The collapse of Cop31 reveals an uncomfortable truth about climate change
Findings are available in the analysis below.2 findings
We do not republish articles from The Telegraph. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The Telegraph reports the collapse of the Cop31 talks with the right parties named as objectors to the draft, but in its own voice it uses three loaded phrases: naked self-interest for Saudi Arabia's objections, imperious and tin-eared for richer nations' demands, and all-out attack for the push to name fossil fuels in the text. These are minor and do not change the account of what happened at the talks.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“imperious and frequently tin-eared demand”
Why this matters
Labels the richer nations' demand imperious and tin-eared in the writer's own voice.
The impression it gives
That richer nations are making an arrogant and insensitive demand, and that this is established rather than the writer's view.
The context
The demand is presented as the writer's characterisation, with its tone given as a verdict rather than as a quoted or sourced position.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“all-out attack”
Why this matters
Describes the push to address fossil fuels in the text as an all-out attack in the outlet's own voice.
The impression it gives
That the fossil fuel language was a hostile assault on oil producers rather than a negotiating position.
The context
Coverage reports the EU and Pacific states pushing for fossil fuels to be addressed in the text, a negotiating position that the phrase recasts as hostility.
What it gets right
“Britain and EU nations raised objections”
It names the parties that objected to the draft, the states whose rejection the other reports on the collapse also describe.