Risk of another 'devastating' crash unless Network Rail brings all infrastructure work in-house - RMT
Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture
The article reports only that the sheriff found Carillion failed to follow the design. It never says she also found that Network Rail had 'failed to ensure' the drain was built properly and in line with the drawings, and had failed to ensure it received the 'as built' drawings. It also leaves out that Network Rail was fined £6.7 million in 2023 after admitting health and safety failings. Without these facts a reader believes the sheriff placed the failure on the contractor alone, and reads Network Rail's statement on its assurance measures with no knowledge of its own established failings.
How we know
- Daily Mail reported“The sheriff also said Network Rail had ‘failed to ensure’ the drain was constructed properly and in line with the drawings.”'Avoidable': How an incorrectly built drain led to deadly rail crash that claimed three lives (opens in a new tab)
- Daily Mail reported“A criminal prosecution led to Network Rail being fined £6.7million in 2023 after it admitted health and safety failings.”'Avoidable': How an incorrectly built drain led to deadly rail crash that claimed three lives (opens in a new tab)
We do not republish articles from The Scotsman. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
Read the original article on scotsman.com (opens in a new tab)What we found (1)
The Scotsman reports the RMT's call for Network Rail to bring infrastructure work in-house after the Carmont fatal accident inquiry, attributes the union's warning in its headline, and names the three men who were killed. It reports only the sheriff's finding against the contractor Carillion and leaves out her finding that Network Rail itself failed to ensure the drain was built properly, so a reader may believe the sheriff blamed the contractor alone.
Leaves out what changes the picture
Serious
What is missing
The article reports only that the sheriff found Carillion failed to follow the design. It never says she also found that Network Rail had 'failed to ensure' the drain was built properly and in line with the drawings, and had failed to ensure it received the 'as built' drawings. It also leaves out that Network Rail was fined £6.7 million in 2023 after admitting health and safety failings. Without these facts a reader believes the sheriff placed the failure on the contractor alone, and reads Network Rail's statement on its assurance measures with no knowledge of its own established failings.
How we know
- Daily Mail reported“The sheriff also said Network Rail had ‘failed to ensure’ the drain was constructed properly and in line with the drawings.”'Avoidable': How an incorrectly built drain led to deadly rail crash that claimed three lives (opens in a new tab)
- Daily Mail reported“A criminal prosecution led to Network Rail being fined £6.7million in 2023 after it admitted health and safety failings.”'Avoidable': How an incorrectly built drain led to deadly rail crash that claimed three lives (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs