‘Distorted, misleading, and disingenuous’: IDF publishes full response to ‘NAZA’ film

The Israel Defense Forces on Thursday published a 10-page English response to the film “NAZA,” which is centered on allegations that Israel intentionally killed tens of thousands of civilians in the Gaza Strip using artificial intelligence, among a slew of other war crimes, after a military representative was finally able to view the documentary almost three weeks after it premiered. In response, the military said the film “presents a distorted, misleading and disingenuous picture of the IDF’s target planning and striking process” and that its narrative is “based on substantial factual errors stemming from manipulative misrepresentations of reality.” The military said that contrary to the film’s claims, the “binding IDF directives explicitly, comprehensively and clearly distinguish between military operatives and uninvolved civilians in Gaza,” and that the processes for attacks “are fundamentally based on this distinction, prohibit intentionally directing strikes against civilians, and require mitigating the possibility of harm to them to the greatest extent feasible.” The IDF said that it “has never planned, approved or carried out any strike in Gaza in which 500 civilians or anything close to that number were expected to be killed,” an allegation brought up in the film, adding, “nor has anyone seriously alleged that an IDF strike caused deaths on that scale or anything close to it.” On claims of using AI to selects targets and approve strikes, the IDF said, “artificial intelligence has never independently selected targets to strike in the IDF,” and “the identification of targets to strike is done only by authorized intelligence officers, strikes are planned by relevant professionals, and the decision whether to strike is made by operational commanders.” The military also said its directives “have never granted automatic authorization for strikes against targets placing a fixed number of civilians at risk,” such as 20 civilians in an attack on a junior operative or 200 civilians in an attack on a senior commander, as claimed in the film. Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email and never miss our top stories Newsletter email address Get it By signing up, you agree to the terms On Lavender, described in the film as a tool used by the IDF to identify Hamas members and recommend them for strikes, the military said that Lavender “is not a database of targets approved to strike, but a database that assists intelligence analysts.” Related: Times of Israel analysis: NAZA’s claims about IDF conduct in Gaza are grave. So are the film’s journalistic flaws On claims that the IDF carried out strikes in areas after issuing evacuation warnings, even if civilians were still there, the military said that its directives “do not permit an evacuation warning for an area to be treated as authorization to carry out strikes there while disregarding civilians who remain.” Advertisement The IDF said that, contrary to claims made in the film, it “does not ignore the aftermath of its strikes but acts to assess them, including with regard to unintended civilian harm,” adding that “these assessments have prompted reviews of hundreds of incidents during the hostilities and provide a basis for lessons learned.” “Had the filmmakers conducted adequate verification and corroboration of facts in good faith, as professional standards require, they could have identified the substantial errors presented in the film. The end result shows that they did not,” the military said. The IDF said that many errors in the film arise because “the interviewees, described as having served in IDF intelligence roles, usually refer to only limited, initial stages dealing with intelligence, rather than the much broader process of planning and approving strikes.” “That [broader] process is not the responsibility of intelligence, but of operational bodies that manage and carry out targeting processes. Accordingly, it is apparent that in various cases interviewees raise speculation and assumptions without a factual basis,” the military said. Directors Rachel Szor, left, and Yuval Abraham, winners of the special jury prize for the film ‘NAZA,’ pose for photographers at the awards photo call during the closing ceremony of the 83rd edition of the Venice Film Festival in Venice, Italy, on September 12, 2026. (Scott A Garfitt/Invision/AP) The IDF accused the filmmakers of not showing “many of the other individuals involved in the full targeting process,” including those “responsible for planning that mitigates civilian harm, legal advisers who review proposed strikes, and commanders responsible for approving or rejecting them.” “To fit the narrative the film seeks to promote, the filmmakers also omit context essential to understanding the war in Gaza and the IDF’s conduct during it,” the military said, adding that the film “does not give due weight to Israel’s security reasons for operating in Gaza and the October 7 massacre; to Hamas’s deliberate strategy of embedding itself within the civilian population, which is the root cause of harm to civilians; or the countless actions and methods the IDF employed to mitigate civilian harm, including warnings before strikes, selection of munitions and appropriate strike planning, facilitating humanitarian aid and more.” Advertisement The IDF also said that “particularly troubling is the film’s further distortion of reality through manipulative editing of interviews, irresponsible allusions to historical atrocities, and its false and baseless attribution of malicious intentions to the IDF.” On the title of the film, “NAZA,” a Hebrew acronym meaning collateral damage, the IDF said that “this is a professional term used by every law-abiding military worldwide to describe incidental harm to civilians resulting from a strike on a military objective, which serves commanders to assess the lawfulness of the strike and adopt measures to mitigate harm to civilians to the greatest extent feasible.” “Paradoxically, the film portrays the exceptional effort and detail the IDF devotes to estimating civilian harm in strikes as indifference to civilian lives,” the military said. The IDF noted that several interviewees describe “the moral weight that comes from the participation in targeting procedures.” “That weight is real, and the IDF does not dismiss it: decisions that may cost civilian lives are among the hardest soldiers and commanders face, and the IDF expects its soldiers to feel that weight and act accordingly. Yet that moral burden is not evidence that decisions were unlawful or indifferent to civilian lives; it reflects the seriousness with which they were made,” the army said. “The tragic consequences of wars do not justify distorting the facts. Serious discussion of civilian harm requires a serious account of how decisions were actually made,” the military said, adding that “the film does not provide one.” “Instead, it offers a simplistic manifesto driven by a clear agenda. It seeks to create the impression that the IDF acts in an inhumane manner. In reality, the filmmakers can create that impression only by distorting facts, omitting essential context, ignoring previous IDF publications and explanations, and adding emotional manipulation and scripted effects,” the military said. “The IDF has acted and continues to act humanely, even if the filmmakers have done everything they can to conceal that fact.” The IDF said it is “open to hearing genuine criticism of its conduct and attaches importance to learning from substantiated allegations and continually improving its practices,” and that it is “bound by and committed to international humanitarian law, its operational procedures are designed to implement those legal obligations, and it operates dedicated units and mechanisms to mitigate civilian harm.” Advertisement The military said it does not “disavow deficiencies and errors that occurred during the war; they do occur in complex combat situations,” and suspected war crimes or violations of army protocol “are examined and, where warranted, addressed through disciplinary action, criminal investigation or other measures.” The IDF lastly accused the filmmakers of not following proper journalistic practice by submitting their allegations to the IDF for examination and response before publication, “nor did they provide a copy of the film after its screening, although the IDF requested it.” “Therefore, in assessing the film’s contents, the IDF relied on a detailed breakdown compiled by a [military] representative who attended a public screening, as well as other public accounts,” the military added. The IDF also published a 17-page Hebrew-language response to the film . Help us report truthfully on social media As a multimedia journalist, my job is to take the quality, fact-based journalism produced by The Times of Israel newsroom and make it accessible across every platform — from Instagram posts to podcasts to short-form videos. This is how many, especially young people, consume news these days. But misinformation is rampant on social media. Our team at ToI produces accurate, responsible short-form reporting on Israel and the Jewish world. If you believe in the importance of factual social media journalism , please consider joining our reader support group, The Times of Israel Community. Your financial support is essential to sustain responsible multimedia reporting. — Gabriella Jacobs, multimedia journalist Support our work Support our work Already a member? Sign in to stop seeing this You're a dedicated reader We’re really pleased that you’ve read X Times of Israel articles in the past month. That’s why we started the Times of Israel - to provide discerning readers like you with must-read coverage of Israel and the Jewish world. So now we have a request. Unlike other news outlets, we haven’t put up a paywall. But as the journalism we do is costly, we invite readers for whom The Times of Israel has become important to help support our work by joining The Times of Israel Community. For as little as $6 a month you can help support our quality journalism while enjoying The Times of Israel AD-FREE , as well as accessing exclusive content available only to Times of Israel Community members. Thank you, David Horovitz, Founding Editor of The Times of Israel Join Our Community Join Our Community Already a member? Sign in to stop seeing this Most Popular 1 Copilot subdued after stabbing pilot in alleged attempt to crash plane full of Israelis 2 Op-ed Unprecedented: Extraordinary heroism and near-miraculous circumstances avert an airplane catastrophe 3 Safely home Hailing pilot and three Israeli heroes, passengers say midair ‘miracles’ thwarted alleged attempt to crash plane 4 ‘Immense courage and resolve’: Pilot feted for crucial role in saving the lives of all aboard flydubai 1073 5 Passengers laud ‘heroism’ of Israelis who subdued flydubai flight attacker, as videos show moments of fear 6 More heavy hitters in US Jewish establishment joining J Street in sign of changing times 7 Analysis ‘It’s bad’: In a polarized Israel, the likeliest election result is more uncertainty 8 Analysis Israel maintains unique air security arrangements, but flydubai incident shows vulnerabilities read more: Israel & the Region IDF Israel Defense Forces NAZA AI artificial intelligence Gaza Strip 2023-2025 Israel-Hamas war If you’d like to comment, join The Times of Israel Community. JOIN THE TOI COMMUNITY Already a member? Log in here close popup Sign in or Join The Times of Israel Community Sign in or Register Paying ToI Community members are invited to comment on articles Email address * Please use the following structure: [email protected] Continue Or Continue with By joining you agree to the terms and conditions Send me The Times of Israel Daily Edition back close popup Register to continue Email address * Change REGISTER Or Continue with back close popup Log in to continue Email address * Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.. Continue back close popup Sign in or Join The Times of Israel Community Sign in or Register You are currently registered. Please join The Times of Israel Community to comment and enjoy other Community benefits Only ToI Community members can comment below articles Email address * Password * Incorrect password. Please try again or choose an option below. Forgot your password? / Send me a login link Continue Sign in without joining Or Continue with close popup Check your email We sent an email to you at . It has a link that will sign you in. Click the link in that email to complete registration so you can comment. back close popup Join The