circumstances of Ron Arad's disappearance. Israel did not comment on the reports of his alleged abduction at the time and has not done so since.

If Israel was indeed responsible for Shukr's disappearance, it would represent a turning point in the intelligence effort to locate Arad. Until then, Israel had focused on the theory that Iran or Hezbollah was behind the missing navigator's disappearance. According to The New York Times, the Mossad subsequently began turning its attention to Nabi Sheet, the last location where Arad was known with certainty to have been held. One of the few people who had been involved in guarding Arad and knew his whereabouts in 1988 was Shukr, a retired Lebanese security officer.

Lebanese sources continue to believe that he was abducted by Israeli agents. Shukr's current whereabouts remain unknown, but Israeli officials told The New York Times that Israel's leading theory, which now guides its search for an explanation of Arad's disappearance, is that he was executed in revenge for the death of Shukr's brother. Shukr's brother had fought Israeli troops in 1988, and Shukr himself was reportedly present on the night in question.

Three months after Shukr's reported abduction, in March 2026, IDF forces entered Nabi Sheet in an attempt to locate Arad's remains. Dozens of Lebanese people were killed during the raid. The forces conducted excavations in the area, including opening and digging at a specific grave in the local cemetery. However, they apparently found nothing, at least so far. The search has continued since then, but with a clear shift in focus: Lebanon, rather than Iran

Read the original article on ynetnews.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The headline states as fact that the Mossad kidnapped two Iranian generals, though the body calls both abductions allegations and says the Saberi abduction has never been officially confirmed. The body itself reports the New York Times investigation's details with attribution.

  1. Headline goes beyond the article

    Serious

    “the Iranian generals the Mossad kidnapped in Damascus and Istanbul”

    Why this matters
    The headline states as fact that the Mossad kidnapped two named Iranian generals in Damascus and Istanbul. It drops the word allegedly that the body uses about both abductions.
    The impression it gives
    That Israel's Mossad kidnapped both generals and that this is established.
    The context
    The body says both men were allegedly abducted by Israel, citing the New York Times investigation, and says the Saberi abduction has never been officially confirmed.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“were allegedly abducted by Israel over the past two decades”
    • Elsewhere in the article“The abduction has never been officially confirmed”

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    The New York Times names two Iranian generals it says Israel allegedly abducted, one from Syria and one from Turkey.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Ynet News (English)

  1. 16 NovIran warns of most severe gas shortages ever this winter due to war damage, worry about public mood3.0
  2. 16 NovThree US carrier strike groups, 50,000 troops: Washington ramps up pressure on Iran0.0
  3. 15 NovIran claims two tankers hit mines in Hormuz, releases unverified video0.0
  4. 15 NovReport: Israel kidnapped and interrogated Iranian generals in search for Ron Arad3.0
  5. 15 NovNo money, just revenge: Israeli arrested after allegedly offering to spy for Iran for free6.0

Everything we scored from Ynet News (English)